The Penguins’ swap of Filip Hallander for Spencer Stastney came off as one of those trades that makes you stop and check the roster math before you judge the players involved.
Hallander had just started to look like he belonged. He missed most of last season after a blood clot that required a 10-month recovery, then came back and posted a goal and two assists in Pittsburgh’s season opener.
That promising start didn’t buy him much breathing room. He was scratched in the Penguins’ October 5 loss to the Winnipeg Jets and then moved to the Oilers shortly after.
The message wasn’t that Hallander wasn’t good enough. It was that Pittsburgh had too many forwards and he became the odd man out.
That’s what made the whole sequence feel so odd. The Penguins picked Hallander in the second round, 58th overall, in 2018, but he took a long road to North America. When he finally arrived for the 2021-22 season, he played 61 AHL games and put up 14 goals and 14 assists, which was fine but not eye-opening.
The story around him was never just about the ice, though. Pittsburgh originally sent Hallander and a first-round pick to the Toronto Maple Leafs for Kasperi Kapanen, only to get him back later along with a seventh-round pick in the Jared McCann deal. That made his Penguins tenure feel like a loop they kept coming back to.
His on-ice production eventually picked up. In his second AHL season, he scored 11 goals and added 22 assists in 43 games.
After that, he left for Sweden and spent two seasons there, finishing his second SHL campaign with 26 goals and 27 assists in 51 games. That performance earned him a two-year, one-way contract with Pittsburgh that guaranteed NHL money.
Last season, he managed four points in 13 NHL games before the blood clot shut him down.
From the Penguins’ side, this was a pure roster squeeze. They came into the season with 18 NHL-calibre forwards, and with Bryan Rust returning from injured reserve, a move had to be made.
Edmonton showed interest in Hallander, and Pittsburgh sent him out because it needed to clear space. At 26 with only 18 NHL games under his belt, he was the easiest player to move.
The weird part is that this is exactly the kind of player the Kyle Dubas-era Penguins have tried to find. They’ve spent that time looking for skaters who had been overlooked, giving them a chance, and getting results from players such as Ryan Shea, Justin Brazeau, Connor Dewar, Anthony Mantha, Parker Wotherspoon, and possibly Nicholas Robertson this season. Yet Hallander, a drafted and developed Penguin, couldn’t get the same runway.
Edmonton, meanwhile, can give him one. The Oilers have more room in their bottom six, and Hallander will get a real shot to keep his NHL career alive.
They had apparently been watching him for a while and liked the offense, work ethic, and pace. In return, they gave up a defenseman who wasn’t playing and likely wouldn’t have much of a role there anyway.
Pittsburgh may not love the return, though Stastney probably won’t see much action there either. The Penguins already have a defensive logjam, and Owen Pickering is an older prospect who should be in the NHL.
In the end, this is the sort of move that lands in the middle. Hallander wasn’t a franchise-changing piece, and if Pittsburgh made a mistake, it wasn’t a massive one.
But the larger issue is hard to miss: the Penguins keep talking about the future while not really having room for it. Josh Yohe of The Athletic pointed out that they’re stuck between trying to stay respectable now and building for later, and that leaves players like Pickering, Avery Hayes, and Rutger McGroarty without much of a path to minutes this season unless injuries open doors or the team falls out of the race and sells off veterans.
A different return might have made more sense. A mid-round draft pick would have been easier to understand than another defenseman they don’t really need. Still, Dubas and his staff have found value in reclamation projects before, so maybe they see something in Stastney.
As for Hallander, the early signs were encouraging beyond the points. He posted an 86.31% expected goals share at five-on-five, a tiny sample but a notable one.
It suggested a player helping drive play rather than just catching a few lucky breaks. Edmonton can use that kind of energy in its bottom six.
The Penguins also may not be done dealing with the fallout from their own roster choices. Brazeau still has to return at some point, and there isn’t a clear spot waiting for him either.
For now, the trade looks like a small, sensible transaction on paper. Whether it stays that way depends on what Hallander becomes in Edmonton.
In Other News...
Oilers Finally Get Help Back As One Lineup Question Looms
The Oilers are finally getting some reinforcements back into the fold, with Zach Hyman, Colton Dach and Jake Walman all set to rejoin the lineup for the upcoming game against Utah. Its a welcome development for a team that has been juggling injuries and trying to keep the roster afloat while key pieces were missing.
Edmonton is still not close to being fully healthy, but the next stretch could bring even more relief. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins is nearing his season debut, and Jason Dickinson is expected back soon after, giving the club a chance to steady its lines and sort out a lineup picture that has been in flux for weeks. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Trade Radar Just Raised One Big Penguins Deadline Question
The Penguins have made it clear they are willing to move veteran pieces if it helps open the door for younger players, and that has put a familiar deadline name back on Edmontons radar. Bryan Rust, Rickard Rakell, Erik Karlsson and even Evgeni Malkin have all been mentioned as possible trade candidates, but from the Oilers side the fit question is really about which of those players best complements a contender already built around elite center depth.
Rust is the name drawing the most interest for a reason, with his pace and puck pursuit making him a natural fit in a top-six role alongside Connor McDavid or Leon Draisaitl. Any serious pursuit would almost certainly have to come with meaningful futures attached, though, and the frameworks floating around center on draft picks and prospects rather than a simple rental-style swap. No deal is done yet, but the line between speculative deadline chatter and real trade pressure is starting to look thinner. [Read more 🡒]
Tristan Jarry Is Giving The Oilers A Goalie Decision To Make
Tristan Jarry has already forced his way into the early-season conversation for the Oilers after getting two starts in 2026-27. He opened with a 19-save effort against the San Jose Sharks, then followed it up with another solid outing against the Utah Mammoth as Edmonton continues to sort through a position that has too often been a problem area for this team.
The latest start only added to the sense that the Oilers have options now, which is a very different place for this group to be. Jarry did allow two goals against Utah, but he still came up with timely stops and helped Edmonton come away with the win, leaving the coaching staff with a real decision to make as multiple goalies are performing well. [Read more 🡒]