The Oilers have spent the first stretch of November winning, but the way they’re getting there is starting to tell its own story. Edmonton has banked seven of a possible 10 points in its first five games of the month, and it has done it in a compressed run of five games over nine days. That pace is about to get even tougher, with 10 more games left before the month is out and a six-game road trip beginning Saturday.
That kind of stretch puts a spotlight on the whole roster, not just the names at the top. The Oilers have already worked through a lighter October, but November is where the depth gets tested, especially with quality opponents ahead and the team trying to stay near the top of the Western Conference. Edmonton is also still missing Matt Savoie, whose absence will continue to be felt through the rest of a crowded month.
At the same time, the workload on the stars has been heavy. Connor McDavid has logged more than 24 minutes in each of his last four games, and even the Nov. 1 matchup against the New York Rangers only gave him 23:22.
Leon Draisaitl has been right there with him, averaging 23 minutes a night over the last five games. Under Kris Knoblach, Draisaitl’s usage was about the same, while McDavid is now averaging nearly a minute more per game this season and leads the league in average time on ice.
The criticism that Edmonton leans too hard on its best players has followed the team before, and so far that pattern hasn’t gone away.
That’s why the next few weeks matter so much. The coaching staff came into the season talking about spreading the minutes around and making sure everyone has a chance to contribute.
It’s the kind of balance that can carry a team through a long regular season and keep the stars fresher for April, May and, ideally, June. With the Oilers set to play their 20th game tonight, the question is whether that balance is coming.
Monday’s 3-1 win over the Rangers showed both sides of the issue. Edmonton’s fourth line barely saw the ice.
Max Jones played 4:42, Trent Frederic 5:40, and neither of them appeared in the third period. Owen Michaels had only a couple of shifts and finished with a little over seven minutes, while the night’s heavy lifting fell to Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Zach Hyman, Kasperi Kapanen, McDavid and Draisaitl.
By the Oilers’ own standards, it wasn’t a clean performance, and the numbers backed that up. McDavid, Draisaitl and Vasily Podkolzin were the only skaters to finish with an expected goal share above 50 per cent, while Jason Dickinson, Alex Formenton, Mathieu Joseph and Owen Michaels all landed below 30 per cent.
There’s a case to be made that the bottom six hasn’t had enough time to settle in. Edmonton won the game, so the result is what matters most, but giving those forwards more runway in the second period and early in the third might have changed the feel of the night. Instead, the stars carried the load again.
The same pattern showed up Saturday against the Canucks. Frederic, Jones and Michaels again saw very limited minutes, and that came in a game where Ryan Nugent-Hopkins left a minute into the second period, leaving the Oilers short a forward for the rest of the night. The result was another night where the top six had to do the bulk of the work.
The defence, though, has been handled differently. Evan Bouchard is sitting eighth in the league in average ice time at 25:36, but there is clearly trust in the top four.
Ryan Shea is averaging 23:06, Mattias Ekholm 21:03 and Connor Murphy 20:55. As Shakir Mukhamadullin keeps moving forward, Bouchard’s minutes should come down a bit.
Jake Walman, meanwhile, does not have Mike Babcock’s trust and is expected to sit again tonight against the Flyers. Rather than forcing the issue, the coaching staff has chosen to dress players it believes can help.
That same mindset may need to carry over to the forwards.
If the current group can’t handle more than a handful of minutes a night, Edmonton may have to look elsewhere. Quinn Hutson and Aku Räty are the strongest candidates for a look in the NHL, as they lead the Condors in scoring this season.
Josh Samanski has gotten off to a slow start, which opens the door for Connor Clattenburg as well, especially if the Oilers want some sandpaper in the bottom six. His energy and physicality could make him a fit in a limited role.
However it happens, the Oilers need more from the lower half of the lineup. A more workable distribution would look something like 20-21 minutes for the top line, 17 for the second, 14 for the third and 9-10 for the fourth, assuming the game doesn’t feature a pile of power plays. That kind of spread would give Edmonton more balance, lighten the burden on McDavid and Draisaitl, and leave a little more in the tank late in games and at the start of the next one.
The Oilers have found ways to win early this season, but they’ve done it with a heavy dose of their biggest names. That formula can get you through a short stretch.
It won’t hold up over 84 games, and it certainly won’t be enough for a deep playoff run. With November turning into a grind, Edmonton needs Mike Babcock to find more trust in the bottom six, whether that comes from giving current players more rope or making changes to the lineup.
In Other News...
Connor Murphy Is Becoming An Oilers Problem They Can't Ignore
Even with the Oilers piling up wins, Connor Murphys place on the blue line has become harder to gloss over. The veteran defenseman has drawn criticism for the numbers underneath the surface, and the concern is less about one bad night than a pattern that has made his minutes a talking point around the team. Edmontons overall record can hide a lot, but it does not erase the fact that Murphy has not driven play the way the club needs from a regular defenseman.
The bigger issue is that Murphy may not be the only problem, which is what makes this situation tricky for Edmonton. The second defensive pairing has been thin enough that his struggles are being viewed in the context of weak support around him, and the Oilers next move could depend on who returns to the lineup and how much depth they can trust. If the team wants to stabilize that side of the defense, it may have to make a decision that changes Murphys role, even if that answer is still unfolding. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Trade Buzz Suddenly Centers On One Believable Star Target
The Oilers have not made any recent trades, but the conversation around their next move is starting to sharpen. If Edmonton decides to add, the focus would be on either a top-six forward or a top-four defenseman, which is exactly the kind of upgrade that can matter most when a contender is trying to squeeze a little more out of its roster.
Among the names being weighed, Quinn Hughes looks like a long shot and Elias Pettersson comes with obvious contract questions, leaving the discussion to drift toward a different established star. Roman Josi stands out as the cleanest fit for Edmontons needs and the most believable of the options, even if there is still plenty standing between speculation and an actual deal. [Read more 🡒]
Babcocks Return To Toronto Adds Extra Heat For The Oilers
Mike Babcocks return to Toronto gives this Oilers road trip a little extra edge, even beyond the standings and the usual late-season noise. Now behind Edmontons bench, the former Maple Leafs coach is back in the building where he spent a memorable stretch with one of hockeys biggest franchises, and he spent time reflecting on both the good and the difficult parts of that run while also taking stock of his current group, which sits atop the Pacific Division.
For the Oilers, the setting adds another layer to a meeting that already matters, with Toronto trying to steady itself under new coach Jim Hiller while the Leafs continue to search for traction in the Atlantic Division. Babcocks presence turns the matchup into more than just another cross-conference game, because the conversation around it is as much about history and unfinished business as it is about the points on the line. [Read more 🡒]