Oilers Goaltending Chaos Has Turned Into A Debate Fans Didn't Expect

Can the Edmonton Oilers maintain their momentum despite a rotating roster of injured and recovering goaltenders?

The Edmonton Oilers have spent much of this season trying to piece together their crease on the fly, but the situation is finally easing up.

Devon Levi came back from a groin injury on Saturday, Tristan Jarry is healthy again after missing Thursday’s game against Anaheim with an illness, and Frederik Andersen is still out with the injury he suffered in the offseason. For a team that entered training camp with three goaltenders and somehow ended up using four different netminders plus an emergency backup in just 10 games, that counts as progress.

Levi’s return was a big one. He had won six of his first seven starts before getting hurt against Carolina on Oct. 22, and he said he felt something go wrong in the third period even though he wasn’t thinking about leaving the game.

“I wasn't going to get out of that game unless I was dead,” Levi said.

That left Jarry to carry the load while Levi missed seven games, and he answered the call. The 31-year-old put together back-to-back shutouts against Calgary and the New York Islanders, then kept giving Edmonton steady work on its road trip through New York.

“With Dev hurt, I knew I'd get a little bit more work,” Jarry said following the Islanders game. “So just being able to take care of that opportunity and kind of just run with it… It's been fun, to say the least.”

The Oilers also got a strong outing from Matt Tomkins, who made 27 saves in a 4-1 win over the New York Rangers at Madison Square Garden. The 32-year-old Edmonton native came into that game with only six NHL starts and no league appearances since April 2024.

Then Jarry got sick, and the crease picture got even stranger. Edmonton had to dress Tomkins and emergency backup Brett Epp against Anaheim on Thursday night because Andersen and Levi were both unavailable.

That probably wasn’t what Stan Bowman had in mind when he built this roster.

Levi returned Saturday against Vancouver and stopped 20 shots in Edmonton’s 4-2 win. Jarry was healthy enough to back him up, and Tomkins was sent back to Bakersfield. After the game, Levi talked about the kind of matchup he enjoys.

“It was a tight game,” Levi said afterward. “I love playing those games, going into the third period (tied) 1-1, knowing that I’m probably going to have to come up with one or two (big saves).

Love it, man. So it was a fun game.”

Jason Dickinson also praised Levi’s approach.

“He's got all the characteristics of a gamer,” Jason Dickinson said. “He fights hard, he battles hard, he's been itching to get back. It's definitely good for us to have him.”

Now Edmonton has two healthy goaltenders who have been playing well, and Andersen’s eventual return should only help. Jarry has played well enough to keep earning chances, Levi has won seven of eight games, and Andersen was supposed to be the starter to begin with.

Through 18 games, the Oilers are 12-3-3, and their goaltending has held together better than the injury list might suggest. Still, four goaltenders and an emergency backup before reaching 20 games is a little much.

Maybe somebody really should check for a curse.

In Other News...

Connor Murphy Is Giving The Oilers Something They Desperately Need

Connor Murphy has carved out a very specific job for the Oilers this season, and it is the kind of role that does not always show up neatly in the numbers. Through the 2026-27 campaign, he has been leaned on for a physical, defense-first presence, taking tough defensive-zone assignments and giving Edmonton a steadier edge around its own net. Even with the traditional and advanced stats not exactly jumping off the page, his value has been tied to the little things that matter in tight games.

Recent matchups with the Canucks and Rangers offered a reminder of why the Oilers keep finding ways to use him. Murphys shot-blocking, willingness to clear traffic and general grit have stood out in moments when Edmonton needed a stop more than a highlight. It is the kind of impact analytics can struggle to fully capture, but the coaching staff and teammates can see it every night, and that sort of reliability is becoming increasingly important as the games get heavier. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Fans Just Earned A Wild Online Reputation

A new social-media study has given Oilers fans an unexpected kind of bragging right, even if it is the sort that comes with a raised eyebrow. Action Network looked at more than 9.7 million Reddit comments across 205 professional sports team communities in 2026, measuring how often fans used profanity, and Edmonton came out on top in a field that stretched across multiple major leagues.

The results put the Oilers crowd in some familiar company, with other passionate fan bases from around the sports world showing up near the top as well. At the other end of the spectrum, the St. Louis Cardinals were identified as the most polite fan base, a reminder that not every online home for a team is built on the same level of intensity. [Read more 🡒]

Leafs Suddenly Have A Bigger Problem Than Their Recent Slide

The Maple Leafs recent slide already had plenty of people looking for answers, and now the injury report is adding another layer of concern. Colton Sissons is out week-to-week with a lower-body injury, while Morgan Rielly is day-to-day after getting hurt in the loss to Montreal. Kirill Marchenko also remains week-to-week with a lower-body injury, leaving Toronto to juggle its lineup a little more than it would like at this point in the season.

Ryan Tverberg was recalled from the AHL as part of the roster shuffle, with Vinni Lettieri sent down, a move that at least gives Toronto another body as it tries to steady itself. Sergei Bobrovsky is scheduled to start in net for the upcoming game, but the bigger question for the Leafs is how long they can keep absorbing absences before the standings start to reflect the damage. [Read more 🡒]