Anthony Richardson’s future with the Colts is hanging over Thursday night’s preseason opener, and the stakes for him are a lot bigger than a normal August snap.
The former Florida quarterback is still only 24, but his NFL path already feels precarious. Indianapolis selected him fourth overall in the 2023 NFL Draft, yet the team declined his fifth-year option, leaving him looking like a player entering what could be his final season with the franchise.
When he takes the field against the New England Patriots, it won’t just be about shaking off rust. It will be a tryout.
According to James Boyd, Richardson will start the first half against the Patriots on Thursday, with Riley Leonard taking over in the second half. The two quarterbacks will then flip roles against the Falcons. Daniel Jones will not play in the preseason, per Steichen.
Richardson’s situation in Indianapolis appears bleak, and the sense around the team is that coach Shane Steichen is simply waiting for the moment to move on. Even so, that doesn’t necessarily close the door on Richardson’s NFL future. A team with a fresh set of eyes could still be tempted by the upside.
At 6-foot-4 and 244 pounds, with a 4.43 time at the NFL Combine, Richardson still looks like the kind of physical specimen teams dream about. The problem has never been the tools.
It’s been turning those tools into dependable quarterback play. He came into the league as a raw prospect, and he still looks that way now.
There are coaches who will see him and think of the same kind of bet that worked with Josh Allen and Cam Newton. Richardson arrived in the NFL with plenty of hype, but not much seasoning.
He spent two years under Dan Mullen at Florida, but he was a backup, which limited his reps compared with Emory Jones. Then he got one full season as a starter under Billy Napier, and while the numbers were productive enough - over 3,200 total yards and 26 touchdowns - his passing efficiency never caught up, as he completed less than 54% of his throws.
He probably needed another year in college. He also needed stronger development. But with the situation as it was, leaving for the NFL made sense.
The frustrating part is how much more Richardson might have become with the right setup. The physical talent has always been obvious, and the injuries haven’t helped. But when he was healthy, he still didn’t do enough to convince the Colts he could be their long-term answer.
That’s why Thursday matters. Most people will see a preseason game. Richardson has to see a career-defining chance.
In Other News...
Floridas First Full-Pad Practice Exposed One Big Question Up Front
The Gators got into full pads for the first time of fall camp on Aug. 11, a useful checkpoint as they move through their sixth practice and inch toward the Sept. 5 season opener. The first day in full gear usually tells you a lot about where a roster is sturdy and where the coaches are still searching, and Floridas work showed both. The team is still building toward live tackling, which is set to begin Aug. 15 during an intrasquad scrimmage, so this was the stage where the competition started to sharpen without quite turning fully real.
One of the more encouraging signs came with wide receiver Dallas Wilson back in live passing work, giving the offense another piece to evaluate as camp intensity rises. Up front, though, the Gators are still feeling out their best combinations, and that uncertainty extends beyond the obvious starting spots. Theres also a real battle developing behind Jayden Woods at edge rusher, which only adds to the sense that Floridas depth chart is far from settled even as the season start gets closer. [Read more 🡒]
Florida QB Battle Reignites Concern Over Aaron Philos Biggest Limitation
The quarterback competition in Gainesville has stayed one of the most watched parts of Floridas offseason, and a recent practice clip involving Aaron Philo brought an old concern right back into focus. Philo arrived with a reputation for being a steady, capable passer, but questions about arm strength have followed him since his Georgia Tech days, and this look only sharpened the conversation around what he can and cannot do in the Gators offense.
None of that means the battle is anywhere close to settled. Tramell Jones Jr. brings a different set of strengths, and Florida still appears to be weighing how each quarterback fits the job rather than simply chasing one trait in a vacuum. Arm strength matters, but it is only one piece of the evaluation, and the open competition suggests the staff is still sorting out which skill set gives the Gators the best path forward. [Read more 🡒]
Florida Receiver Battle Just Got Tougher For One Overlooked Gator
A quiet subplot in Floridas receiver room has been TJ Abrams decision to stick around after the coaching change, a choice that kept the redshirt sophomore in Gainesville even as the roster and depth chart continue to shift. Abrams had every reason to weigh his options, but staying put reflects both his comfort in Florida and the value he places on finishing his degree at the university, which gives his return a different kind of meaning than a typical offseason stay-or-go decision.
Now the work gets more competitive. Abrams is headed into fall camp with a crowded group of receivers around him, and hes using the offseason to sharpen the parts of his game that can separate him from the pack, focusing on his speed and route running with the staff. For a player looking to carve out a bigger role, theres not much margin for error, and this camp will be a first real test of whether that patience turns into opportunity. [Read more 🡒]