As the Oilers’ schedule starts to stiffen, the real question isn’t whether they have enough talent. It’s whether they can find the right mix before the games get heavier and the margins get thinner.
Wednesday night’s win over the Philadelphia Flyers gave Edmonton another glimpse of what a second line might look like. Zach Hyman scored twice, and one of those goals came with a new look beside veteran centre Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and emerging power forward Colton Dach.
The trio has only logged seven minutes together, so it may be a short-lived experiment. Still, it was enough to raise the bigger issue: can Dach handle that kind of load, and can the Oilers settle on something dependable behind their stars?
At 14-3-3, the roster is healthy enough to let the coaching staff dream a little. If Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Vasily Podkolzin stay together on the top line the rest of the way, then the real puzzle becomes how to use the rest of the forwards on the second and third units.
There’s a cost to stacking the top line, and Edmonton has already felt it. Through 20 games, the Oilers have outscored opponents 27-9 at five-on-five when McDavid and Draisaitl are on the ice together or when either centre is out there alone, a 75 percent share.
But when both are off the ice, Edmonton drops to 38 percent, with a 15-24 goal split over a large chunk of minutes. That’s a lot of game to hand over in a sport where control matters.
Moving Draisaitl down would create more balance, but for now the safer play is to keep riding the hot hand. If the climb gets tougher, Babcock will still have the option of splitting McDavid and Draisaitl later.
The second line is where the Oilers may already be finding something. Nugent-Hopkins and Hyman are back, and that alone changes the picture. Matt Savoie could eventually be another option, but for now the best fit may be Dach alongside those two.
Dach has surged over the last eight games. In 106 five-on-five minutes, he’s producing 1.13 goals per 60 and 1.69 points per 60.
His line has outscored opponents 6-3, his expected goal share sits just under 50 percent, and he’s been active and intelligent on the forecheck. His passing has also stood out.
The sample is still small, but at 6-foot-3 and 215 pounds, he brings the kind of size and recent form that put him in the conversation. He’s only played seven minutes with Nugent-Hopkins and Hyman this season, which tells you how new this idea still is.
Kasperi Kapanen has also spent time on that line, logging 36 minutes there, but the results haven’t been there. The trio has been outscored 0-2.
Babcock has size spread across the lineup, and Kapanen has worked on skill lines before, most often with Draisaitl. At five-on-five, he’s at just 0.47 points per 60, though he did find real success on the power play while Hyman was out.
Savoie remains another possibility, but his return is still some way off. For now, Dach-Nuge-Hyman looks like the clearest path, even if the Oilers keep auditioning options well into November and December.
The third line is a different kind of problem. Jason Dickinson has been exactly what you want from a suppression centre.
Opponents have a hard time generating offense against him, and he’s also chipped in at a strong clip himself, with 1.58 points per 60 and a 67 percent outscoring rate. His five-on-five goals-against rate of 0.53 is absurdly low, and even his expected number, 2.49, would still be elite if it climbs back toward that level.
The challenge is finding the right wingers to make that line work. Dickinson has been used with several options, but the expected goals numbers tell the story.
Dickinson and Trent Frederic have posted a 2.12 xGA-60 in 19 minutes. Dickinson and Mathieu Joseph sit at 2.35 in 62 minutes.
Dickinson and Kapanen are at 2.39 in 32 minutes. Dickinson and Alex Formenton are at 2.56 in 60 minutes.
Since this line won’t be driven by offense and Babcock values both Kapanen and Joseph, those two look like the most logical choices from the players currently on hand. Savoie will be part of the discussion once he’s ready, but not yet.
Then there’s the fourth line, where Owen Michaels has been asked to hold down the centre spot because he’s the only right-handed centre on the roster. Babcock has kept using the rookie through 20 games regardless of the results, but the last month has been rough.
Over his last 15 games and 151 minutes, the line has managed only an 18 percent goal share. The goals-against rate is 3.57, while the expected number is 3.04, which suggests some bad luck has been involved too.
The issue is that Michaels’ wingers haven’t been able to stabilize things. Joseph has a 3.52 xGA-60 with Michaels, compared with 2.64 away from him.
Formenton has also struggled, sitting at 2.64 away from Michaels but 3.35 with him. That combination hasn’t worked.
The best version of Michaels this season has come with Trent Frederic. Michaels and Frederic have a 1.84 xGA-60 together, while Frederic sits at 2.96 away from the rookie. With limited choices, a Frederic-Michaels-Filip Hållander line, with Hållander at 2.06 xGA-60 with Michaels, may be the cleanest answer.
If Edmonton goes with that setup, the healthy scratches would be Formenton and Max Jones. Babcock would still have Savoie, Ike Howard and Mattias Janmark waiting in the wings once they’re healthy again.
So after 20 games, the Oilers have looked like a one-line team. Hyman’s two goals on a line with Nugent-Hopkins and Dach suggest a second line might already be taking shape.
The third line should come together once two veterans settle in with more consistency. The fourth line, though, depends on Michaels adjusting to the NHL after college.
That’s a huge ask, and it remains one of the biggest challenges on the roster.
In Other News...
Connor Murphy Is Becoming An Oilers Problem They Can't Ignore
Even with the Oilers piling up wins, Connor Murphys place on the blue line has become harder to gloss over. The veteran defenseman has drawn criticism for the numbers underneath the surface, and the concern is less about one bad night than a pattern that has made his minutes a talking point around the team. Edmontons overall record can hide a lot, but it does not erase the fact that Murphy has not driven play the way the club needs from a regular defenseman.
The bigger issue is that Murphy may not be the only problem, which is what makes this situation tricky for Edmonton. The second defensive pairing has been thin enough that his struggles are being viewed in the context of weak support around him, and the Oilers next move could depend on who returns to the lineup and how much depth they can trust. If the team wants to stabilize that side of the defense, it may have to make a decision that changes Murphys role, even if that answer is still unfolding. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Trade Buzz Suddenly Centers On One Believable Star Target
The Oilers have not made any recent trades, but the conversation around their next move is starting to sharpen. If Edmonton decides to add, the focus would be on either a top-six forward or a top-four defenseman, which is exactly the kind of upgrade that can matter most when a contender is trying to squeeze a little more out of its roster.
Among the names being weighed, Quinn Hughes looks like a long shot and Elias Pettersson comes with obvious contract questions, leaving the discussion to drift toward a different established star. Roman Josi stands out as the cleanest fit for Edmontons needs and the most believable of the options, even if there is still plenty standing between speculation and an actual deal. [Read more 🡒]
Babcocks Return To Toronto Adds Extra Heat For The Oilers
Mike Babcocks return to Toronto gives this Oilers road trip a little extra edge, even beyond the standings and the usual late-season noise. Now behind Edmontons bench, the former Maple Leafs coach is back in the building where he spent a memorable stretch with one of hockeys biggest franchises, and he spent time reflecting on both the good and the difficult parts of that run while also taking stock of his current group, which sits atop the Pacific Division.
For the Oilers, the setting adds another layer to a meeting that already matters, with Toronto trying to steady itself under new coach Jim Hiller while the Leafs continue to search for traction in the Atlantic Division. Babcocks presence turns the matchup into more than just another cross-conference game, because the conversation around it is as much about history and unfinished business as it is about the points on the line. [Read more 🡒]