The Edmonton Oilers have a goaltending call to make tonight against the Vancouver Canucks, and it goes beyond simply asking whether Tristan Jarry should get the crease again after Tuesday’s 6-5 overtime loss.
Jarry’s line from the opener was ugly: 17 saves on 23 shots, a .739 save percentage. That kind of number jumps off the page, especially for a team trying to settle things down defensively. But the real question is whether those goals were mostly on him, or whether Edmonton’s breakdowns put him in a bad spot over and over again.
A straight shot total does not tell the full story. A puck fired from the boards and a clean look from the crease are both shots in the book, but they are not the same challenge for a goalie. The Oilers need to sort out which goals were preventable and which came off dangerous looks created by their own mistakes.
Sportsnet’s Mark Spector called Vancouver’s chances high quality, while also pointing out that Jarry did not come up with the timely saves Edmonton needed. Both things can be true at once. The Oilers gave up dangerous looks, and Jarry still had to stop more of them.
That’s why the coaching staff should be looking at video as much as numbers. How often did Jarry face a shooter who had time and space?
How often was he forced to react immediately to a clean chance? That kind of review tells you more than save percentage alone.
The goal that stands out most came early in the third period. Jonathan Lekkerimaki scored from the right circle after an Edmonton giveaway, beating Jarry between the pads.
The turnover opened the door, but it still left Jarry with a save he needed to make. The key questions are basic ones: did he set his angle properly, did he stay balanced, and did he close the space underneath him?
If he was in position, the giveaway does not excuse the goal. That was a soft one, and it turned a 2-2 game into a deficit Edmonton could not absorb. The Oilers then gave up another Canucks goal less than two minutes later, exactly the kind of sequence where a goalie save can change the feel of a period.
There is also the larger body of work to consider. Jarry’s Edmonton history last season was rough, with an .857 save percentage and a 3.86 goals-against average in 19 appearances. One game is not enough to define him, but it does make it harder to brush off Tuesday as a one-off.
Even so, that past does not settle the issue. It shows the results were not good enough, but it does not tell you how much of the problem was Jarry and how much was what was happening in front of him.
What it does mean is that another start cannot be handed out on reputation or optimism alone. He has to show repeatable habits: tracking pucks cleanly, staying under control, and handling rebounds when he can.
Jarry himself put it plainly after the game: “I need one or two of those.” That is the right standard. Edmonton does not need perfection from its goalie, but it does need enough stops to keep mistakes from becoming goals every time.
A second straight start would give the Oilers a useful comparison against the same opponent, even if the picture still would not be perfect. Vancouver’s chances could look different, and Edmonton’s own defensive play could change the workload.
But if Jarry sees similar looks and handles them better, that matters. If he struggles again on manageable shots, the case for a change gets a lot stronger.
For now, giving him another chance is reasonable. Making that decision permanent would not be.
The Oilers need reliability in goal, but they also need better puck management and fewer dangerous chances in front of that goalie. Tonight is a chance to see whether both sides can move in the right direction.
In Other News...
Babcocks Blunt Oilers Message Overshadowed A Night Fans Wont Forget
The opener in Edmonton had plenty of the kind of drama fans remember long after the final horn, and Evan Bouchard was right at the center of it with a performance that gave the home crowd plenty to cheer about. Even in a game that went to overtime, there was enough offense and enough spectacle to make it feel like one of those nights that can shape early-season conversation.
Mike Babcock, though, was not interested in celebrating the mood around the arena after the loss. The Oilers coach turned his focus straight to the other end of the ice and made it clear he expected more from his team without the puck, leaving the performance as much a warning as a takeaway for a club that already knows its margin for error can be thin. [Read more 🡒]
Gretzky Just Gave Oilers Fans A Reason To Exhale On McDavid
Wayne Gretzky gave Oilers fans a little breathing room on The Pat McAfee Show, weighing in on Connor McDavids future and making it clear he expects the superstar to stay in Edmonton for the long haul. McDavid is in the first season of the two-year extension he signed in October, and with the league still recalibrating around his place at the top of it, every public comment about his next contract gets a little extra oxygen.
Gretzky also said he hopes McDavid eventually gets the Stanley Cup finish that has so far eluded him, pointing to the way the Oilers captain carries himself and his constant drive to win. For a fan base that lives and dies with McDavids decisions, the timing matters too, because he wont be able to sign another extension until July 1, 2027, leaving plenty of runway for the speculation that always follows a player of his stature. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Suddenly Face A Bigger Nugent-Hopkins Concern Than Fans Expected
The Oilers forward depth took another hit Monday when Ryan Nugent-Hopkins was placed on injured reserve after a lower-body injury suffered late in practice. The timing adds another layer of concern for Edmonton, which has already been managing a crowded injury list and now has to navigate a stretch without one of its most reliable two-way centers, with the expectation being that the absence could last about two weeks.
Josh Samanski was recalled under emergency conditions to help fill the gap up front, giving the Oilers another temporary option while the lineup stays in flux. Edmonton also has Matt Savoie and Alec Regula on long-term injured reserve with month-to-month timelines, so Nugent-Hopkins status only sharpens the pressure on a depth chart that is already being tested in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]