Oilers Fans May Feel Very Different About That Broberg Holloway Debate

Despite new acquisitions and roster talent, the St. Louis Blues continue to battle stagnation and inconsistency in the highly competitive Central Division.

Edmonton Oilers fans have had plenty of reason to keep an eye on St. Louis since the Blues landed Philip Broberg and Dylan Holloway. But if the idea was that those offer sheets would push the Blues into a new tier, the results so far have been a lot more ordinary than dramatic.

St. Louis sits tied for sixth in the Central Division and 17th in the league, and the season has mostly looked like more of the same: flashes of offense, stretches of inconsistency, and a team still trying to prove it belongs in the next class of contenders. The Blues have been stuck in the middle for years, and even with a few promising young pieces in the mix, they haven’t broken through.

Thursday’s 5-2 win over a bad Penguins team gave the Blues a needed result, but it didn’t exactly scream arrival. Holloway scored twice, though he has just six goals this year and has had trouble staying healthy throughout his pro career.

Broberg didn’t record a point and finished minus-1. Then came Saturday’s wild 9-6 win over the Blues, where Holloway added an assist and Broberg chipped in a goal, two assists and a plus-3.

There is talent here, no question. Broberg, Jimmy Snuggerud, Justin Barron, Jake Neighbours and Mason McTavish are part of a young core that gives St.

Louis something to work with. But the bigger picture still looks muddy.

The Blues have been spinning their wheels in a strong division, and the gap between “interesting” and “good enough” remains wide.

The numbers tell the story. St.

Louis has scored 76 goals and allowed 73, which doesn’t exactly point to a playoff team. Only the lowly Chicago Blackhawks are behind them in the division.

At the other end, Jordan Binnington’s season has been rough, with a 4.77 goals-against average and an .847 save percentage. If the Blues are going to make a real push, they’ll need multiple long winning streaks to get there.

Broberg has become one of the more important pieces on the roster. He’s currently the team’s third-leading scorer and is skating on the top defensive pairing with Logan Mailloux.

The offense is moving in the right direction, but his defensive game still has questions around it. He was plus-21 in his first season, then plus-14 last year, and now sits at plus-4.

For all the talk about the blue line, he’s still the best of a shaky group.

Holloway’s case is different, but just as revealing. Edmonton could have kept him or gone in another direction with Vasily Podkolzin, and the comparison hasn’t been kind to the Blues.

Holloway has six goals and 12 assists for 18 points in 23 games this season, while Podkolzin has 13 goals and eight assists for 21 points in 25 games. The money only makes the contrast sharper: Podkolzin is at $2.95 million a year, while Holloway is at $7.75 million a year.

The Blues forward was supposed to bring a heavy game and some finishing touch, but the penalty totals don’t match that reputation. He has 86 penalty minutes in 247 NHL games, and this season he has zero.

He hasn’t spent a minute in the box in 2026-27. Across two seasons in St.

Louis, he has only 30 penalty minutes. Podkolzin, by comparison, has 33 penalty minutes this season alone.

Injuries have also been part of Holloway’s story. He still hasn’t played a full NHL season, and that was true in Edmonton and in the minors too. He came close in his first year with the Blues, but last season he dressed for only 59 games.

So yes, the Blues have some pieces. And yes, it’s still early, with only a quarter of the season gone. But for now, the bigger label still fits: this is a team that has been mid for a long time, and the Broberg-Holloway gamble hasn’t changed that yet.

In Other News...

Oilers Are Suddenly Linked To A Blue-Line Move With Huge Stakes

The Oilers are suddenly being tied to a blue-line swing with real long-term implications, as reports have Edmonton in the mix for Red Wings defenseman Simon Edvinsson before Dec. 1. Edvinsson remains unsigned and is not with Detroit right now, which has only added to the sense that his situation could turn quickly if a contract does not come together. For Edmonton, the appeal is obvious: a young defenseman with upside who could fit into a roster that is always looking for more stability on the back end.

Getting there would not be simple, though. The Oilers would have to navigate their cap situation carefully and put together a trade package that likely includes roster players, prospects and draft picks to even have a chance. And with the possibility that Edvinsson could end up playing in Sweden if no deal is reached, the clock only makes the stakes feel higher for a team that knows how valuable a move like this could be. [Read more 🡒]

Hurricanes Win Over Edmonton Came With One Big Twist

The Oilers 7-4 loss to Carolina on the back end of a weekend set had plenty of familiar frustrations, but the night also carried a pregame wrinkle that made the matchup stand out. The Hurricanes honored Taylor Hall for reaching 1,000 NHL games before puck drop, turning the evening into a celebration before Edmonton had to try to steady itself in a tough road spot.

Instead, the game unraveled in the second period, when Carolina struck three times in quick succession and Edmonton never really recovered. The Oilers also lost Zach Hyman to a migraine that affected his vision, adding to an already messy night, and the officiating only sharpened the frustration around the result as Connor Murphys recent penalty problems continued to draw attention. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Take Another Brutal Hit In An Already Thin Stretch

The Oilers latest trip through a thin stretch got a little tougher in Carolina, where their winning streak came to an end and the injury list picked up another name. Zach Hyman left the game because of a migraine after playing less than nine minutes, a frustrating development for a team already trying to manage a banged-up lineup and keep its rhythm intact.

There was at least one bright spot in the loss, with rookie Owen Michaels scoring his third goal of the season. But for Edmonton, the bigger concern is how quickly the margins are shrinking as the schedule rolls on, especially when one of the lineups most reliable pieces cant stay in the game long enough to settle in. [Read more 🡒]