Anthony Richardson’s preseason has left the Colts in a familiar spot: still trying to figure out what they actually have.
His time in Indianapolis has already been a strange mix of dazzling flashes and rough nights, the kind of run that can make you believe one minute and shake your head the next. Year 3 was basically a redshirt season, which is a weird place for a quarterback to land this early, but it at least gave Richardson a chance to reset after a year on the bench that was interrupted by a freak eye injury.
The biggest thing that stands out now is that some of the easy stuff is starting to look easier. Richardson is getting better at making layups look like layups.
On speed outs, especially, his throwing motion looks calmer, like he’s taking a little heat off the ball instead of trying to fire everything through a wall. That has helped make the shorter throws feel much more manageable.
There’s one rep against the Lions that really captures the progress. Richardson identifies Cover Zero, which means the defense is bringing more rushers than the Colts can block.
He pulls the tight end in to help protect, giving Indianapolis seven blockers to match the seven defenders in the box. Then he gets NWI and Anthony Gould to adjust the play into a Cover Zero beater.
Gould runs the flat route to attack the defense’s leverage. The snap is messy and throws off the timing, but Richardson stays composed and still gets the ball out on time for a completion.
That’s the kind of sequence that looks like actual quarterbacking.
His footwork, too, seems more settled on certain plays.
But the same old issues are still hanging around. The inconsistency is obvious, and the mental mistakes are still too costly.
One play in particular stood out: against press coverage, routes can convert depending on how the defender plays it, and this looked like one of those moments. Treadwell beats the corner off the line and raises his hand, but Richardson throws it as if he’s still expecting the original route to develop, likely a comeback.
The result is a miss the receiver never had a real chance to make.
That’s the frustrating part. The easy throws are starting to look easier, but he still has to complete the ones that should be there. Misses happen to everyone, but there are still too many plays like that one, the kind that leave you wanting more because the receiver is left stranded.
And then there’s the ball security issue. When a quarterback has put the ball on the ground as often as Richardson has in his career, he can’t afford another fumble in what amounts to a glorified tryout for NFL teams. The fumble in New England is not going to help him change that conversation.
As for where this goes from here, the Colts appear to have made him part of the initial 53-man roster, likely as the QB2. It would be surprising to see him sit on the roster all year and then leave in free agency with Indianapolis getting nothing back.
It would also be surprising if Richardson doesn’t ask for his release at some point during the season. He seems like a player who needs a fresh start, and it has felt for a while like a trade would have made the most sense for both sides.
If Richardson is the Colts’ QB2 this year, that’s not nothing. But he still looks more like a developmental swing for a team that can afford to wait than a clean answer for a team that needs someone who can help win games right now.
In Other News...
Florida Fans Got A Brutal NFL Cut-Day Reality Check
NFL cut-down day brought a rough reminder of how thin the margin can be for former Florida players trying to stick on a league roster. After preseason evaluations wrapped up, the status of 10 ex-Gators came into focus, and the results were mixed in a way that should feel familiar to anyone tracking the programs pipeline to Sundays. Stone Forsythe and J. Michael Sturdivant earned spots on their teams 53-man rosters, a welcome sign that Florida still has players carving out roles at the next level.
The rest of the picture was less encouraging, with Kyle Trask, Kaiir Elam, Dameon Pierce, Amari Burney, Trikweze Bridges and Tyreak Sapp among those released or waived. Zachary Carter and Graham Mertz landed on injured reserve with their teams, leaving their immediate status in a different kind of holding pattern. For Florida fans, it was the sort of end-of-August snapshot that mixes a little pride with a lot of unease, because the NFL is never shy about reminding former college stars how quickly things can change. [Read more 🡒]
Florida Fans Keep Getting The Same Frustrating Offseason Reality
The offseason in college sports keeps reminding Florida fans how quickly a roster can turn over, and how familiar faces can disappear before the next fall even arrives. The article frames that frustration through the Ship of Theseus idea, using it to explain how constant player movement and coaching changes make it harder for fans to feel like they are following the same team from one year to the next.
For Gators supporters, the challenge is not just learning new names, but adjusting to how transfer rules and coaching turnover have changed the very rhythm of fandom. What used to be a slower, more stable connection to players now gets replaced by a cycle of introductions, departures and half-formed memories, leaving plenty of room for nostalgia and a lingering sense that the sport itself is always becoming something else. [Read more 🡒]
Floridas First Depth Chart Leaves Several Key Week 1 Battles Open
Floridas first depth chart for 2026 at least settles the biggest question heading into Week 1 against Florida Atlantic: junior Aaron Philo is the starter at quarterback. The release also gives an early look at the Gators starting offensive line and several other first-unit spots, offering the first public snapshot of how Billy Napiers team plans to line up when the season opens.
Even so, plenty of the roster remains unsettled, which is the more interesting part of the exercise this early in September. Florida listed ongoing competitions at defensive line, running back and offensive line, and it also used co-starters at the H tight end, defensive end and second outside cornerback positions, a sign that several jobs are still being sorted out even as the opener approaches. [Read more 🡒]