Change is coming fast in college football, and Florida’s quarterback room just got a major shake-up. Former five-star recruit DJ Lagway - ESPN’s No. 1 dual-threat QB in the 2024 class - is heading to the transfer portal. That’s a massive development for the Gators, who already parted ways with their head coach midseason and now lose the centerpiece of their future offense.
But while the news is big for Florida, it could have ripple effects across the state - especially in Tallahassee.
Florida State’s Quarterback Picture Just Got More Complicated
FSU is already staring down a quarterback decision of its own. With Thomas Castellanos’ eligibility in limbo due to an ongoing appeal, Mike Norvell and his staff are preparing to move forward with or without him. That means the Seminoles have to weigh two paths: roll with redshirt freshman Kevin Sperry, or dip into the transfer portal for the third year in a row.
And here’s the thing - going into 2026 with a quarterback who has little to no game experience is a risky proposition, especially for a program that expects to compete at a high level. Sperry might have long-term upside, but right now, he’s an unknown. And in today’s college football landscape, where wide receivers and offensive linemen are looking to pair with proven QBs, uncertainty at the most important position can hurt your ability to build a complete offense.
The Case for a Transfer QB - Again
FSU’s offense made strides in 2025, showing more rhythm and explosiveness compared to the previous season. But red zone execution - particularly at quarterback - was a glaring issue. Against top-tier defenses, those missed opportunities were the difference between good and great.
That’s why bringing in a transfer quarterback isn’t just a luxury - it might be a necessity. If Norvell is feeling any pressure to win in 2026 (and let’s be honest, expectations at FSU are never low), then securing a veteran presence under center could be the most important move of the offseason.
The portal opens on January 2nd, and the competition will be fierce. Florida’s in the market now.
Miami, under Mario Cristobal, has made a habit of going portal shopping for quarterbacks each year - and don’t be surprised if they make a run at Lagway, too. That means FSU will have to be aggressive, strategic, and maybe even a little creative to land the right guy.
A Balanced Approach Could Be the Best Play
Now, there’s a valid argument to be made for developing what you have. Sperry is talented, and giving him reps in 2026 - even in a limited role - could set him up for success in 2027. The key is finding the right balance: bring in a transfer who can lead the offense now, while still giving Sperry meaningful snaps to grow.
That approach not only keeps the offense competitive this season, but it also gives future recruits and current players confidence in the program’s direction. It’s about building for now and next - and that’s the kind of quarterback strategy that wins in today’s game.
Bottom Line
FSU is at a crossroads. The quarterback room needs clarity, and the portal offers a chance to bring in someone who can keep the offense humming. But with Florida, Miami, and other programs all looking to upgrade at the same position, the Seminoles have to move quickly and decisively.
The next few weeks could shape the 2026 season - and maybe even the future of Mike Norvell’s tenure in Tallahassee.