Tigers Lineup Split Is Hurting Detroit At The Worst Time

The Detroit Tigers face a challenging period with playoff hopes dwindling, as some players shine while others falter at the plate.

The Detroit Tigers entered their homestand looking like a team ready to build momentum. Instead, the slide has taken over. After taking two of three from the Cleveland Guardians, Detroit has now been swept by the Chicago White Sox, dropped two of three to the Pittsburgh Pirates and lost the series opener to the Kansas City Royals.

That stretch has dragged the Tigers’ playoff chances down at exactly the wrong time, and the middle of the lineup has been a big part of the problem. Still, not everyone in Detroit’s offense has gone quiet.

Gleyber Torres has been one of the steadier bats in the lineup since mid-August. Keeping him at the MLB Trade Deadline may have caught some people off guard, but the veteran second baseman has done his part.

Since the beginning of the White Sox series on Friday, Aug. 14, Torres is 10-for-29 (.345 AVG).

He went hitless in the opener against Kansas City, but he had at least one hit in each of the Chicago games before going quiet in the series finale against Pittsburgh.

Torres is batting .266 with eight home runs and an OPS of .769 this season. Whatever happens with the Tigers’ playoff push, he has filled his role without becoming a drag on the offense.

Colt Keith has also been giving Detroit a lift when he gets into the lineup. He may not be starting every day, but he keeps producing when called upon. In his third season with the Tigers, Keith has not matched the home run pace he showed in his first two years, when he hit nine, but he has been finding ways to extend innings and keep things moving.

Since the beginning of the White Sox series on Friday, Aug. 14, Keith has seven hits in 17 at-bats (.412 AVG). He also made an immediate impact against Kansas City, coming off the bench and lining a double down the right-field line.

That kind of production is starting to make a daily lineup spot harder to ignore, even with some inconsistency in the field.

The other side of the story has been rougher. Dillon Dingler was one of the biggest reasons the Tigers looked so good in the first half, but his bat has gone ice-cold since the trade deadline. Since the opener against Chicago, Dingler is 2-for-28 (.071 AVG), and since Aug. 9 against the San Francisco Giants, the All-Star catcher has just three hits in 49 at-bats.

If Detroit is going to claw its way back into the race, Dingler needs to get back to the version of himself that carried the offense earlier in the year.

Spencer Torkelson has hit a similar wall in the middle of the order. He was one of the team’s more reliable hitters, but the timing of his slump has made it sting even more, especially with Dingler and Riley Greene unavailable to help.

Since the start of the White Sox series, Torkelson is 1-for-20 (.050). He came into that stretch batting .232, and after the Royals opener, he’s down to .224.

He still hasn’t homered in August, which is a major part of his game.

Torkelson continues to move around the middle of the lineup and should keep playing, but the Tigers need him to snap out of it. Entering the second game of the series, Detroit has a 9.8% chance of making the playoffs, according to FanGraphs.

In Other News...

Tigers Fans Are Split Over What The Numbers Say About Torkelson

Spencer Torkelson has become one of those players who can split a fan base without even changing positions. At first base, the advanced numbers have not been kind, with Statcasts Outs Above Average and Fielding Bibles Defensive Runs Saved both painting an unflattering picture, but plenty of viewers who watch him every day see something different. Broadcasters and some fans argue that he looks steadier and more reliable than the metrics suggest, which is part of why the discussion around his defense has been so lively.

That divide says as much about first base defense as it does about Torkelson. It remains one of the harder spots on the field to quantify cleanly, and the metrics used to judge it are still evolving, which leaves room for disagreement when the eye test and the numbers do not line up. For the Tigers, the bigger question is not whether the debate exists, but how much weight to give a stat line that many around the game still believe does not fully capture what happens on the field. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers Just Put James Outman In A Tough Spot

James Outmans latest stop with the Tigers turned into a brief one, even after Detroit brought him back from the seven-day concussion injured list. The club activated the outfielder and then designated him for assignment, a roster squeeze that came as Detroit selected left-hander Andrew Sears from Triple-A Toledo and sent Enmanuel De Jesus down.

Outman had already logged 45 games with the Tigers, but the bat never really caught up, leaving him vulnerable once the team needed room for Sears and his expected Major League debut. For Detroit, it was a straightforward organizational move on paper, but for Outman it leaves his next step hanging as the club recalibrates its pitching depth. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers Are Giving A Promising Lefty A Real Chance To Stick

Andrew Sears is getting a legitimate look at the major league level, and it comes at a time when the Tigers are always searching for useful arms they can trust in the middle of a long season. The 23-year-old lefty, drafted in the 10th round in 2023, has worked his way back from an elbow injury and put together strong stretches at Triple-A Toledo, where his sinker-slider mix has played well and his changeup has kept moving in the right direction.

Now the Tigers are planning to use Sears as a bulk reliever in an upcoming bullpen game, which gives him a chance to show he can handle more than just a cameo. For a club that values pitchers who can miss bats and throw strikes, the recent gains in his command and strikeout rate make this a meaningful test, even if the assignment itself is only temporary for now. [Read more 🡒]