Oilers Penalty Kill Turnaround Is Raising One Important Question

The Edmonton Oilers' revitalized penalty kill strategy, characterized by aggressive play and strategic personnel management, positions them as a rising defensive force in the NHL.

The Edmonton Oilers’ penalty kill is no longer the weak spot it looked like in the opening weeks. What started out around 70 per cent efficiency has climbed to 79.5 per cent, and the results have followed: just two goals allowed over the last 24 opponent chances.

That number has the Oilers sitting 15th in the NHL on the penalty kill, a clear step forward from 2025-26, when they finished 20th at 77.8 per cent. The turnaround hasn’t come from one fix. It’s been a group effort, with forwards, defensemen and goaltenders all helping clean things up.

Up front, Edmonton has leaned on speed. Connor McDavid and Alex Formenton, along with Kasperi Kapanen and Mathieu Joseph, have become the main forward combinations on the kill, and the approach is obvious: pressure, pace and quick exits. Those four can fly, and that speed gives Edmonton a chance to disrupt the power play before it settles in.

They also bring the threat of turning defense into offense. Even when they don’t score, they can eat clock and keep possession long enough to take the sting out of the penalty. All four are inside the top 10 on the team in on-ice goals for per 60 minutes while shorthanded and time on ice while shorthanded.

McDavid is still an elite penalty killer, but there’s also a case for trimming his workload there. Formenton and Kapanen could form a strong top pairing, while Joseph could be used with Jason Dickinson, who already logs plenty of penalty-kill minutes and could take on a full-time role. Since McDavid already carries the second-highest ice time during regular play for Edmonton, easing off his shorthanded usage would make sense if the Oilers want to preserve him and keep the rest of the unit rolling.

There’s also more help on the way. Matt Savoie and Mattias Janmark are expected back from injury, and both can contribute on the kill, giving Mike Babcock even more options.

On the back end, Edmonton appears to have found its top penalty-kill pair in Ryan Shea and Connor Murphy. The two have been strong across the board while shorthanded, using their size to block shots and their puck skills to clear the zone quickly. The second unit has also taken a step, with Mattias Ekholm continuing to do what he’s always done on the kill and Shakir Mukhamadullin taking on a bigger role beside him.

Mukhamadullin has moved into the top 10 on the team in shorthanded minutes, including more than six minutes in Edmonton’s 5-2 win over the Philadelphia Flyers. He’s posted a goals-against per 60 minutes of just 4.5 while on the kill, and Babcock has clearly taken notice.

That matters even more with Jake Walman’s future in question. With uncertainty there, Edmonton needs its penalty-kill defenders to keep handling those minutes while also carrying important regular shifts. So far, they’ve done exactly that.

And then there’s the goaltending. Devon Levi and Tristan Jarry have been a major part of the improvement, stepping in with timely saves when the structure breaks down. The Oilers have faced the sixth-most shots in the NHL while shorthanded, but they’ve allowed only the 15th-most goals, which says plenty about the work their goalies have done.

If this keeps trending up, Edmonton gets even tougher to handle. The power play is already one of the league’s best, and the penalty kill is starting to look like it belongs right alongside it.

In Other News...

Oilers Still Waiting On A Crucial Nugent-Hopkins Answer

Ryan Nugent-Hopkins remains out of the Oilers lineup with an undisclosed condition, and the uncertainty around his status has become a familiar frustration for a team already juggling injuries and interruptions this season. He last played against the Toronto Maple Leafs, and since then Edmonton has been waiting for a clearer picture on one of its most important forwards.

Coach Mike Babcock said Nugent-Hopkins was undergoing medical evaluation, with an update expected soon, but for now the club is still in limbo. For an Oilers team trying to keep its season on track, the timing matters almost as much as the diagnosis, because Nugent-Hopkins has already had a campaign marked by stops and starts. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Open An Unexpected Top-Line Audition At A Delicate Time

After the Oilers saw their six-game win streak come to an end, Mike Babcock used practice to take a look at something a little different up front. Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl were split up, and Filip Hallander was moved onto McDavids line as Edmonton continues to sort through its forward mix with Ryan Nugent-Hopkins out for three games while he undergoes ongoing medical tests.

The timing makes the experiment more interesting than it might otherwise be, because the Oilers are trying to keep their top-end attack intact while also managing a lineup that is still in flux. Babcock said the changes are only tentative and could still be adjusted before game time, which leaves Edmonton with an open question about how long this look lasts and whether it becomes more than a short-term test. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Fans Have A Fair Question About Sam OReilly

When the Oilers moved Isaac Howard to Tampa Bay in July 2025 for Sam OReilly, it was the kind of swap that immediately invited comparison. Howard had not found much traction in Edmonton, while OReilly has been handed a more visible role with the Lightning, including time on the power play. For a fan base that watches every prospect move with a sharp eye, the question is simple enough: what does Edmonton actually have in OReilly, and how quickly can he matter?

The answer is still unfolding, and that is part of what makes the deal worth revisiting. OReillys usage in Tampa Bay suggests the Lightning see a player they can trust in more situations, while Edmonton is left evaluating whether the trade was about fit, development, or a longer runway for a player who has yet to fully define himself at the NHL level. In a market that remembers every prospect decision, this one already feels like it could age in more than one direction. [Read more 🡒]