Paul Bissonnette has thrown out a prediction that would light up the NHL calendar: an Edmonton Oilers-Toronto Maple Leafs Stanley Cup Final.
“I honestly think that we can see an Edmonton Oilers-Toronto Maple Leafs Stanley Cup Final this year,” Bissonnette said in a clip shared by Viva La Stool. The matchup sells itself. Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl on one side, Auston Matthews and William Nylander on the other, with two fan bases hanging on every shift and the Cup possibly ending up in Canadian hands.
For the league, that kind of final would be a monster. It would pull attention far beyond Toronto and Edmonton, with every game carrying a national spotlight and a story built in from the start.
The Oilers would be chasing another shot at the finish line after reaching the Final in 2024 and 2025. For the Leafs, just getting there would count as a breakthrough after missing the playoffs last season following nine straight appearances.
Edmonton looks like the team with the cleaner path. The Atlantic is tougher to get through than the Pacific, and Toronto may have to survive a string of demanding series just to come out of the East. The Oilers, by comparison, have a route back into the mix that at least makes sense on paper.
That said, the bracket never plays out on paper. Anaheim knocked Edmonton out in the first round last spring, a reminder that one hot goalie, one injury, or one ugly matchup can wreck a season fast once the playoffs start. The Oilers have the kind of experience that can fuel another long run, but they still have to earn it.
Goaltending will be a huge piece for both clubs. Toronto brought in Sergei Bobrovsky, a two-time Cup winner, while Edmonton added Frederik Andersen. Those moves give each team a possible answer in net, but the real question is whether either goalie can hold up across four rounds.
The stars will matter too. Toronto needs Matthews and Nylander to keep producing when playoff space disappears and the scoring chances get tighter.
Edmonton’s top-end firepower is already proven; McDavid and Draisaitl have shown they can drive an attack deep into the postseason. The key for the Oilers is whether the rest of the forward group can chip in enough that opponents can’t key on those two every night.
Bissonnette would still lean Edmonton if the matchup actually happened. He pointed to the Oilers’ recent Cup Final experience and said he prefers their coaching group, led by Mike Babcock with D.J.
Smith and Misha Donskov in support. Toronto’s new staff under Jim Hiller brings talent, but Edmonton’s core has already lived through the pressure this series would bring.
So yes, a Leafs-Oilers Final is possible. It would be huge.
It would be unforgettable. But first, both teams still have to get there.
In Other News...
Messier Just Turned Up The Heat On Oilers' Babcock Debate
The Oilers decision to bring in Mike Babcock this summer already carried plenty of baggage, and Mark Messier has now poured more fuel on the debate. Edmonton turned to Babcock in June after moving on from Kris Knoblauch, a move that drew attention not just because of the coaching change, but because of Babcocks long and controversial track record around player treatment.
Messier publicly questioned the organizations judgment, saying he was stunned by the hire in light of the reports that have followed Babcock for years. The fact that Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl interviewed and backed the move only added another layer to the conversation, especially with the NHL having previously reviewed the situation and cleared Babcock before Edmonton made its call. [Read more 🡒]
Leo Carlsson Debate Just Put Ducks Leadership Under The Microscope
A broader debate around team authority has crept back into the conversation around the Oilers, and Mark Messier is adding his voice to it. The Hall of Famer took issue with the way Edmonton handled its coaching search, arguing that letting players carry so much weight in the process muddies the line between the locker room and the front office and can create problems the moment things go sideways.
The timing matters because Edmonton is trying to operate like a serious contender, which leaves little room for uncertainty about who makes the decisions. Messiers comments have revived a familiar question for the Oilers: how much influence should the core players have when the organization is making one of its biggest calls, and where does leadership start to blur into ownership? [Read more 🡒]
Messiers Oilers Blast Just Raised A Bigger Leadership Question
Mark Messiers latest blast landed with the kind of force only a former captain of his stature can generate, because it was aimed not at a bad shift or a rough stretch, but at the Oilers larger sense of direction. Edmontons decision to hire Mike Babcock already invited scrutiny, and Messier added another layer by framing it as more than just a coaching choice, turning the focus toward how the organization makes major calls.
What makes the criticism sting is the leadership angle. Messier took aim at the process behind the hire and the way the clubs leadership group fit into it, raising a familiar question for a team that has spent years trying to balance star power with structure. For an Oilers team still trying to define its identity, the debate now is not only about the coach they brought in, but about who should have had a voice in getting him there. [Read more 🡒]