Oilers Depth Problem Is Getting Harder To Ignore On This Road Trip

The Oilers' game against the St. Louis Blues will test whether the team can overcome depth issues that have persisted despite offseason adjustments and strong individual performances.

The Edmonton Oilers are running out of room to ignore the same old problem.

After 25 games, their record still looks strong at 17-5-3, but the warning signs are loud enough to hear all the way to the end of this road trip in St. Louis.

The issue isn’t hard to spot: when Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl are on the ice together, the Oilers look dangerous. When they aren’t, the whole thing starts to wobble.

That split has been stark this season. In 322 minutes and 45 seconds together, McDavid and Draisaitl have driven a 25-9 scoring edge, good for a 73.5 per cent goal share and a plus-16 differential.

Their expected goal share sits at 60.5 per cent, also a plus-5.9. But in the 718 minutes without them, Edmonton has been outscored 27-17, owns just a 38.6 per cent goal share and has been outchanced badly at 36.7 per cent expected goals.

That’s the kind of imbalance that starts to define a team.

Mike Babcock said as much after Saturday’s 7-4 loss to the Carolina Hurricanes, where Edmonton’s depth issues were laid bare.

“I probably should have split up the big guys and tried to give us more depth that way, but in the end we weren’t good enough today.”

“When you look at today, though, I mean, their lineup is definitely deeper than ours, and it showed today.”

The Oilers spent the offseason trying to address exactly this sort of thing. Coming off an embarrassing first-round exit to the Anaheim Ducks, they moved on from the final three years of Darnell Nurse’s contract, turning him into a potential future tree in Shakir Mukhamadullin.

They brought in Devon Levi for a third-round pick, and he’s now flourishing as the starting goalie. Ryan Shea was added and has become a significant piece on the blue line.

Jason Dickinson and Connor Murphy were re-signed, while Mathieu Joseph and Alex Formenton arrived as depth additions, with mixed results.

And yet the same familiar concerns are back in the spotlight.

Injuries have played a role, with the top-six group of Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Zach Hyman and Matthew Savoie rarely intact. But opportunity only matters if somebody grabs it, and that hasn’t happened often enough. Dickinson has been getting caved in since returning from injury, Owen Michaels has looked overwhelmed despite scoring in the first period against Carolina, and the bottom six has been uneven.

Vasily Podkolzin has been a bright spot. Kasperi Kapanen has held his own.

Trent Frederic has been a cardio king, with his only point coming on a goal in the second game of the season. Mathieu Joseph has more to give.

Alex Formenton has speed to burn, but has lost more puck battles than I can count. Filip Hallander has been a bright spot, while Max Jones is little more than a fill-in.

Colton Dach, a natural winger, has been forced to play down the middle and hasn’t looked comfortable there.

The blue line has been steadier, though not without its own issues. Evan Bouchard and Mattias Ekholm continue to carry the load.

Shea has had his moments. Murphy has struggled mightily.

Mukhamadullin has emerged as a capable defenseman, and Ty Emberson has been solid even if the numbers don’t fully support the third pair. Jake Walman, carrying a $7 million salary, has now spent the seventh straight game in the press box and the 10th of the last 13.

That leaves the Oilers with a simple but uncomfortable question: what happens when the players given a chance don’t produce?

The lineup for tonight reflects some of that uncertainty. McDavid is centring his own line with Dach and Hyman, while Draisaitl is between Podkolzin and Kapanen.

Hallander joins Dickinson and Frederic on the third line, with Formenton, Michaels and Joseph on the fourth. On defense, it’s Ekholm and Bouchard, Shea and Murphy, and Mukhamadullin with Walman.

Jarry is in goal.

There’s also a chance the forward group shifts again quickly. McDavid and Draisaitl are centring their own lines, per the Oilers, and Hyman left Saturday’s game against the Hurricanes after dealing with a migraine.

If he can’t go tonight, Hallander could move up while Max Jones fills in on the third line. Nugent-Hopkins has been cleared to play and is expected back Tuesday when Edmonton hosts the Vegas Golden Knights.

St. Louis comes in on tired legs too, after beating the New Jersey Devils 9-6 on Saturday night.

The Blues are in the second half of a back-to-back, with Jake Neighbours posting five assists in that win. Philip Broberg, Logan Mailloux and Robert Thomas each had a goal and two assists.

The Blues’ lineup has Neighbours, Thomas and Snuggerud together, with Holloway, McTavish and Dvorsky on the second line. Kaskimaki, Buchnevich and Berggren make up the third, while Toropchenko, Suter and Johnston are on the fourth.

Broberg and Mailloux are paired on defense, Barron is with Parayko, and Fowler is with Carlo. Hofer is confirmed in goal.

The Oilers need a response, and they need it from more than just their stars. The prediction here is a 4-1 Edmonton win, a rebound that gets them to 4-2 on the six-game road trip.

Jack Michaels is expected to keep leaning into Pavel Buchnevich’s name, and Jarry is projected to deliver a quality start. Leon Draisaitl could also pile up four points, with he and McDavid on track to become the first two players in league history to reach 50 points in a season for the fifth time.

In Other News...

Oilers Are Suddenly Linked To A Blue-Line Move With Huge Stakes

The Oilers are suddenly being tied to a blue-line swing with real long-term implications, as reports have Edmonton in the mix for Red Wings defenseman Simon Edvinsson before Dec. 1. Edvinsson remains unsigned and is not with Detroit right now, which has only added to the sense that his situation could turn quickly if a contract does not come together. For Edmonton, the appeal is obvious: a young defenseman with upside who could fit into a roster that is always looking for more stability on the back end.

Getting there would not be simple, though. The Oilers would have to navigate their cap situation carefully and put together a trade package that likely includes roster players, prospects and draft picks to even have a chance. And with the possibility that Edvinsson could end up playing in Sweden if no deal is reached, the clock only makes the stakes feel higher for a team that knows how valuable a move like this could be. [Read more 🡒]

Hurricanes Win Over Edmonton Came With One Big Twist

The Oilers 7-4 loss to Carolina on the back end of a weekend set had plenty of familiar frustrations, but the night also carried a pregame wrinkle that made the matchup stand out. The Hurricanes honored Taylor Hall for reaching 1,000 NHL games before puck drop, turning the evening into a celebration before Edmonton had to try to steady itself in a tough road spot.

Instead, the game unraveled in the second period, when Carolina struck three times in quick succession and Edmonton never really recovered. The Oilers also lost Zach Hyman to a migraine that affected his vision, adding to an already messy night, and the officiating only sharpened the frustration around the result as Connor Murphys recent penalty problems continued to draw attention. [Read more 🡒]

Oilers Take Another Brutal Hit In An Already Thin Stretch

The Oilers latest trip through a thin stretch got a little tougher in Carolina, where their winning streak came to an end and the injury list picked up another name. Zach Hyman left the game because of a migraine after playing less than nine minutes, a frustrating development for a team already trying to manage a banged-up lineup and keep its rhythm intact.

There was at least one bright spot in the loss, with rookie Owen Michaels scoring his third goal of the season. But for Edmonton, the bigger concern is how quickly the margins are shrinking as the schedule rolls on, especially when one of the lineups most reliable pieces cant stay in the game long enough to settle in. [Read more 🡒]