Justin Verlander may have softened his edges, but Max Scherzer made sure his own exit still looked exactly like Max Scherzer.
Verlander’s final start with the Tigers came with a very different vibe. Before and after the outing, he made it clear he didn’t want to treat it like just another day at the office.
He ditched the headphones, lowered the guard, and spent time talking with teammates beyond just his catcher. He also pointed to his daughter Genevieve as the reason he wanted to pitch from a place of love rather than anger.
That wasn’t the version of Verlander fans were used to in his prime, when even he has said he could be a bad teammate. But the change landed, and the scene over the weekend - especially when his daughter was with him as he left - hit people hard.
Scherzer, though, wasn’t interested in a sentimental rewrite.
The longtime former Tiger pitched what is expected to be his final major league start on Sunday, even though he has not officially announced his retirement. And naturally, he turned it into a little theater. Blue Jays manager John Schneider came out in the seventh with two outs to take him out, and Scherzer sent him right back to the dugout.
Max Scherzer was NOT coming out of this game! 😤 pic.twitter.com/W1rLRiP3S5
- MLB (@MLB) September 27, 2026
The numbers backed up the drama: seven innings, six hits, one earned run, one walk and seven strikeouts. Scherzer finally yielded in the eighth, with a runner on first, after a long conversation on the mound. There were hugs, a hat tip and a standing ovation for a pitcher who may end up in the Hall of Fame alongside his longtime rival.
He probably wouldn’t have gotten the same farewell treatment if he had announced retirement as early as Verlander did. Still, this felt right for Scherzer - the fiery Mad Max version of an ending, not the quiet kind.
That contrast goes all the way back to their Detroit days, when Scherzer and Verlander were already fire and ice.
And there’s one more wrinkle that fits the whole Scherzer story: he is now three strikeouts behind Verlander on the career leaderboard. So don’t be shocked if he shows up again in 2027 on a league-minimum deal, just to chase down or pass him. Tigers fans may want Verlander’s mark to hold, but that would be an incredibly petty, and perfectly Scherzer, way to go about it.
In Other News...
Tigers Face A Painful Veteran Reset After Disappointing 2026
The Tigers 2026 season ended the way few around the club expected, with a record below .500 and a reminder that preseason hopes never turned into sustained results. Now the front office is staring at a familiar sort of offseason pressure, with the roster set to lose several veteran names and the organization needing to decide how quickly it wants to pivot toward a younger core.
Gleyber Torres, Justin Verlander, Kenley Jansen and Jack Flaherty are all expected to move on, whether through free agency or retirement, leaving Detroit with experience to replace in several spots. The bullpen will be one of the clearest areas for change, and the broader challenge for the Tigers is finding a way to rebuild around younger players without letting another disappointing year linger into next spring. [Read more 🡒]
Comerica Park Just Gave A Respected Veteran A Sendoff Tigers Fans Felt
There was a little extra emotion in Comerica Park when Justin Verlander and Kirby Yates found themselves on opposite sides of the field for what turned out to be their final MLB game at the ballpark. Verlander, a familiar figure to Tigers fans, was on the mound for one last matchup there, while Yates took the opposing side in a fitting closing chapter for a pitcher whose career had stretched across 12 seasons.
Yates still got the kind of reception usually reserved for home colors, a special ovation that cut through the usual road-player routine and underscored how much respect he earned over the years. His path included a standout 2019 season and a strong run before retirement became official, and the moment at Comerica Park served as a reminder that some farewells are bigger than the scoreline. [Read more 🡒]
Eduardo Valencia Just Delivered A Tigers Moment Fans Wont Forget
For most of the night, the Tigers were staring at a loss in what was expected to be Justin Verlanders final Major League start, a setting that already carried its share of emotion. Then Eduardo Valencia stepped in with two outs in the ninth and changed everything, launching a two-run walk-off homer that turned a 3-2 deficit into a 4-3 victory over the Pirates.
It was the kind of sudden, stirring finish that sticks with a fan base, and it also put Valencia in a rare bit of franchise history. He became the first Tigers rookie since Lou Whitaker in 1978 to hit a walk-off home run while the team was trailing, a milestone that gives his rookie season an instant signature moment even before the larger story around the night has fully settled. [Read more 🡒]