Darryl Sutter didn’t exactly ease into the conversation about Johnny Gaudreau and Matthew Tkachuk. He went straight at it.
On the Cam and Strick podcast, the former Flames coach looked back on his time in Calgary and offered a blunt explanation for why both players moved on after the 2021-22 season. During the COVID years, when travel was restricted and players were cut off from family, Sutter said the pull back home was stronger than the pull to stay in Canada.
“Those American kids… they were basically stranded in Canada. Nobody could come and see them… Canada was not their thing. They didn’t leave because they didn’t like Calgary or the team - they wanted to go back home.”
That quote landed hard, especially in Flames circles, because it touched on a larger issue that’s been building around the league: American players increasingly have more freedom, more leverage and more reasons to prefer certain destinations. Sutter’s point also lands in a moment when Canadian teams are watching how often U.S. stars use no-trade lists and destination control to shape their careers.
Sutter’s voice carries weight for a reason. He’s one of the most established figures in the NHL coaching world, with two separate runs behind the Flames bench from 2002-06 and 2021-23.
He won the Jack Adams Award in 2021-22, and earlier in his career he guided the Kings to two Stanley Cups from 2011-2017. Around the league, he’s known for being dry, direct and impossible to mistake for anyone else.
The timing of the Flames’ losses made the blow even sharper. Calgary had won the Pacific Division and looked like a true contender before Gaudreau and Tkachuk exited within ten days in 2022.
Together with Elias Lindholm, they formed what was described as the best line in hockey, and the numbers backed it up. Gaudreau finished with 40 goals, 115 points and a +64 rating.
Tkachuk had 42 goals, 104 points and a +57 mark.
Losing one player like that is a setback. Losing both is a gut punch that changes the direction of a franchise.
It also came at a time when the Battle of Alberta had real heat behind it. Calgary and Edmonton had just battled through a bruising five-game playoff series, one that ended with Connor McDavid’s overtime winner in Game 5. Everything about the rivalry seemed to be building toward another run of big moments and playoff showdowns.
Instead, the Flames dropped off, missed the playoffs every season since, and the rivalry’s momentum vanished with them.
For Canadian clubs, Sutter’s comments feed into a question that’s already sitting in front offices: how do you balance taking the best player available with the reality that some American prospects may eventually want to head closer to home? With the U.S. producing elite talent at a huge clip, and with tax advantages in certain states adding another layer to the decision, that tension is only getting louder.
The Flames lived through the downside of it.
In Other News...
Oilers Front Office Still Has One Trust Problem Fans Havent Dropped
Even after a summer that brought some cautious optimism around Mike Babcock and a few moves aimed at tightening things up, Oilers fans still do not seem ready to hand the front office a clean slate. The latest read from The Athletic points to a base that remains wary of management, with concerns about the blue line and depth scoring still hanging over the conversation as Edmonton tries to convince people it is headed in the right direction.
Stan Bowmans group now has the usual burden of any hockey operation trying to reshape public perception: winning has to do the talking. The noise around the front office has not gone away, and until the Oilers show real on-ice progress, that trust problem figures to stay part of the backdrop in Edmonton. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Front Office Doubts Are Growing Around Connor McDavid's Window
The Oilers spent the offseason making major changes behind the bench, part of a broader effort to reset after a season that left plenty of questions about where the roster is headed. Firing Kris Knoblauch and bringing in Mike Babcock were the most visible moves, but they also fed a larger conversation around how Edmonton is managing the window around Connor McDavid and whether the organization is steering with urgency or just reacting to the latest setback.
That backdrop helps explain why the front-office conversation has turned so sharp. In a recent Athletic fan-based ranking, Edmonton slid further down the list as doubts continued to build around the way the team is being run, and the reaction has had less to do with one single move than with a growing feeling that the plan has been hard to pin down. For a franchise trying to keep pace with its superstar's timeline, that kind of skepticism is starting to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers May Be Eyeing A Veteran Move That Reshapes The Bottom Six
The Oilers search for a little more certainty in the bottom six may be turning toward a familiar kind of veteran fix. Edmonton has been linked to a possible addition who could help stabilize the fourth line, bring some reliability at the dot, and give the coaching staff another trusted option when the game tightens up in the defensive zone.
A move like that would not just be about one player, either. It could ripple through the rest of the roster, forcing the Oilers to make a choice on younger depth pieces while they sort out how they want their checking lines to look heading into the next stretch of the season. More Oilers talk is expected soon on Sports 1440 and YouTube, where this kind of roster wrinkle should get plenty of attention. [Read more 🡒]