Floridas CFP Ranking Just Reopened A Debate Fans Know Too Well

Kirk Herbstreit questions Florida's place in the CFP rankings, highlighting their unpredictable season performance and sparking debate over SEC team selections.

Kirk Herbstreit didn’t hide his frustration with Florida’s place in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, and the Gators’ season has given him plenty to point at.

Florida slid back into the CFP Top 25 at No. 24 this week, but on “The Pat McAfee Show,” Herbstreit made his stance plain. “Florida is not a very good team,” Herbstreit said. “They’re very erratic and inconsistent.”

That word - erratic - fits a team that has beaten Texas and Ole Miss, yet also dropped four games by double digits. Florida’s resume is a strange mix of headline wins and rough nights, and Herbstreit also took aim at the committee’s back end, where four SEC teams with four losses landed from No. 21 through No. 25.

“What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said.

Florida’s return to the rankings came after a 21-14 win at No. 11 Kentucky, a result that counted as the Gators’ third victory over a top-11 opponent this season. They had already been ranked No. 24 in the committee’s first release before falling out after a loss to Oklahoma.

The problem for Florida is that the good Saturdays have often been followed by something ugly. The Gators lost by 28 at Missouri and by 16 at home against Oklahoma, and no team in that part of the rankings has bounced around quite like this one from week to week.

Jon Sumrall’s first season in Gainesville opened with four straight wins, and a 52-28 blowout of then-No. 4 Ole Miss pushed Florida all the way to No. 8 in the AP poll in late September.

But the momentum didn’t last. The next two games brought a 45-17 loss at Missouri and a 38-19 home loss to South Carolina.

Then came the quarterback shuffle. Backup Tramell Jones Jr. made his first career start and led Florida to a 27-24 win over No.

7 Texas in Austin, a game in which the Gators recorded six sacks. Sumrall wasn’t interested in dressing up the performance.

“Like I’ve watched this practice, we’re not very good. We still suck. We just suck less, all right,” Sumrall said.

Florida followed that upset with back-to-back losses, falling 27-8 to Georgia in Atlanta and then 23-7 at home to Oklahoma. Jones threw two interceptions against the Sooners, who outgained the Gators 351-203. Afterward, Sumrall didn’t sugarcoat it.

“I don’t have a whole lot of words that are going to make this right,” Sumrall said. “I felt really bad for that performance we put on.”

The quarterback situation has been just as unsettled as the results. Aaron Philo, a Georgia Tech transfer, was benched against Georgia, then got the job back at Kentucky and delivered a big night on the ground.

He ran 15 times for 102 yards and scored the go-ahead 2-yard touchdown with 9:08 remaining. Florida’s defense finished the job by stopping Kentucky on fourth down on both of its fourth-quarter possessions.

“He’s got heart, he’s tough,” Sumrall said of Philo. “Our quarterback room hasn’t always been perfect this year, but they love each other.”

The Kentucky win made Florida bowl eligible. If the Gators beat Vanderbilt and Florida State, Sumrall would finish his first season 8-4 and Florida could stay in the rankings. For now, though, the pattern is hard to ignore: every high point has been followed by a stumble, and the Gators still have to show they can put two good weeks together.

Florida hosts Vanderbilt on Saturday at noon ET on SEC Network before closing the regular season at Florida State on Nov. 27.

In Other News...

Florida Heads Into Vanderbilt With Availability Questions Fans Will Be Watching

Floridas first injury report for its final home game against Vanderbilt gave fans a clearer picture of who may and may not be available, and it was not exactly a reassuring one. The Gators listed several players as out or questionable, with receiver Vernell Brown III still sidelined by a knee injury and tight end Lacota Dipree out with an ankle issue while he awaits MRI results.

Safety Bryce Thorton was among the players tagged questionable, adding another layer of uncertainty to a roster already missing safety DJ Coleman, right tackle Emeka Ugorji and linebacker Jaden Robinson. With Vanderbilt coming in for the regular-season finale, Floridas availability picture is now a key storyline to watch as the week moves forward. [Read more 🡒]

Florida Heads Into Vanderbilt With A Growing Availability Problem

Floridas trip to Vanderbilt is coming with a longer injury list than the Gators would prefer, and the latest availability report only adds to the uncertainty. Safety DJ Coleman, right tackle Emeka Ugorji and tight end Lacota Dippre have already been ruled out with lower-body injuries, trimming depth at three spots the staff has had to manage carefully.

Linebacker Jaden Robinson and receiver Vernell Brown III will also miss the game, with Brown still working back from a knee injury. Corner Dijon Johnson is doubtful, while receiver Bailey Stockton and safety Bryce Thornton are questionable, leaving Florida to sort through several late-week decisions before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]

Florida Heads Into West Virginia Test With Two Big Concerns

West Virginias run in the Players Era 8 tournament has turned into a chance for Florida to measure itself against a team that has already shown plenty of fight. The Mountaineers dropped an 86-82 semifinal to Kansas despite a huge night from freshman point guard Miles Sadler, who poured in 34 points and kept West Virginia within reach almost the entire way. Now the Gators get the Mountaineers in the third-place game after their own loss to Houston, with both teams looking to leave the event with something to build on.

For Florida, the matchup carries a couple of obvious concerns. West Virginias guard play has been lively, and Sadlers scoring burst showed how quickly the Mountaineers can put pressure on a defense when the ball starts moving and shots start falling. Coaches from both sides have already pointed to the performances and game flow from the semifinal, which only adds to the intrigue heading into a game that should tell Florida a lot about where it stands after a tough tournament stretch. [Read more 🡒]