The early returns from the Tigers’ trade-deadline haul have been a mixed bag, and not in the way Detroit was hoping.
Three of the four pitchers acquired in the Tarik Skubal and Casey Mize deals are now sidelined with injuries, with Brady Smith becoming the latest after the West Michigan Whitecaps placed him on the injured list Thursday night. Smith joins River Ryan and Kash Mayfield on the shelf, while the top prospect in the group, Zyhir Hope, is still searching for his rhythm at the plate.
Smith’s exit on Saturday was abrupt. The 21-year-old right-hander, who came over from the Los Angeles Dodgers in the Skubal trade with Ryan and Hope, left after facing just five batters. He was shaking his right arm before a trainer checked on him, and he walked off the mound at LMCU Ballpark in Comstock Park.
Ryan, 28, was already rehabbing a hamstring injury when the Tigers got him and is now on the injured list at Triple-A Toledo. Still, there’s at least some momentum there. Tigers manager AJ Hinch said last week that Ryan is getting closer to competition, has begun throwing bullpens and remains a possibility to help the club down the stretch.
Mayfield’s situation is even more delayed. The 21-year-old first-round pick in 2024 has not yet made his Tigers organizational debut after the Whitecaps placed him on the injured list Aug. 11 because of a hamstring injury.
He hasn’t pitched since July 24 with High-A Fort Wayne, a Padres affiliate. Mayfield came to Detroit in the Mize deal with 27-year-old starter Jackson Wolf.
All three pitchers - Ryan, Mayfield and Smith - rank among the Tigers’ top 10 prospects, according to MLB Pipeline.
The one name that has drawn the most attention from the Skubal return, Hope, has also had a quiet start. The 21-year-old outfielder, now No. 39 on Baseball America’s top 100 prospects list, is at Double-A Erie and is hitting .160 through 50 at-bats.
He has two home runs and nine RBIs. After a sluggish beginning in Erie, though, Hope has gone 5 for 11 over his last three games entering Friday, with three runs scored.
Smith has at least shown flashes in his brief time in the system. In two starts - one of them cut short by the injury - he has given up two earned runs on three hits and four walks in 6.1 innings, with five strikeouts.
Wolf has also gotten his first work in the organization. In two appearances for the Mud Hens, including one start, he has allowed three runs on six hits in eight innings, with seven strikeouts and one walk. His first outing for the Tigers organization came Aug. 9, when he worked four one-hit, shutout innings.
The Tigers also added two more prospects as players to be named later in earlier deals, bringing in left-hander Jojo Ingrassia from the Boston Red Sox in the Jahmai Jones trade and right-hander Zane Barnhart, a Hillsdale College product, from the Baltimore Orioles in the Jake Rogers deal.
Ingrassia, 24, has made two relief appearances for the Whitecaps, allowing two runs on four hits and two walks in 5.1 innings while striking out seven.
Barnhart, 24, has appeared six times for Erie in relief, covering 7.1 innings. He has given up three runs on seven hits and four walks and has struck out seven.
In Other News...
Tigers Fans Are Split Over What The Numbers Say About Torkelson
Spencer Torkelson has become one of those players who can split a fan base without even changing positions. At first base, the advanced numbers have not been kind, with Statcasts Outs Above Average and Fielding Bibles Defensive Runs Saved both painting an unflattering picture, but plenty of viewers who watch him every day see something different. Broadcasters and some fans argue that he looks steadier and more reliable than the metrics suggest, which is part of why the discussion around his defense has been so lively.
That divide says as much about first base defense as it does about Torkelson. It remains one of the harder spots on the field to quantify cleanly, and the metrics used to judge it are still evolving, which leaves room for disagreement when the eye test and the numbers do not line up. For the Tigers, the bigger question is not whether the debate exists, but how much weight to give a stat line that many around the game still believe does not fully capture what happens on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Just Put James Outman In A Tough Spot
James Outmans latest stop with the Tigers turned into a brief one, even after Detroit brought him back from the seven-day concussion injured list. The club activated the outfielder and then designated him for assignment, a roster squeeze that came as Detroit selected left-hander Andrew Sears from Triple-A Toledo and sent Enmanuel De Jesus down.
Outman had already logged 45 games with the Tigers, but the bat never really caught up, leaving him vulnerable once the team needed room for Sears and his expected Major League debut. For Detroit, it was a straightforward organizational move on paper, but for Outman it leaves his next step hanging as the club recalibrates its pitching depth. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Are Giving A Promising Lefty A Real Chance To Stick
Andrew Sears is getting a legitimate look at the major league level, and it comes at a time when the Tigers are always searching for useful arms they can trust in the middle of a long season. The 23-year-old lefty, drafted in the 10th round in 2023, has worked his way back from an elbow injury and put together strong stretches at Triple-A Toledo, where his sinker-slider mix has played well and his changeup has kept moving in the right direction.
Now the Tigers are planning to use Sears as a bulk reliever in an upcoming bullpen game, which gives him a chance to show he can handle more than just a cameo. For a club that values pitchers who can miss bats and throw strikes, the recent gains in his command and strikeout rate make this a meaningful test, even if the assignment itself is only temporary for now. [Read more 🡒]