Tigers Just Got A New Reason To Worry About Shota Imanaga

With the White Sox's lucrative contract for Dustin May escalating pitcher prices, the Tigers' pursuit of Shota Imanaga hangs in the balance.

The White Sox may have just changed the temperature of the starting pitching market, and the Tigers could feel the heat.

Detroit was the first team to make a notable move after the GM Meetings, landing reliever Emilio Pagán on a one-year, $11.5 million deal. Since then, the market has moved in fits and starts, with only a few relievers coming off the board. But the pace picked up on Friday when World Series champion Jake Bauers agreed to a four-year, $58 million deal with the Red Sox, and it accelerated again Tuesday when Chicago signed Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract.

That May deal is the one that could ripple straight into Detroit’s plans.

May’s résumé does not exactly scream ace-level certainty. He never threw more than 56 innings in a season during the first five years of his career as a starter, missed all of 2024 because of multiple health issues, and has put up a 4.82 ERA over the last four years in the two seasons since. Still, the White Sox are paying him $17.5 million per year.

If that’s the price tag now, Shota Imanaga may be headed into a much richer market than the Tigers expected.

Evan Petzold and Jon Morosi have both added fuel to the Tigers-Imanaga buzz in recent days, and the fit makes sense for Detroit as it looks to complete its rotation. Imanaga dealt with struggles in 2025 and 2026, but he stayed mostly healthy and posted a 3.45 ERA over his three seasons with the Cubs. He originally signed for $13.25 million a year and accepted a $22.025 million qualifying offer last season, but a deal in the $18 million-per-year range with escalators did not seem out of reach.

Now it might be.

With May landing $17.5 million annually, Imanaga could reasonably push into the low- or mid-$20 millions per year, and that may be more than the Tigers want to commit. If he winds up elsewhere on a two-year, $50 million type of deal, Detroit fans may have the White Sox to thank for the price spike.

For Chicago, though, the gamble comes with plenty of risk. May’s injury history and uneven production do not exactly suggest a safe bet. But the White Sox clearly saw enough to pay up.

In Other News...

Dodgers GM Just Added Intrigue To How Fans Judge The Skubal Trade

The Tarik Skubal trade keeps taking on new meaning in Detroit, and not just because of what the Tigers got back in the deal. Los Angeles sent River Ryan, Brady Smith and Zyhir Hope to Detroit, and Dodgers general manager Brandon Gomes has only added to the conversation by drawing a comparison between Ryan and former Dodgers pitcher Walker Buehler, pointing to the way both developed in the minors and the confidence that stood out early.

For Tigers fans, Ryan is the name that makes this one especially worth watching. His path has been slowed by Tommy John surgery and limited big-league experience, but the early signs in Detroit have been promising enough to keep the trade under a bright spotlight. With Gomes publicly framing Ryan as a pitcher with real upside, the long view on this deal feels a little more complicated, and a little more interesting, than it did when the headlines first broke. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers Could Cap Awards Season With A Sweep Fans Will Love

The Tigers have already spent plenty of this fall in the awards conversation, and today could add another layer to it when the Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger winners are announced at 6 p.m. EST on FanSideds The Baseball Insiders podcast. Detroit has three finalists in the mix: Kevin McGonigle, Riley Greene and Dillon Dingler, giving the club a real chance to see its young core recognized on a national stage.

For a team that spent much of the season leaning on emerging talent, the Silver Slugger race is a fitting snapshot of how far that group has come. Greene has been a steady presence, Dingler has put himself in the conversation at catcher, and McGonigles inclusion underscores the organizations depth of offensive talent. The only thing left is to see whether Detroit can turn those finalist spots into the kind of sweep that would make the fan base smile. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers Are Giving Two Familiar Arms Another Chance To Matter

The Tigers spent part of the Rule 5 Draft deadline window circling back on two pitchers who were already familiar to the organization. Sawyer Gipson-Long and Bailey Horn both landed minor-league deals after earlier roster moves had pushed them out of the picture, a reminder that Detroit is still trying to preserve every bit of pitching depth it can find as it maps out the next couple of seasons.

Both arms have had injury issues, but the Tigers are keeping them in the fold as part of the broader depth chart rather than treating them as finished products. The expectation is that both could open 2027 at Triple-A Toledo, which gives Detroit some low-risk insurance if either can get healthy and steady enough to matter again. [Read more 🡒]