The Edmonton Oilers have leaned hard into second chances in recent years, but that approach is starting to carry a real cost with their own fan base.
It began with two notable additions who arrived with serious baggage: Evander Kane and Corey Perry. Edmonton took a swing on both after their previous contracts were terminated, and both players went on to become strong contributors. But the success of those gambles hasn’t softened the bigger concern around the organization’s direction.
That concern only grew when the Oilers hired Stan Bowman as general manager in July 2024. Bowman brought a championship résumé, including three Stanley Cup titles with the Chicago Blackhawks, but his name was also tied to the fallout from the Blackhawks scandal.
He resigned as Chicago’s GM in October 2021 after an investigation found the organization mishandled and failed to act on sexual assault allegations against video coach Brad Aldrich in 2010. Edmonton brought him in just three years later.
The front office doubled down on that path with Mike Babcock, another hire that came loaded with controversy. Babcock had not won anything in over 15 years, and after leaving the Toronto Maple Leafs in 2019, Brendan Shanahan said Babcock’s coaching tactics “weren’t appropriate or acceptable.”
There were also allegations of mental abuse. His next stop with the Columbus Blue Jackets never got off the ground; he resigned in 2023 before coaching a game, and while the NHL investigated and cleared him to find employment, that didn’t erase the baggage surrounding him.
The latest move is the one that seems to have pushed things too far for some supporters. Edmonton signed Alex Formenton to a one-year deal with an $850,000 cap hit.
Formenton had spent the last few seasons in the Swiss league and, according to the source, wasn’t impressive there. He was also one of five players from Canada’s 2018 World Junior team charged with sexual assault.
After a highly publicized trial, all five were acquitted in July 2025 and later reinstated into the NHL.
Even with the acquittal, the signing has been enough to alienate at least one of the team’s most visible supporters. Mary Loewen, known to Oilers fans as “Momma Stanley” for dressing as the Stanley Cup during the playoffs, said she would no longer back the team.
“I am deeply disappointed by the Edmonton Oilers’ decision to sign Alex Formenton. Although he was acquitted in court, I cannot ignore my conscience or what this decision represents to me.
As a sexual assault survivor, I must stand by my morals and stand with the woman at the centre of this case. For that reason, as long as Formenton remains an Oiler, I cannot and will not support or cheer for this team”, she stated.
The Oilers were one win away from the Stanley Cup in 2024, but the source argues these moves have turned them into a team many outside Edmonton won’t want to see succeed. More than that, they may be pushing away some of the very people who once rode hardest with them.
In Other News...
Connor Ingram Gave Oilers Stability Then It Ended Far Too Fast
Connor Ingrams time in Edmonton was supposed to be a short-term answer, the kind of move a team makes when it needs calm in a crease that has seen enough turbulence. Instead, the veteran goalie gave the Oilers a stretch of stability after arriving from Utah in October 2025, then quickly became another name in a career that never seemed to settle for long. He went on to appear in 37 games for Edmonton before reaching free agency.
Ingram announced his retirement from professional hockey on Sept. 11, closing the book after five NHL seasons that took him from Nashville to Arizona, then Utah and Edmonton. Over that span, he played 134 regular-season games and nine playoff contests, a modest total that still reflected the persistence it takes to stick in the league as a goaltender. For the Oilers, the ending leaves behind the familiar feeling of a promising stop that ended far sooner than anyone in the organization could have wanted. [Read more 🡒]
Aku Rty Is Giving Oilers Fans A Real Camp Question
Aku Rty is one of the more intriguing names in Oilers camp because the skill set is easy to notice. He is 25, shoots right, brings real speed, and has shown a scoring touch that has translated well enough to keep him on the radar, including a strong Liiga season with power-play production. The range of his NHL equivalencies over the years suggests there is still a player here worth tracking, especially for an organization that is always sorting through depth options.
The bigger question is where he fits when the roster math gets real, and the answer may end up being more about Bakersfield than Edmonton. Rtys offensive flashes make him interesting, but there is still uncertainty around his overall game away from the puck, which is the sort of detail that can decide whether a player settles into a meaningful minor-league role or remains just outside the main competition for a call-up spot. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Mourn The Man Who Helped Keep This Team In Edmonton
Cal Nichols, one of the most important figures in Oilers history, has died, and his place in the franchises story is secure. The team announced his passing and recognized the role he played in helping preserve hockey in Edmonton, where his influence stretched far beyond the business side of the sport.
Nichols founded the Edmonton Investors Group and helped assemble the ownership effort that stabilized the franchise at a critical moment. For Oilers fans, his name is tied to the period when the clubs future in the city was uncertain, and the reminder now is how close that future came to looking very different. [Read more 🡒]