Oilers Hot Start Is Hiding One Big Cup Contender Concern

The Edmonton Oilers' hot streak has ignited speculation about their Stanley Cup aspirations, but questions remain about their depth and goaltending durability.

The Edmonton Oilers are already sitting near the top of the league, but the case for calling them Stanley Cup favourites still comes down to two big questions: can the goaltending hold, and can they add another real difference-maker up front?

That’s where this season gets interesting. More than a quarter of the way through the regular season, no team has won more games than Edmonton.

Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Evan Bouchard are all on pace for historic numbers, and even if that kind of production doesn’t last all year, it’s a reminder of why this team has been so difficult to beat in a seven-game series. When those stars are rolling, they can take over games almost by themselves.

Still, there are reasons people are pumping the brakes. The Oilers need more depth scoring.

Their five-on-five play has slipped over the last seven games, even though they’ve won five of them. And some around the league still see the goaltending as something that won’t last.

Even with those concerns, Edmonton is first in the standings while some major power rankings have them outside the top five. So what would it take for the rest of the league to buy in?

The first box is goaltending that stays competent.

The Oilers haven’t had elite goaltending since 2016-17, when Cam Talbot finished fourth in Vezina voting. Since then, the results have ranged from average to bad to decent.

This year, though, it’s been excellent. Tristan Jarry and Devon Levi have combined for a .922 five-on-five save percentage, which ranks third in the NHL.

If you remove the first two games of the season, they’re actually first.

That level probably won’t last forever, but Edmonton doesn’t need perfection. Over the last two seasons, the Oilers finished 32nd and 23rd in five-on-five save percentage, and they still got back to the Stanley Cup Final once despite sub-par goaltending.

The question now is whether Jarry, Levi and eventually Andersen can keep the team in the top ten. A five-on-five save percentage around .909 would be enough for that, and right now the Oilers are well above it.

There’s also a built-in safety net. If one goalie hits a rough patch, the team brought in three goalies for a reason. If one struggles, they can lean on the other until Andersen returns.

The second thing Edmonton needs is a top-six forward who changes the shape of the lineup.

The numbers make the need obvious. With McDavid and Draisaitl on the ice at five-on-five, the Oilers are outscoring opponents 25-7.

With both off, they’re minus-10. With Bouchard on the ice, they’re plus-27.

With all three off, they’re minus-16.

That’s why Stan Bowman’s biggest shopping priority should be an impact forward who can lift the team when the stars aren’t out there.

There are two paths. One is to bring in a high-end scoring winger and split up McDavid and Draisaitl.

The idea is simple: keep an elite centre on the ice for most of the game and make life miserable for opponents. In that setup, the top nine could look like this:

New Addition - McDavid - Hyman

Podkolzin - Draisaitl - Kapanen

Nugent-Hopkins - Dickinson - Savoie

The other route is to keep the two stars together and add another elite centre. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins has one even-strength goal in 12 games, and while there’s been some encouraging chemistry with Colton Dach, that pairing looks more like a strong third-line option than a second-line engine on a contender. The Oilers have outscored opponents 6-2 in their 70 five-on-five minutes together, but that doesn’t solve the bigger need for more offence behind the top group.

If Edmonton landed a true 2C, the top nine could be arranged like this:

Draisaitl- McDavid - Podkolzin

Podkolzin - New Addition - Savoie

Nugent-Hopkins - Dickinson - Kapanen

However they choose to build it, the point is the same: one more impact top-six forward would give Edmonton a top nine that’s hard to match.

And that’s why the Oilers are already close. Bet365 has them at +750, the second-best odds in the league behind the Carolina Hurricanes at +550. If the goaltending stays steady and the scoring depth gets a boost, it becomes a lot easier to make the case that Edmonton should be viewed as the Stanley Cup favourite.

In Other News...

Sabres Fans May Not Like What This Devon Levi Story Suggests

Devon Levis path has already taken a strange turn since Buffalo moved on from him, and the early returns in Edmonton have only made the story more interesting. The Oilers have been one of the NHLs surprise teams out of the gate, and Levi is part of that broader picture after landing in a situation where the organization has embraced him and given him room to settle in.

For the Sabres, the move always carried a little more baggage than a simple goalie swap, because Levi was never viewed as a cookie-cutter prospect. Edmonton, though, has taken a different approach, and that contrast is what makes this storyline worth watching now. If Levi keeps trending the way he has, the conversation around Buffalos decision only gets louder, and the Oilers may end up with a piece that looks far more important than the market originally suggested. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Trade Debate Just Shifted To One Crucial Roster Question

The Oilers ongoing search for a roster upgrade has only sharpened the debate around how they want to build around Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. Edmonton has already been tinkering with its top-end alignment, even splitting the two during games at times, and that has only added another layer to the trade conversation as the club weighs whether a move should bring more depth, more balance, or both.

Jake Walman is part of that broader discussion after being a healthy scratch in Florida, though any path involving him is complicated by his no-movement clause. And while the front office continues to explore what a meaningful addition might look like, the real question is less about whether Edmonton can find help and more about which kind of help actually fits the cap, the roster, and the teams needs. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Face A Massive Sidney Crosby Decision They Can't Ignore

The idea of Sidney Crosby in an Oilers uniform is the kind of speculation that instantly grabs attention, even if it starts from a long shot. Pittsburghs struggles have pushed more eyes toward the possibility of a rebuild, and Edmontons place in the conversation says plenty about how aggressively the market would have to be framed for a player of Crosbys stature.

For the Oilers, the appeal is obvious: a franchise center who changes the tone of a roster and fits the urgency of a team trying to win now. But the reality is still rooted in hypotheticals, with no sign Crosby is asking out and no indication Pittsburgh is ready to move him, which leaves the whole discussion hanging on the kind of conditions that would have to align for a blockbuster to even become thinkable. [Read more 🡒]