The Edmonton Oilers' decision to reassign promising goalie prospect Connor Ungar to the ECHL has left many scratching their heads. Ungar, who made waves within the organization over recent months, was called up to the AHL's Bakersfield Condors in December.
This opportunity came after Connor Ingram was promoted to the Oilers, and Ungar seized it with an impressive 9-2-1 record and a .926 save percentage. For the Oilers, it seemed like they had discovered a hidden gem, a potential NHL call-up for next season.
Given his performance, keeping Ungar in the AHL to further hone his skills seemed logical. However, the team opted to move him back to the ECHL, making room for the veteran tandem of Matt Tomkins and Calvin Pickard on the Condors' roster.
From a business perspective, the move might make sense. Tomkins and Pickard bring NHL experience, which typically warrants AHL spots. Yet, when considering the broader implications, the decision appears questionable.
The Oilers, in their quest for contention, have sacrificed high draft picks, leaving their farm system in need of nurturing any promising talent that emerges. Ungar's unexpected rise should have been met with continued development opportunities, not a demotion.
During his stint with the Condors, Ungar proved to be the standout goalie, showcasing potential that could benefit the organization long-term. In contrast, Tomkins, a journeyman in his 30s, and Pickard, fresh off waivers, seem less likely to contribute significantly to the Oilers' future.
The situation is complicated by the fact that neither Pickard nor Tomkins can be reassigned to the ECHL without consent, which they're unlikely to provide. However, alternative solutions, such as trading one of the veterans, were possible. Both goalies possess some value and could have been moved for a reasonable return.
Instead, the Oilers are left with two seasoned goalies in the AHL while Ungar, their promising prospect, finds himself two steps away from the NHL. This move could be perceived as a setback for the development program, prioritizing veteran presence over nurturing young talent.
The message sent to Oilers prospects is concerning. Rewarding young players for their hard work and potential is crucial, and this decision might suggest otherwise. As the Oilers look to the future, ensuring that promising players like Ungar are given the opportunities they deserve should be a priority.