Buster Faulkner looks like the kind of rising offensive mind who will get a head-coaching job soon, and that’s exactly why the Florida State conversation matters. The 45-year-old coordinator is running the best offense in the country, and it’s no surprise his name is already floating around for future openings.
One of those openings could come about 130 miles northwest of Gainesville, where Florida State is expected to fire Mike Norvell eventually. That has already sparked talk about Faulkner taking over in Tallahassee. It would be a big swing for the Seminoles, and it would also yank a top coach away from Florida’s orbit.
But that’s where the fit gets messy. Faulkner should think hard before stepping into that situation.
Florida State still carries the weight of its history. Since Bobby Bowden arrived in 1976, the program has won multiple national titles, produced multiple Heisman Trophy winners and stacked up a 14-year run of top-5 finishes from 1987 to 2000. That’s the standard people still associate with the Seminoles.
The problem is that’s not the program Faulkner would actually inherit.
Right now, Florida State is in a rough place from top to bottom. The athletic director is gone, and Norvell has overseen a decline marked by poor coaching hires, bad recruiting and a general lack of aptitude in all elements of running a football program. Fundraising is down, and the program is trying to stay viable for the next wave of conference realignment.
That isn’t just a harsh opinion from the outside, either. People much closer to the program have been saying the same thing.
A quick turnaround is possible in college football, and Florida is proof of that. Sumrall is changing things quickly, and Florida’s broader athletic picture is in a much better spot.
The men’s basketball team won a national championship in 2024, and Gators baseball was a runner-up in 2023 and a CWS semifinalist in 2024. The football program had underachieved, and the new voice has already mattered.
Tallahassee would be a different kind of job entirely. It would be a rebuild from the studs up, and that’s a big ask in the NIL and transfer portal era.
The roster can change fast, but only if the infrastructure is sound. At Florida State, it isn’t.
There’s no clear vision or direction, and the recent history says as much. Willie Taggart was handed a bare room and lasted 21 games before being fired.
Norvell followed and is on track to have his fifth losing season in Tallahassee since taking over in 2020. If the administration could move on from him right now, it would.
Faulkner would probably get patience there, but Florida State has already shown it can be patient to a fault. That has not produced results, and the program still has to deal with a buyout between $40-50 million for Norvell while trying to raise more money from boosters who are tired of pouring in cash and getting little back.
Timing changes everything. Ten years ago, Faulkner probably would have jumped at the chance. Now, with Florida State struggling to adjust to the realities of modern college football, it looks like a brutal first head-coaching landing spot - even for someone with as much upside as Faulkner.
In Other News...
Florida State Has A Growing QB Concern At The Worst Time
Florida State does not need another distraction at quarterback, but the early part of the season has made that almost impossible to avoid. Around the sport, several other college passers are trying to settle in and find traction, with LaNorris Sellers, Jayden Maiava, Marcel Reed and Ashton Daniels all under the microscope as their teams work through uneven starts and look for cleaner play in the weeks ahead.
For the Seminoles, that broader quarterback turbulence only sharpens the focus on their own situation. Passing efficiency, turnovers and decision-making matter even more now, and the concern is whether Florida State can get steadier play before the schedule tightens further. There is still time for the position to settle, but the window is narrowing and the next stretch will say plenty about whether the Seminoles can keep this from becoming a bigger problem. [Read more 🡒]
Jameis Winstons Giants Role Just Got More Complicated
Jameis Winston is back in a starting quarterback role with the New York Giants after Jaxson Darts injury changed the depth chart, and for now he has the kind of opportunity he has been chasing. For a player whose NFL journey has always seemed to come with extra turns, the Giants latest move only adds another layer to a quarterback room that is suddenly much less settled than it looked a short time ago.
The twist came with New Yorks trade for JJ McCarthy, a move that gives the team another young arm to develop while Winston tries to steady the offense in the present. Winston has spoken confidently about handling the starting job and about helping McCarthy grow, but the timing makes this a tricky stretch for everyone involved, with the Giants balancing immediate needs against whatever they believe the next phase at quarterback should look like. [Read more 🡒]
Florida State Defense Just Created A Bigger Virginia Concern
Florida States defense is heading into the Virginia matchup with a clear message from coordinator Tony White: the emphasis wont be on chasing the quarterback. Even with Virginia showing balanced offensive production and strong play at the position, White said the Seminoles are looking elsewhere for their answers, which says plenty about how they want to shape this game on the back end and in the run fit.
White also admitted the bigger issue has been Florida States own uneven execution of defensive calls, a point Virginia can study now that his remarks were made publicly available. For a Cavaliers offense trying to build a plan, that kind of candor is useful information, especially when the Seminoles are signaling a different priority than the one opponents might expect. [Read more 🡒]