The Edmonton Oilers took a step on Wednesday by adding left winger Alex Formenton, a move that gives them more speed on the fourth line and should help on the penalty kill.
But the real issue still sits much higher in the lineup.
Edmonton remains without the kind of top-6 addition that would make the second line look dangerous against elite competition, and that matters because the second line gets a heavy dose of the league’s best. If the Oilers are serious about opening night with this setup, there is still major work to be done.
At captain’s practice on Wednesday, Mike Babcock skated Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl together with left winger Vasily Podkolzin. If that trio stays intact all season, it would look like the best line in the NHL. The trouble is what comes after it.
The second line featured Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Zach Hyman and Ike Howard. Nugent-Hopkins and Hyman are proven veterans, but both are past their peak seasons - Nugent-Hopkins is 33 and Hyman is 34.
Howard is 22 and has only 29 NHL games under his belt. That’s not a group that screams top-end balance.
Stan Bowman still needs to land a difference-maker, whether that’s a first-shot scorer or a high-skill right-handed centre. The kind of player Florida Panthers GM Bill Zito seems to find every year. If Babcock wants the McDavid-Draisaitl- Podkolzin line to be a monster in 2026-27, Bowman has to keep digging for an elite talent.
The numbers help explain why.
At five-on-five, the isolated goals and expected goals data for Edmonton’s top five centres from a year ago showed Draisaitl on his own as the best option the Oilers had. McDavid’s isolated results weren’t as clean defensively, but they still produced a strong 54 percent share. Draisaitl’s late-season injury and absence made that even more important.
The deeper concern is the centre depth behind them. Nugent-Hopkins, Curtis Lazar and Adam Henrique were operating against softer competition, which helps explain their lower goals-against rates.
Nugent-Hopkins, in particular, has long been a strong defensive centre. He skates efficiently, stays around the puck and consistently puts himself in position to read danger before it develops.
Coaches have trusted him with major roles his whole career for a reason.
His most common linemates over the years include McDavid, Draisaitl, Taylor Hall and Jordan Eberle. That’s not a coincidence. Nugent-Hopkins has always been the kind of player who can steady a line.
What he still needs is a winger who can tilt the ice offensively. Right now, Babcock and Bowman seem to be betting on Hyman in that role.
That part of the plan has some logic. Hyman is a real goal scorer when he’s healthy. Over the past three seasons at five-on-five, he has averaged 1.29 goals per 60, the best mark among Oilers forwards and fourth among NHL forwards with 2,700-plus minutes, according to Natural Stat Trick.
But McDavid changes everything. With McDavid over those same three seasons, Hyman has averaged 1.43 goals per 60 at five-on-five, with 56 goals in 2,351 minutes.
Away from McDavid, that number drops to 0.92 goals per 60, with 13 goals in 850 minutes. Good player either way.
Different level of impact next to the captain.
And when Nugent-Hopkins and Hyman have been together away from both McDavid and Draisaitl, they’ve posted a 50 percent goal share in 360 five-on-five minutes. That’s workable in spots. It’s a lot less convincing as the backbone of a second line that has to survive serious competition.
The obvious in-house answer is the one the Oilers have chased for years: split McDavid and Draisaitl.
The yearly five-on-five numbers tell the story. Together, the two superstars have been excellent almost every season. But the rest of the roster hasn’t always held up when they’re apart, and that’s the problem Edmonton keeps running into.
There have been a few bright spots. Jay Woodcroft’s 2022-23 team got offence from all over the lineup, and “the rest” also cleared 50 percent in 2016-17. The 2019-20 dip can be chalked up to luck, though a rough 20 minutes with James Neal didn’t help.
The takeaway is simple: McDavid and Draisaitl together are a weapon. The math doesn’t love them together when you look at how the rest of the team performs.
The solo numbers have their own lessons too. McDavid was below 50 percent in 2018-19, with shaky goaltending and difficult results alongside Milan Lucic and Jesse Puljujärvi.
Draisaitl had a rough early stretch in his career as well, when he struggled against top competition. Lucic, in particular, was a tough fit in those seasons.
Babcock has a plan, and the Oilers are moving as if they’re committed to it. He may be able to get Nugent-Hopkins centring a line with Hyman on the wing and push that group above 50 percent. That would still be a stretch.
After that, Edmonton has to build two depth lines that can hold the fort. Babcock has a strong history of sending out goal-suppression lines, and that may be part of the answer. But it doesn’t change the main point: the Oilers still need another top-6 forward.
In Other News...
Oilers Just Made A Move Fans Will Have Strong Opinions On
The Oilers added a name that immediately got people talking when they signed Alex Formenton to a one-year deal. It is the kind of move that goes beyond the usual roster churn, because Formenton has been out of the NHL spotlight and his arrival in Edmonton carries plenty of baggage beyond simple hockey fit.
Even by the standards of a late-summer transaction, this one is sure to land with strong opinions attached. Formentons past involvement in the 2018 Hockey Canada case involving five players is part of why the signing is drawing so much attention, and it puts the organization in the middle of a conversation that has very little to do with line combinations or depth charts. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Spark Immediate Backlash With Controversial Alex Formenton Decision
The Oilers latest roster move has quickly turned into something bigger than a hockey transaction, with the club signing forward Alex Formenton and putting itself right back in the middle of a sensitive conversation around a player who was previously involved in the trial tied to the 2018 Hockey Canada team. Formenton, who has been away from the NHL spotlight, expressed gratitude for the chance to return, but the reaction around the deal has been immediate and far less straightforward than a typical depth addition.
What makes this signing especially notable is the way it came together and the scrutiny it is already drawing. NHL Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly said Edmonton did not need league approval to make the move and learned of the signing at the same time as everyone else, a detail that underscores how quickly the news landed across the sport. For the Oilers, the bigger question now is not just how Formenton fits on the ice, but how long this decision stays in the spotlight off it. [Read more 🡒]
McDavid Just Sent A Clear Message About What Oilers Need Most
Connor McDavid spent the captains skate in Edmonton on Sept. 9 talking less about flash and more about the basics the Oilers have to get right. His message was clear: after long stretches of players being shuffled around the order and into different roles, the lineup needs more stability, and the team has to come out of the gate with the kind of pace that keeps it from playing catch-up early.
There is also a calendar wrinkle that could work in Edmontons favor. With no Olympic or Four Nations Face-Off interruptions to break up the season, McDavid pointed to the possibility of more rest and recovery as a small but meaningful edge, the kind that can matter over a long grind if the Oilers are able to settle in quickly and stay there. [Read more 🡒]