Mike Babcock wasn’t interested in making Mark Messier’s criticism into a fight.
After Messier said he was “absolutely shocked” by Babcock’s hiring and “horrified” by the Oilers’ hiring process, the Edmonton coach took the high road on Thursday and kept his answer measured. He leaned into respect rather than retaliation, even joking around the fact that one of the teams at training camp is called Team Messier.
“He won four Cups here,” said Babcock. “I’m younger than him.
When I watched him, hard leader, two-way, competitive. Went to New York, worked hard, two-way, competitive.
Real leader.
“I’ve dealt with him two times in my life. One time we were getting presented Olympic gold medals here, and he ran around.
I think my daughter was seven or eight then. He treated us great.
Another time was at the Hall of Fame thing. He treated me great.
Like I said, Mark Messier is a legend here. Is it ESPN that he does?
Is that the one? He does great on that.
I have nothing but respect for him.”
Messier’s issue wasn’t with Babcock alone. The former Oilers captain took aim at the way the hiring unfolded, saying he believed there should be a clear divide between players, coaches and management. He specifically objected to players being involved in the process.
“I am absolutely shocked they hired him,” he said during the ESPN NHL Opening Night media call, transcribed by ESPN’s Greg Wyshynski. “I’m absolutely shocked from the stories that I heard from very good, reputable, character people about the way they were treated. It’s been no secret.
“I agree with Ray. The way that he was onboarded through the players interviewing him is absolutely something that I’ve never heard of before.
Maybe the game has changed, and that’s the way it’s going. Great.
I don’t know. It certainly wasn’t like that.”
Babcock made it clear he wasn’t spending much time on outside opinions. His morning, he said, was taken up by something far more personal.
“I got up this morning, my deer pictures were right there,” said Babcock. “I had about 1,000 of them I had to delete. That’s my social media.
“My dad had this unbelievable line. He said, ‘Son, if your knees hit my kitchen table, I probably care what you think.’
In other words, it’s your family and the people around you. The rest is just noise, man.
I’ve been doing this a long time.”
Connor McDavid, as usual, didn’t give much away when the topic came up. He kept his answer short and direct.
“Everybody’s got their opinion,” said McDavid. “Obviously he’s one of the greats of the game, and he’s entitled to his opinion.”
Zach Hyman, though, answered with more force. Edmonton’s new assistant captain pointed to Messier’s status in the game, but also pushed back hard on the negativity.
“He was number 11, I was number 11 for the longest time, and I couldn’t wear the jersey here because he’s revered here,” said Hyman. “He’s a legend with the Oilers and in hockey, obviously. So I think that everybody in the game respects him.
“I think if he really wants to see what’s going on firsthand, he’s more than welcome to come here. I think Oilers fans love him.
There’s a lot of excitement. There’s a lot of positivity here.
Nothing but good is happening right now. So to try and spew something negative right now - I think it’s his opinion.
Like I said, I have a lot of respect for him, and if he’d like to see what’s going on, he’s more than welcome to come down.”
In Other News...
Messier Just Turned Up The Heat On Oilers' Babcock Debate
The Oilers decision to bring in Mike Babcock this summer already carried plenty of baggage, and Mark Messier has now poured more fuel on the debate. Edmonton turned to Babcock in June after moving on from Kris Knoblauch, a move that drew attention not just because of the coaching change, but because of Babcocks long and controversial track record around player treatment.
Messier publicly questioned the organizations judgment, saying he was stunned by the hire in light of the reports that have followed Babcock for years. The fact that Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl interviewed and backed the move only added another layer to the conversation, especially with the NHL having previously reviewed the situation and cleared Babcock before Edmonton made its call. [Read more 🡒]
Leo Carlsson Debate Just Put Ducks Leadership Under The Microscope
A broader debate around team authority has crept back into the conversation around the Oilers, and Mark Messier is adding his voice to it. The Hall of Famer took issue with the way Edmonton handled its coaching search, arguing that letting players carry so much weight in the process muddies the line between the locker room and the front office and can create problems the moment things go sideways.
The timing matters because Edmonton is trying to operate like a serious contender, which leaves little room for uncertainty about who makes the decisions. Messiers comments have revived a familiar question for the Oilers: how much influence should the core players have when the organization is making one of its biggest calls, and where does leadership start to blur into ownership? [Read more 🡒]
Messiers Oilers Blast Just Raised A Bigger Leadership Question
Mark Messiers latest blast landed with the kind of force only a former captain of his stature can generate, because it was aimed not at a bad shift or a rough stretch, but at the Oilers larger sense of direction. Edmontons decision to hire Mike Babcock already invited scrutiny, and Messier added another layer by framing it as more than just a coaching choice, turning the focus toward how the organization makes major calls.
What makes the criticism sting is the leadership angle. Messier took aim at the process behind the hire and the way the clubs leadership group fit into it, raising a familiar question for a team that has spent years trying to balance star power with structure. For an Oilers team still trying to define its identity, the debate now is not only about the coach they brought in, but about who should have had a voice in getting him there. [Read more 🡒]