Oilers PK Problem Is Putting Pressure On Stan Bowman

The Edmonton Oilers must urgently address their lack of a penalty-killing right-shot center to sustain their competitive edge and alleviate Leon Draisaitl's overextended role.

The Edmonton Oilers have plenty going for them: elite talent, solid defensive structure and strong goaltending. But as the trade deadline approaches, one roster hole stands out, and it’s hard to miss.

They need a fourth-line right-shot centre who can kill penalties and handle himself in the faceoff circle.

Rookie Owen Michaels got off to a promising start, but he’s not NHL-ready yet. That doesn’t make him a miss; it just means he needs more time in the American League before he’s ready to fill that job on a contending roster. The Oilers may still see him as a future option there, but for now, he’s not the answer.

The bigger issue is how often Leon Draisaitl is being asked to do work on the penalty kill. Edmonton does not need Draisaitl or Connor McDavid on the top power-play unit and then starting every penalty kill, but that’s been the recent direction under head coach Mike Babcock.

Through the first 16 games, Draisaitl had played just 2:18 on the penalty kill, or 8.6 seconds per game. That usage made sense: come on late, finish the kill, then get back to five-on-five.

Lately, though, that’s changed. In the last eight games, Draisaitl has logged 8:01 of PK time. Michaels played 3:27 on the kill against Anaheim, when he was also on for two power-play goals against, but in the seven games since, he has only seen 3:17 total on the penalty kill and didn’t get a shift there in the last two games.

Michaels has been strong on penalty-kill faceoffs, winning 35 of 59, but the ice time tells the real story. He’s averaged 7:46 at five-on-five and only 0:50 on the PK.

The coach’s message has been clear enough: confidence in the rookie has faded. That’s understandable, but it also reinforces the need for a veteran option, ideally a right-shot centre who can kill penalties.

Jason Dickinson should also be used more on the kill.

The numbers back that up. When Dickinson is on the ice, the penalty kill gives up fewer goals.

Last year in the playoffs, the PK allowed one goal in the seven minutes he played, and seven goals in the 14:49 he was off the ice. He knows the job.

Faceoffs haven’t been a problem either; in last year’s postseason he went 4-6 in the dot, while the other centres combined to go 7-9. This season he is 4-4.

That matters because the alternatives haven’t been nearly as effective. Michaels has been excellent on draws, but his goals-against rate is far worse than Dickinson’s.

Michaels sits at 16.34 goals against per 60 on the PK, while Dickinson is at 4.51. Draisaitl’s faceoff work is part of the reason Babcock has leaned on him more, as he’s 22-14 in the dot for 61.1 per cent, but that still doesn’t look like the best long-term solution.

So the need is obvious, and Stan Bowman has 101 days until the trade deadline to find the right fit. The Oilers may not land that player immediately, but the sooner they do, the better. Until then, Dickinson looks like the best internal answer for a bigger role on the first penalty-kill unit.

There aren’t many right-shot centres who kill penalties and are available, but five names stand out among teams currently outside a playoff spot: Kevin Stenlund, Freddy Gaudreau, Colton Sissons, Noel Acciari and Ty Dellandrea.

Stenlund has the strongest appeal of the group. He is the only pending unrestricted free agent, he has Stanley Cup experience and his five-on-five numbers are respectable.

The issue is Utah’s position in the standings. The Mammoth are tied with Winnipeg for the final Wildcard spot, one point ahead of St.

Louis and four ahead of Seattle, though the Kraken have four games in hand. That makes Utah more likely to add than sell.

Sissons is the next-best target, but his cap hit complicates things. Toronto would need to retain salary to make it work, and that’s possible if the Leafs decide they’re sliding into a deeper reset. Sissons has experience, and on a struggling Toronto team his five-on-five results are fine: he’s been outscored 11-10 at even strength and is even in shots for and against at 92-92.

Dellandrea has been heavily outplayed at five-on-five, and Acciari hasn’t been much better, which makes both of them less attractive unless something changes. Gaudreau is solid on the penalty kill, though his five-on-five underlying numbers are rough. Still, Seattle has only four forwards who have outshot opponents while on the ice, and Gaudreau leads the Kraken with seven five-on-five goals while averaging 12:51 per game at five-on-five, so he’s at least worth a deeper look.

The market is thin, and Edmonton may have to widen the search to a left-shot bottom-six centre who can kill penalties and hold his own on draws. But the priority remains the same: find someone who can take pressure off Draisaitl and give the Oilers a steadier answer in a role they clearly need filled.

In Other News...

Oilers Still Waiting On A Crucial Nugent-Hopkins Answer

Ryan Nugent-Hopkins remains out of the Oilers lineup with an undisclosed condition, and the uncertainty around his status has become a familiar frustration for a team already juggling injuries and interruptions this season. He last played against the Toronto Maple Leafs, and since then Edmonton has been waiting for a clearer picture on one of its most important forwards.

Coach Mike Babcock said Nugent-Hopkins was undergoing medical evaluation, with an update expected soon, but for now the club is still in limbo. For an Oilers team trying to keep its season on track, the timing matters almost as much as the diagnosis, because Nugent-Hopkins has already had a campaign marked by stops and starts. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Open An Unexpected Top-Line Audition At A Delicate Time

After the Oilers saw their six-game win streak come to an end, Mike Babcock used practice to take a look at something a little different up front. Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl were split up, and Filip Hallander was moved onto McDavids line as Edmonton continues to sort through its forward mix with Ryan Nugent-Hopkins out for three games while he undergoes ongoing medical tests.

The timing makes the experiment more interesting than it might otherwise be, because the Oilers are trying to keep their top-end attack intact while also managing a lineup that is still in flux. Babcock said the changes are only tentative and could still be adjusted before game time, which leaves Edmonton with an open question about how long this look lasts and whether it becomes more than a short-term test. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Fans Have A Fair Question About Sam OReilly

When the Oilers moved Isaac Howard to Tampa Bay in July 2025 for Sam OReilly, it was the kind of swap that immediately invited comparison. Howard had not found much traction in Edmonton, while OReilly has been handed a more visible role with the Lightning, including time on the power play. For a fan base that watches every prospect move with a sharp eye, the question is simple enough: what does Edmonton actually have in OReilly, and how quickly can he matter?

The answer is still unfolding, and that is part of what makes the deal worth revisiting. OReillys usage in Tampa Bay suggests the Lightning see a player they can trust in more situations, while Edmonton is left evaluating whether the trade was about fit, development, or a longer runway for a player who has yet to fully define himself at the NHL level. In a market that remembers every prospect decision, this one already feels like it could age in more than one direction. [Read more 🡒]