Six coaches left Week 4 with louder questions hanging over them, and the list runs from Lincoln Riley at USC to Mike Norvell at Florida State. The results were ugly in different ways, the buyout figures are all over the map, and each school now has to weigh the cost of patience against the price of moving on.
South Carolina’s Shane Beamer took one of the most painful losses of the bunch, a 49-18 defeat at No. 8 Alabama. That dropped the Gamecocks to 2-2 overall and 0-2 in SEC play, and it also extended some troubling trends: South Carolina has now lost seven straight to SEC opponents and 11 of its last 13 games against Power Four teams.
The frustration had already been building after last week’s collapse against Mississippi State, when the Gamecocks blew a 16-point lead in a 41-34 home loss. After the Alabama game, Beamer owned it. "This is on me," he said.
Beamer is 35-32 in his sixth year at South Carolina, and last season ended at 4-8. The athletic director, Jeremiah Donati, also did not hire him.
A source close to Donati said last November that Beamer would get through the first half of 2026 before any review of his future. South Carolina now turns to Kentucky on Saturday at 4:15 p.m.
ET, then heads to Florida.
Buyout: About $27.9 million if fired before the season ends, dropping to about $22.1 million at the end of December
At USC, the loss wasn’t as lopsided, but the stakes may have been even bigger. Oregon beat the Trojans 41-27 at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, and the Ducks had to finish the job without quarterback Dante Moore, who left in the second quarter after a late hit. The game was tied in the fourth quarter before Oregon finally separated late.
USC is 4-1, but Riley’s record against elite competition remains a glaring issue. He is now 5-15 against top-25 teams at USC, and he still has not gotten the Trojans into the College Football Playoff.
Before kickoff, Pete Thamel laid out exactly what was on the line. "If they lose Saturday, it's reasonable to say Lincoln Riley is on the hot seat," Thamel said. USC gets Washington next, and the rest of the schedule still includes Penn State, Ohio State and Indiana.
Maryland’s situation got ugly fast in a 54-3 home loss to UCLA, the worst beatdown among this group. The Terrapins were shredded by first-year Bruins coach Bob Chesney, and it marked Maryland’s second straight home loss to a first-year head coach after Virginia Tech’s James Franklin won in College Park a week earlier.
The numbers were brutal across the board. Malik Washington threw four interceptions, two of them returned for touchdowns.
Maryland managed only 39 rushing yards, and the defense surrendered 475. Before halftime, students were already chanting "Fire Locksley".
Locksley’s team is 2-2 in his eighth season, and Maryland has dropped to 4-8 in each of the last two years. The Terps also have not beaten a Power Four opponent since a win over Wisconsin on Sept.
20, 2025. Even so, the D.C. native said he still believes in what he’s building.
"I still have a lot of confidence in myself and the staff to get this thing fixed," Locksley said. "That will have to be earned, I won't be able to claim it."
Buyout: More than $9 million if fired before the season ends
Colorado’s Deion Sanders entered Big 12 play with his team still searching for traction, and Baylor handed the Buffaloes a 23-13 loss. Colorado is 2-2, and Sanders is now 18-23 in four seasons in Boulder.
The week before, Colorado lost 41-7 at Northwestern, and Sanders responded by removing several players from the team after a postgame incident. After the Baylor game, he said the Buffaloes still aren’t matching what he believes they can be.
"We're better than this. It seems as though we're better than our opponents, but the score does not dictate that," Sanders said.
Colorado finished 3-9 last season after going 9-4 the year before. The next three games are Texas Tech, Utah and Oklahoma State. Firing Sanders appears unlikely, with a resignation after the season ending looking more realistic.
Buyout: About $25.5 million (75 percent of his remaining base salary) if fired before the end of 2026, dropping to about $17.25 million in 2027
Rutgers is in a different spot after finally getting on the board, but Greg Schiano still starts from a hole. The Scarlet Knights opened with a 37-21 home loss to UMass, then fell to Boston College and USC before beating Howard 58-7 on Friday for their first win. That victory was Schiano’s 100th at Rutgers, and the team is now 1-3.
The road ahead is rough immediately, with No. 6 Indiana coming to town Saturday at 8 p.m.
ET. Rutgers athletic director Keli Zinn has publicly stood by Schiano, saying, "Greg and I are on the exact same page with this: I want what he wants and he wants what I want," Zinn said.
Buyout: About $17.3 million, based on the roughly $22.5 million left on his contract; the amount shrinks if he takes another coaching job
Florida State’s Mike Norvell is also feeling the heat, even after a 34-7 win over Central Arkansas pushed the Seminoles to 2-2. Central Arkansas is Norvell’s alma mater, but the earlier damage is what lingers: losses to SMU and Alabama, plus the school’s decision to fire athletic director Michael Alford before the Alabama game.
Norvell is 40-36 in his seventh season. Florida State followed a 13-0 regular season in 2023 with a 2-10 mark in 2024 and a 5-7 finish in 2025. October brings Virginia, Louisville and Miami.
Buyout: About $48 million if fired now, dropping to about $45.6 million after the season; he's owed 85 percent of his remaining salary
In Other News...
Jameis Winstons Giants Role Just Got More Complicated
Jameis Winston is back in a starting quarterback role for the New York Giants after an injury to Jaxson Dart opened the door, but his latest opportunity comes with a new layer of uncertainty. The Giants recently added JJ McCarthy in a trade, giving the quarterback room another young arm and making the depth chart more crowded just as Winston was settling back into the job.
Winston has sounded confident about handling the starters responsibility while also saying hes willing to help McCarthy develop, a tone that fits both the moment and the bigger picture in New York. For a player trying to steady his place under center, though, the addition of another quarterback with long-term value only adds another variable to a situation that already changed once and could keep changing. [Read more 🡒]
Florida State Defense Just Created A Bigger Virginia Concern
Florida States defensive preparation for Virginia sounds like it is leaning more toward discipline than disruption. Defensive coordinator Tony White said in a press conference that the Seminoles would not center their approach on pass rushing, even with Virginia bringing balanced offensive production and a quarterback who has played well. White also pointed to his own defenses inconsistency in executing calls, a sign that the emphasis inside the building is on getting the structure right first.
That kind of public comment can matter more than usual this week because it gives Virginia a clearer view of how Florida State is thinking about the matchup. With Whites remarks openly available, the Cavaliers have a little more to study as they sort through their own game plan, and the Seminoles now have to worry about whether the message they sent was as useful to the opponent as it was to their own locker room. [Read more 🡒]
Florida State Suddenly Has A Recruiting Problem It Cant Ignore
The recruiting picture around Florida State got a little shakier when 2027 three-star tight end Connor Winn backed away from his commitment without offering a reason. Even in a class cycle that is still early, a decommitment like that matters because it signals how quickly momentum can change when a program is trying to stabilize both on the field and in the living room.
Mike Norvells uncertain future only adds to the pressure, since recruits tend to watch coaching situations closely and revisit their choices when the noise gets louder. Winn may not be the last one to do it, either, with other pledges likely to keep an eye on how the Seminoles handle the next stretch of games and whether the staff remains intact. [Read more 🡒]