Mike Babcock isn’t interested in making Mark Messier’s criticism of his hiring into a public back-and-forth.
Messier set the conversation off Wednesday when he blasted the Edmonton Oilers’ decision to bring in Babcock, calling the move “horrifying” during a media call. He said his reaction came from stories he had heard from “reputable, character people” about how Babcock had treated players in earlier coaching jobs.
The reaction carried extra weight because Messier isn’t just any former Oiler. His name still carries huge influence around the organization, and his disapproval only intensified the scrutiny on Edmonton’s choice.
Babcock heard all of it, and when he spoke Thursday after the team’s skate ahead of its third preseason game against the Vancouver Canucks, he stayed pointedly calm.
“One of these teams [in training camp] is Team Messier, right? He won [five] Cups here,” Babcock said.
“When I watched him, hard, leader, two-way, competitive. He went to New York, hard, two-way, competitive.
Real leader.”
The two have crossed paths a couple of times, even though Messier never played for Babcock. That history, at least from Babcock’s perspective, has been positive.
“I’ve dealt with him two times in my life,” explained Babcock. “One time we were presented with Olympic gold medals here.
I think my daughter was seven or eight then. He treated us great.
“Another was at [a] Hall of Fame thing. He treated me great.
Messier is a legend here. He does great on [ESPN].
I have nothing but respect for him.”
So while Messier’s comments have added another layer of pressure around Babcock’s arrival in Edmonton, the coach made clear Thursday that he wasn’t looking to escalate it. Whatever criticism Messier has for his coaching past, Babcock said his view of the Oilers icon hasn’t changed.
In Other News...
Messier Just Turned Up The Heat On Oilers' Babcock Debate
The Oilers decision to bring in Mike Babcock this summer already carried plenty of baggage, and Mark Messier has now poured more fuel on the debate. Edmonton turned to Babcock in June after moving on from Kris Knoblauch, a move that drew attention not just because of the coaching change, but because of Babcocks long and controversial track record around player treatment.
Messier publicly questioned the organizations judgment, saying he was stunned by the hire in light of the reports that have followed Babcock for years. The fact that Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl interviewed and backed the move only added another layer to the conversation, especially with the NHL having previously reviewed the situation and cleared Babcock before Edmonton made its call. [Read more 🡒]
Leo Carlsson Debate Just Put Ducks Leadership Under The Microscope
A broader debate around team authority has crept back into the conversation around the Oilers, and Mark Messier is adding his voice to it. The Hall of Famer took issue with the way Edmonton handled its coaching search, arguing that letting players carry so much weight in the process muddies the line between the locker room and the front office and can create problems the moment things go sideways.
The timing matters because Edmonton is trying to operate like a serious contender, which leaves little room for uncertainty about who makes the decisions. Messiers comments have revived a familiar question for the Oilers: how much influence should the core players have when the organization is making one of its biggest calls, and where does leadership start to blur into ownership? [Read more 🡒]
Messiers Oilers Blast Just Raised A Bigger Leadership Question
Mark Messiers latest blast landed with the kind of force only a former captain of his stature can generate, because it was aimed not at a bad shift or a rough stretch, but at the Oilers larger sense of direction. Edmontons decision to hire Mike Babcock already invited scrutiny, and Messier added another layer by framing it as more than just a coaching choice, turning the focus toward how the organization makes major calls.
What makes the criticism sting is the leadership angle. Messier took aim at the process behind the hire and the way the clubs leadership group fit into it, raising a familiar question for a team that has spent years trying to balance star power with structure. For an Oilers team still trying to define its identity, the debate now is not only about the coach they brought in, but about who should have had a voice in getting him there. [Read more 🡒]