The Edmonton Oilers are facing a classic goaltending conundrum-three capable netminders, but only so much ice time to go around. With Tristan Jarry back healthy and Connor Ingram playing sharp, Calvin Pickard suddenly finds himself on the outside looking in. And while the numbers may point toward an easy decision, the impact of potentially moving on from Pickard goes well beyond what shows up on the stat sheet.
Why Pickard Matters More Than You Think
Pickard has been more than just a depth option in net-he’s been a stabilizing force, both on and off the ice. In the room, he’s the kind of teammate every coach wants and every player respects.
He’s not flashy, doesn’t chase headlines, and won’t be the first name fans chant from the stands. But inside that locker room, he’s earned his stripes by showing up, doing the work, and keeping things grounded.
When the pressure ratcheted up during the Oilers’ recent playoff runs, Pickard didn’t flinch. He stepped in when called upon and delivered the kind of calm, composed play that teams rely on deep into the postseason. Sure, his regular-season numbers in 2025-26 may not jump off the page, but when the stakes were highest, he showed exactly why he belonged.
That kind of presence-especially from a depth goalie-is invaluable. Younger players notice.
Teammates take comfort. Coaches trust him.
And in a league where momentum can shift on a single bounce, having a steady hand like Pickard’s in the mix can make all the difference.
The Locker Room Glue
What really separates Pickard is what he brings when the pads come off. He’s a pro’s pro-quiet, focused, and drama-free.
He’s not in it for the spotlight. He’s in it because he loves the game and understands the privilege of being part of an NHL roster.
That mindset resonates in a room full of personalities and pressure.
Losing a player like that doesn’t always show up in the standings, but it shows up in the feel of a team. Chemistry isn’t built on goals and assists alone-it’s built on trust, accountability, and guys like Pickard who keep the room connected. That’s not easy to replace, no matter how talented the next man up might be.
Looking Ahead
If the Oilers do end up parting ways with Pickard-and all signs suggest that’s where this is headed-it’ll be a move made for roster balance, not because of anything he did wrong. And when that moment comes, it’s worth taking a beat to appreciate what he’s brought to Edmonton. Not just in the crease, but in the culture of the team.
The Oilers may continue to win games without him. But the heart of the locker room? That’s where his absence will be felt the most.