Sidney Crosby’s name keeps surfacing in trade chatter, and the latest wrinkle is one Oilers fans will notice.
The Penguins captain has been linked to movement before - last season, he was tied to a possible deal to the Colorado Avalanche, a scenario that would have paired him with fellow Cole Harbour, Nova Scotia native Nathan MacKinnon along with Conn Smythe-winning defenseman Cale Makar and longtime captain Gabe Landeskog. This year, the noise around Crosby is quieter, but the conversation hasn’t gone away.
What stands out now is Crosby’s repeated support for Edmonton Oilers head coach Mike Babcock. Crosby has already backed Babcock’s coaching style and organization, and he did it again recently.
In a piece by Kurt Leavins of the Edmonton Journal, Crosby said Babcock’s coaching has helped the Oilers “look like they are on the same page.” He also said, “you can tell how focused they are.”
That kind of praise naturally invites a bigger question: could Crosby ever wind up in Edmonton?
Maybe. But that’s a summer conversation, not a now conversation.
Chris Johnston recently said any decision from Crosby to leave the team that drafted him would come in the offseason. That window is not as far off as it sounds, either. Crosby is set to become a free agent this summer unless he signs a new deal with the Penguins before the end of June.
There’s also the broader Penguins picture. Elliotte Friedman has suggested Pittsburgh is in a position to start a rebuild of sorts, but Crosby wouldn’t be part of that process until well after the deadline. Still, if he wanted out, a couple of things could push the situation in that direction.
The first is simple enough: the standings. When Friedman made that point, the Penguins were 5-9-2. They’ve won two of their last three since then, but they’re still eight points out of a playoff spot, with American Thanksgiving getting closer.
The second is what Pittsburgh does with the rest of its roster, especially Erik Karlsson. Bleacher Report recently floated the Carolina Hurricanes, Ottawa Senators, Tampa Bay Lightning, Toronto Maple Leafs and Utah Mammoth as possible landing spots. If the Penguins decide to move him, the return would likely need to include a younger defenseman, which is why a Karlsson-for-Nikishin deal or a reunion with the Senators could make the most sense for Pittsburgh.
Karlsson would also waive his no-move clause for Toronto to reunite with former Senators teammate Daniel Alfredsson, now an assistant to head coach Jim Hiller, but it’s unclear whether Pittsburgh would want a deal built around a team whose blue line skews older. In Toronto’s case, only Cole McWard is at or below 25, while five of the Leafs’ full-time defensemen are older than 30.
If Karlsson goes, more moves could follow before the March 1 trade deadline. Evgeni Malkin could be among them, especially with his age and Dubas’ view of Malkin’s contract situation not exactly sounding optimistic about the long term. If Pittsburgh truly isn’t open to re-signing him, he’d be the second superstar moved in what could become a major overhaul.
And if that kind of shakeup happens, Crosby could look elsewhere for the final stretch of his career, likely on a one- or two-year deal before eventually returning on a one-day contract to retire as a Penguin. The article points to other stars who have done something similar, including Michael Jordan with the Washington Wizards and Tom Brady with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
If Crosby ever did choose Edmonton, it would almost certainly be in that short-term, late-career mold. With his ties to Babcock and his continued public praise, the idea isn’t far-fetched if the Oilers’ coaching setup is still the same heading into the 2027-28 season.
In Other News...
Oilers Suddenly Have A Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Problem
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins availability took an immediate hit heading into Sundays game against the Flyers, forcing Edmonton to adjust its middle-six mix on the fly. Colton Dach is set to slide into the second-line centre role, a notable change for a team that leans heavily on Nugent-Hopkins for stability and matchup flexibility.
The lineup shuffle also opens the door for Filip Hllander, who is back in action for the first time since Nov. 5. For now, the Oilers are left waiting on the bigger question around Nugent-Hopkins, with the club expecting a clearer read on his status Monday as it tries to sort out what comes next down the middle. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Escaped A Leafs Letdown That Nearly Cost Them
The Oilers left Toronto with the kind of narrow win that can feel bigger than the score line, especially after a game in which the Maple Leafs looked more organized defensively and got strong work in net from Anthony Stolarz. Edmonton still had to sweat through a tight, low-event night before escaping with a 1-0 result, a reminder that even a struggling opponent can make life uncomfortable when the margins are thin.
Torontos frustration only deepened in a building where the club has now dropped six straight home games, its longest home regulation skid in 41 years. The Leafs sit at the bottom of the Atlantic Division with 18 points through 22 games, and the latest loss added another layer of bitterness after a tying goal was taken off the board, leaving Edmonton to survive a game that nearly turned into a letdown. [Read more 🡒]
Devon Levi Is Giving The Oilers Exactly What Buffalo Couldn't
Devon Levis move from Buffalo to Edmonton has quickly become one of those transactions that looks different in hindsight than it did on July 1, when the Sabres sent the goaltender to the Oilers for a third-round pick. Edmonton needed stability in net, and Levi has provided it almost immediately, giving the club the kind of calm, reliable presence that can settle a team down over a long stretch.
Since arriving, Levi has already posted a shutout and won nine of his first 10 games with Edmonton, a sharp contrast to the goaltending issues Buffalo has continued to wrestle with from the players it kept. For the Oilers, the early returns have been hard to ignore, and the bigger question now is how long this kind of run can keep reshaping the conversation around a trade that already looks like a win. [Read more 🡒]
