CLEVELAND - The Tigers had this one in hand, then watched it slip away in the kind of finish that leaves a dugout staring into space.
Detroit lost both ends of Friday’s doubleheader against the Guardians, first in a 7-6 walk-off in Game 1 and then again in Game 2, when Cleveland erased a 3-1 deficit and won 4-3 on Brayan Rocchio’s RBI single in the 10th. The sweep pushed the Tigers to 64-77, dropped them 13 games under .500, and left them with 16 losses in their last 20 games.
Game 2 looked manageable for most of the afternoon, especially with rookie left-hander Andrew Sears dealing in his first major league start. Sears worked 5.2 innings and gave up one run on four hits, showing a lively 94-mph four-seam fastball and pairing it with a slider and changeup that kept the Guardians off balance.
His quick pace became a storyline almost immediately. Cleveland tried to disrupt him, and in the fifth inning catcher Austin Hedges was called for a pitch-clock violation after stepping out too late. Stephen Vogt came out of the dugout to defend Hedges, who was arguing with home plate umpire Manny Ramirez, and Vogt was ejected.
Sears didn’t flinch. He allowed just three hits through five innings and was one out away from getting through the sixth before Nathaniel Lowe broke through. After Sears had already topped his season high in pitch count from the minors, Lowe won a seven-pitch battle and drove a 3-2 slider, Sears’ 93rd pitch, into the gap in right-center to score Jose Ramirez from first.
Beau Brieske took over and finished the sixth by striking out pinch-hitter Daniel Schneemann with a 97-mph heater, then worked a clean seventh with two more strikeouts.
Detroit’s lead, though, was in trouble the moment Jacob Waguespack started the eighth by walking Steven Kwan. Travis Bazzana followed by jumping on a 2-0 count and sending a center-cut 94-mph four-seamer into the left-center seats to tie the game and trigger the Progressive Field fireworks.
The Tigers still had a chance to recover in extra innings, but they couldn’t score with the free runner in the top of the 10th. Cleveland then got Rocchio aboard on a fielder’s choice, and he tried to move Patrick Bailey to third on a bunt. Colt Keith handled it well, fielding the bunt, pivoting and throwing Bailey out at third with Kevin McGonigle covering.
Rocchio wasn’t done. He stole second and third against Kenley Jansen, then came home with two outs on Bazzana’s single to end it.
Detroit also had to deal with the loss of Hao-Yu Lee, who left in the third inning after a collision at the plate with Hedges. Lee was trying to score from third on a ground ball to third by Spencer Torkelson when Jose Ramirez’s throw beat him to the plate and Lee’s lower left leg slammed into Hedges’ shin protector.
He stayed bent over for several seconds, needed help getting up, and limped off with Tigers trainers. The team’s initial diagnosis was a left shin contusion.
Lee had earlier delivered an RBI single in a third inning that started with promise. Zach McKintry singled and Gleyber Torres walked before Lee’s hit.
Kevin McGonigle followed with an RBI double, and Detroit still had no outs. But the inning never fully opened up.
McGonigle was eventually thrown out on an unusual 6-2-4-5 fielder’s choice by Eduardo Valencia, Lee was thrown out at the plate, and Max Clark grounded out to end it.
The Tigers added another run in the fifth on an RBI single by Valencia, but they wasted that chance too, stranding Dillon Dingler after his double and a trip to third with one out.
By the end of the day, the big innings Detroit needed never came, and the late leads it built in both games were gone.
In Other News...
Tigers Just Reopened A Deadline Frustration Fans Never Wanted
As the Tigers drift out of playoff contention, the playing time is starting to tilt toward the future, with younger players such as infielder John Peck getting more of a look. It is the kind of shift that usually comes late in a lost season, when development matters more than squeezing out every last win and the organization begins to sort out who belongs in the next wave.
The frustration for Detroit is that the deadline did not fully match that reality. Gleyber Torres stayed put despite carrying real value and looming free agency, a decision that fit the broader mixed approach under president of baseball operations Scott Harris. The Tigers tried to walk the line between selling and staying competitive, and for fans, that half-step has only revived an old question about what kind of season this was supposed to be. [Read more 🡒]
Casey Mize Trade Is Suddenly Looking Better For The Tigers
At the August 3 trade deadline, Detroit moved Casey Mize to San Diego, and the deal looked like the kind of swap both clubs could judge over time. Since arriving with the Padres, Mize has had a rough run in six starts, going 1-3 with a 6.67 ERA, which has only sharpened the spotlight on what the Tigers gave up and what they got back.
Jackson Wolf and Kash Mayfield were among the pieces heading to Detroit, and their early returns have come in different forms across their respective leagues. The larger picture still needs more time to settle, but for now the early results have made the Tigers' side of the trade appear a little more encouraging than it did in the moment. [Read more 🡒]
Eduardo Valencia Is Forcing A Big Tigers Decision Much Sooner Than Expected
Eduardo Valencia has made himself part of the Tigers conversation far sooner than anyone probably expected when he debuted in July. In fewer than 30 big league games, he has hit .313 with a .956 OPS and six home runs in 83 at-bats, production that has stood out even as Detroit has used him mostly as a catcher and designated hitter.
What makes his rise especially interesting is the roster ripple it could create. The Tigers already have other catching prospects in the pipeline, and Valencias bat may push the club toward a bigger role for him as a full-time DH, depending on how they weigh his offensive value against his defensive limitations and the broader needs of the roster this offseason. [Read more 🡒]