Florida State may have found a backup quarterback who is actually built to survive the job.
Malachi Marshall arrived in the summer as a JuCo transfer, and after a fast offseason he’s now in the mix to beat out second-year quarterback Kevin Sperry for the No. 2 spot behind starter Ashton Daniels. The biggest development: Marshall has added 18 pounds, according to Mike Norvell’s first game-week press conference on Monday in Tallahassee. He was listed at 168 pounds on the initial FSU roster after being listed at 6-foot-2, 170 pounds last season at Iowa Western.
That kind of frame was always going to be a problem in the Power 4. Even now, Marshall would still be on the light side for an ACC quarterback, but Norvell said he has “he’s put himself in a position to play,” pointing not only to his fall camp but also to the added strength he’s built to handle hits if he gets thrown into action this year. The remaining hurdle is the mental side - getting comfortable enough with the offense to actually run it.
Sperry, meanwhile, hasn’t done enough to make this a locked-in competition. Last season he went 12-17 for 194 yards and two touchdowns across three games against East Texas A&M, Kent State, and Stanford.
Florida State lost to Stanford, and Sperry’s QBR in those appearances was 43.9. That résumé didn’t slam the door on the depth chart, and it helped push Norvell and general manager John Garrett to bring in both Daniels and Marshall.
Marshall’s case is straightforward. He led Iowa Western to a national championship last year, and he brings arm talent, movement ability, and the kind of upward physical trend that often comes when a player jumps into better training and nutrition. His route to Florida State has been a winding one - Stony Brook to Iowa Western and now to Tallahassee - but he’s shown enough on the field and in camp to stay in the conversation.
The question is whether he can learn the offense fast enough. That matters, but Sperry’s edge there may not be as large as it looks.
With Gus Malzahn as the offensive coordinator last offseason, Sperry’s advantage amounts to about one spring, not some massive head start. Marshall has enough experience, even at the JuCo level, to close that gap if the rest keeps coming together.
And that’s where Norvell’s track record hangs over this whole thing. In six years at Florida State, he hasn’t developed a homegrown quarterback into the answer.
That’s why it’s hard to assume Sperry will suddenly be the exception. If Daniels goes down, or if Florida State needs someone in a blowout in Week 0, Marshall looks like the better bet to take the snaps.
In Other News...
Mike Norvell Just Gave Florida State Fans Another Reason To Groan
Mike Norvell is already asking Florida State fans to adjust to one notable change for 2026: the Seminoles will not release depth charts during game weeks, including for the Week 0 matchup against New Mexico State. Norvell has still identified Ashton Daniels as the starting quarterback, but beyond that, the usual lineup guide that helps frame a game week will not be part of the routine.
The move is unusual in college football and has not gone over smoothly with fans or the media, which is hardly surprising for a program that lives under a microscope every season. Depth charts do not decide games, but they do help set expectations and cut through uncertainty, so leaving that information out only adds another layer of frustration around a team that already has plenty of eyes on it. [Read more 🡒]
Mike Norvells Quarterback Problem At FSU Just Got Harder To Ignore
Mike Norvells quarterback track record at Florida State has become one of the more glaring storylines of his tenure, and it goes beyond any one season. The Seminoles have spent years trying to recruit and develop the position at a higher level, only to watch several of the most highly touted additions either fall short of expectations or move on before finding traction. Luke Kromenhoek, the highest-ranked quarterback recruit Norvell has brought in, ended up transferring twice and later lost a starting competition at South Florida, a reminder of how unsettled the position has been.
Since 2020, Florida State has signed a string of blue-chip quarterbacks, but the return on that investment has been thin, with limited starts and little sustained success to show for it. The result has been a program that has repeatedly leaned on transfer quarterbacks to open seasons, which only adds to the pressure on Norvell to finally solve a problem that keeps surfacing in the most important spot on the field. [Read more 🡒]
FSU Gets A Needed Backfield Boost Before A Sneaky Tough Opener
Florida State got a timely boost in the backfield this week, with Mike Norvell confirming that senior running back Tre Wisner will be available for the season opener against New Mexico State. Wisner had been sidelined for preseason scrimmages because of a minor issue, but he was back at practice last week, giving the Seminoles a healthier look as they head into the start of the season.
Norvells update matters because New Mexico State has the kind of defense that can make an opener more annoying than expected, with experience and physicality built into the matchup. For Florida State, having Wisner back helps settle a key part of the offense before the first whistle, especially in a game where getting the ground attack moving early could take some pressure off everything else. [Read more 🡒]