Oilers Ranking Reignites A Debate Fans Have Tried To Ignore

With a dismal ranking from The Athletic, the Oilers face scrutiny over their shallow pool of promising young players ahead of the upcoming NHL season.

As training camps approach for the 2026-27 NHL season, the prospect rankings are starting to roll in, and the Oilers have landed near the very bottom of one of the latest lists.

Corey Pronman of The Athletic slotted Edmonton 31st out of 32 NHL teams in his prospect-pool rankings, a placement that fits the reality of how the organization has operated over the past few seasons. The Oilers have gone to the Stanley Cup Finals twice in the last three years, and that push has come at a cost. They’ve moved multiple picks and prospects to add help at the deadline, including first-rounders used to bring in Mattias Ekholm, Adam Henrique, and Jake Walman.

That kind of approach has left the cupboard thin. Since the 2023 NHL Draft, Edmonton has had only one first-round selection across four drafts. More broadly, the Oilers have made 20 picks out of the 28 they started with, which means they’ve averaged trading away two picks per draft over the last four seasons.

That reality makes a weak prospect ranking easier to understand. The bigger question is how Pronman sorted the names that are actually eligible to count.

Pronman’s eligibility cutoff is straightforward: "Player eligibility is determined by age. A player is eligible if he is 22 years old or younger as of Sept. 15, 2026."

That rules out several players in Edmonton’s system, including Josh Samanski, Connor Ungar, Quinn Hutson, and Viljami Marjala.

From the players who do qualify, Pronman listed five prospects and called two of them "quality pro prospects," while also noting, "The problem is that after them, there's next to nothing in this farm system."

His top five for the Oilers were:

  1. Matt Savoie
  2. Rudolfs Berzkalns
  3. Asher Barnett
  4. Ike Howard
  5. David Lewandowski

Savoie at No. 1 is easy enough to follow. He has already shown he can handle NHL minutes and has the kind of upside that could make him a breakout candidate in his second season.

After that, the list gets a little more debatable. Berzkalns comes in second, and while there is legitimate NHL potential there, the choice to place him ahead of Howard stands out.

Howard struggled at the NHL level, but he was excellent in the American Hockey League as a rookie and could be poised for a step forward next season as a top-nine secondary scorer. Berzkalns, by contrast, looks more like a safer bottom-six type without quite the same ceiling.

Barnett brings a different profile as a mobile, two-way defenseman who projects as a No. 4-6 option at the NHL level. Lewandowski also has some appeal, with the ingredients to develop into a middle-six power forward winger who can use his size and strength to create space while still bringing skill.

Still, the overall criticism is hard to ignore: the pool is shallow, and Pronman’s ranking reflects that. Even so, there are a few names missing from the discussion, including Tommy Lafreniere and Samuel Jonsson, who both showed promise in their development this past season.

In the end, the exact order will be debated for a long time, but the real answer won’t come for years.

In Other News...

Oilers Training Camp Battles Could Decide How Real This Cup Push Is

Training camp is still ahead, but the Oilers already have a few roster puzzles that could shape how serious this Cup push really is. On the back end, Spencer Stastney, Ty Emberson and Shakir Mukhamadullin are all in the mix for limited spots, and the outcome of that battle will say plenty about how Edmonton wants to build its blue line for the 2026-27 season.

Ike Howard is another name to watch as he pushes for a top-six role and could begin his camp path on the third line, giving the Oilers another layer of competition up front. The biggest uncertainty, though, may be in goal, where Frederik Andersen, Tristan Jarry and Stuart Levi are all part of the conversation and nothing has been settled yet, leaving Edmonton with one of those preseason decisions that can quietly define everything that follows. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Trade Picture Just Got More Interesting For Top Nine Help

The Oilers search for top-nine help is already taking shape well ahead of the 2026-27 season, and the trade board has gotten a little more crowded. Montreals Zachary Bolduc-for-Logan Mailloux swap is still part of the conversation because Bolduc remains a restricted free agent and his next deal has not been settled, which keeps the Canadiens in the spotlight as a team to watch if the market starts moving.

Pittsburgh adds another layer to the picture, since Sidney Crosby and the Penguins are expected to get an extension done soon and the talks are centered on term rather than retirement. That matters for Edmonton because the Penguins direction will help define which names actually reach the market, and as the Oilers keep looking for offensive support, a few familiar teams could become much more relevant if they decide to sell. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Linked To A Risky Scoring Bet With Serious Upside

Patrik Laine has long been the kind of scorer who can change the look of a power play in a hurry, which is why his name still carries real weight around the league even after the stops and starts of recent seasons. Drafted second overall by the Winnipeg Jets in 2016, he flashed elite finishing touch early and then ran into a long stretch of health troubles that have kept him from building much momentum, including a brief five-game run with the Montreal Canadiens.

For Edmonton, the appeal is obvious if the price and structure make sense. A player with Laines track record is the sort of low-floor, high-ceiling bet front offices kick around when they want offense without a long-term commitment, and his veteran status only adds to the calculus. The catch is obvious too, with teams expected to weigh his injury history heavily as they look at how to protect themselves in any deal. [Read more 🡒]