Tommy Castellanos may end up doing more than fighting for a roster spot. He could be the player who blows the door open for a wave of college football chaos.
On Thursday, Pete Nakos reported that Castellanos is filing a lawsuit against the NCAA, with help from Darren Heitner, to seek an injunction that would allow him to enter the transfer portal. Castellanos is reportedly willing to return as either a quarterback or an athlete, but Florida State appears to have moved on with Ashton Daniels set to start in 2026 at quarterback and a young group of skill players already in place.
The legal fight comes after Tuesday night’s news out of Tallahassee. Following Florida State’s first scrimmage of 2026 fall camp, Mike Norvell said his program had “communicated with” some former players about returning for a fifth year of eligibility after a federal court injunction made Class of 2022 athletes eligible. That ruling came after the NCAA declined to grandfather those players into the new five-in-five eligibility rule introduced this offseason.
For now, the injunction applies only to Class of 2022 players who used four years of eligibility in four years and did not sign an NFL contract this offseason. That limited the pool of possible returns, and Castellanos quickly became the name to watch. He took minicamp invites as a wide receiver, but he was not signed as an undrafted free agent.
If Castellanos was the player who reached out to Florida State - and that appears likely, though it has not been confirmed - the sides evidently didn’t find a match. Now he’s taking the NCAA to court.
The larger issue is what happens if he wins. The current landscape has mostly been manageable in football because few players had the kind of foresight college basketball players from the 2022 class showed in April. Those basketball players entered the transfer portal during the portal window ahead of the five-in-five rule taking effect, and the Colorado District Court’s injunction should allow them to move freely, even though the NCAA is appealing.
Football players largely didn’t make that move, which is why the current ruling has had only a limited impact on 2026. Indiana defensive lineman Stephen Daley has already returned to Bloomington, but cases like his are rare. The players who fit this exact profile are few: good enough to help a Power 4 team, but not signed to any NFL contract this offseason.
Castellanos’ argument is simple enough. He says that if he had known he would receive a fifth year of eligibility, he would have entered the portal. That’s a messy argument, but it’s a strong one, and given the NCAA’s recent run in court, it looks like a winning one.
And if it is, the ripple effects could be huge. Players in that narrow category would suddenly be able to move around the sport, helping teams that need immediate help, including less competitive Power 4 programs and even Group of Six schools.
The real flood, though, could come if the same logic extends to another group: players from the 2022 class who signed NFL contracts this offseason but may not make a 53-man roster. They could argue they never would have gone pro if they had known a fifth year was coming.
It sounds like a stretch, but it’s really the same basic case. If Castellanos prevails, it becomes hard to see that next argument failing.
If that happens, the sport could be looking at a frenzy. And it wouldn’t stop with football.
All of this still has to move through the courts, and the clock is already ticking. Week 0 begins on August 28. Even if players aren’t ready to suit up by then, or if school calendars keep them from enrolling right away, the season could still be reshaped by midyear additions with College Football Playoff implications.
Right now, Castellanos is trying to knock over the first domino. If he wins, the rest may not stay standing for long.
In Other News...
Tony Whites First Scrimmage Reaction Says A Lot About FSUs Defense
Florida States defense has been under close watch this offseason, and defensive coordinator Tony Whites first reaction to the teams recent scrimmage offered a familiar mix of frustration and perspective. White initially came away focused on the negatives, which is usually how a coach sees a live work day before the film brings a clearer picture, and that was the case here too. After going back through the tape, he saw more signs of progress than he did in the immediate aftermath, a reminder that the Seminoles are still sorting through details even as camp moves along.
Tom Herman has also become part of that process in a meaningful way since joining Florida States OPS staff this offseason. White pointed to Hermans long coaching background and the support he offered during the scrimmage, using that experience as another layer of help in refining the defense and sharpening the teams overall preparation. For a unit trying to find its footing, having another veteran voice in the building can matter, even if the most important answers still have to show up on the field. [Read more 🡒]
FSU Running Back Battle Just Took An Unexpected Turn
Quintrevion Wisners push to move into Florida States backfield picture hit a small snag this week when he was held out of the Seminoles first preseason scrimmage. Offensive coordinator Tim Harris Jr. said the absence was tied to a minor issue, but he also noted that Wisner has been practicing well and has made progress since spring ball, which keeps him firmly in the conversation as camp rolls on.
For now, the opening created by Wisners absence has given Ousmane Kromah and Sam Singleton Jr. a little more room to make their own case in the competition for the top running back spot. Those extra reps matter in a battle that was already expected to be one of the more closely watched storylines of preseason, and Florida State will be paying close attention to how the rotation sorts itself out once everyone is back on the field together. [Read more 🡒]
Ousmane Kromah Is Forcing A Florida State Backfield Shakeup
Florida States backfield already had a crowded look to it before camp, and the addition of Texas transfer Quintrevion Wisner only added another layer to the mix. But Ousmane Kromah has kept pushing his way into the conversation after a freshman season that appears to have given way to a much stronger offseason and a fall camp that drew steady praise from Mike Norvell and the Seminoles staff.
Norvell has made it clear this years rotation will look different, which matters in a room that also includes Samuel Singleton Jr. and a newcomer expected to compete for touches. For Kromah, the real significance is less about being part of the mix than about how far he has climbed within it, with the early-season pecking order now sounding very much like a competition the Seminoles will keep watching closely. [Read more 🡒]