The Tigers’ infield logjam isn’t going away on its own, and that’s exactly why Otto Lopez stands out as such a tempting offseason target.
Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald reported last week that Lopez and Xavier Edwards could be available in the right deal, and Lopez looks like the cleaner fit for Detroit. He brings the kind of profile the Tigers have been missing: steady defense at shortstop, a right-handed bat built on contact, and enough certainty to give the infield some shape.
Lopez is only 28, and he just put together a huge season at shortstop on both sides of the ball. He hit .300 in 2026 with 52 extra-base hits, fewer than 90 strikeouts and a 122 OPS.
Defensively, he added 14 Outs Above Average and 6 Defensive Runs Saved. That’s a major upgrade over the current options, whether you’re talking about Javier Baez, John Peck or Colt Keith.
What makes Lopez especially appealing is how cleanly his offensive game translates. He doesn’t walk much, but he also doesn’t whiff often, and his chase rate stays in a pretty manageable range.
He made contact with 90.1% of pitches in the strike zone and paired that with a 31.1% squared up rate. The power isn’t the point here.
He’s not the kind of hitter who’s going to launch 20-plus homers a year, especially not in Detroit. But he doesn’t need to be.
His value is in the batting average, the reliable contact and the glove that plays.
A move for Lopez would also help the Tigers sort out the rest of the infield. He and Kevin McGonigle would give Detroit a real foundation at shortstop and either second base or third, depending on where Hinch prefers McGonigle.
Spencer Torkelson is likely to stay at first because of his defense, though Josue Briceño could eventually take over there during the year. That leaves only second or third base for Hao-Yu Lee, Keith or Max Anderson to compete for.
It could also create more room for movement elsewhere. Báez could be dealt, or Detroit could even choose to eat his contract in his walk year.
Of course, a trade like this would not come cheap. The Tigers would probably have to send back an infield piece, and Keith makes sense as part of that package because he still doesn’t have a clear defensive home.
Even so, his versatility could appeal to a young Marlins club. If not Keith, Detroit could pivot to Anderson, Peck or Jace Jung, depending on what Miami wants.
That’s the tradeoff here: a real cost for a player who could change the look of the roster. If Lopez is truly on the market, the Tigers should be ready to act.
It would mean parting with a top prospect and some young bats in the Florida Coast League, but the payoff is obvious. Detroit’s biggest issue among its position players is defense, and Lopez would immediately strengthen that side of the ball.
It would be a departure from the Tigers’ usual approach, but it would also be a rare gamble worth making.
In Other News...
Tigers Linked To Another Rotation Arm As Free Agency Pressure Builds
The Tigers are staring at a familiar offseason question as rotation depth becomes a priority, and Clay Holmes has now entered the picture as another possible answer. After Holmes and Matthew Boyd both opted out of their contracts, the market for starting pitching took another turn, and Holmes in particular figures to draw plenty of attention after working for the Mets and Cubs in 2024.
Detroit has already been tied to ways of strengthening the staff, and Holmes fits the kind of arm that can quickly change the conversation around a rotation if the fit is right. With multiple teams expected to chase him, the Tigers will have to decide how aggressive they want to be as the pressure to add proven pitching keeps building. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Bullpen Need Could Put Focus On One Affordable Trade Target
The Tigers bullpen search could lead them to a relatively affordable arm if they decide to shop for help rather than pay a premium. One name surfacing as a fit is Colorado left-hander Brennan Bernardino, who has built a case as a dependable late-inning option with a 2.81 ERA across 74 appearances in 2026 and club control that runs through 2029.
For Detroit, the appeal is obvious: a lefty who can stabilize a relief group without forcing the front office into a long-term commitment. The question is whether the Rockies would move him for a minor league pitching prospect, and whether the Tigers view the price as worth paying once they weigh his fit, value and the kind of bullpen role he could fill. [Read more 🡒]
Reese Olson Could Still Change Detroits 2027 Pitching Picture
Reese Olsons path back gives the Tigers one more reason to think beyond the immediate season and toward 2027, when the right-hander is expected to be available again after February shoulder labral repair surgery. Olson has already shown steady improvement since his MLB debut in 2023, and even without a full season on his rsum, he has done enough to stay in the conversation as a meaningful part of Detroits pitching plans.
What makes Olson such an interesting name in the long view is the flexibility he could offer once he returns. The Tigers see him as a possible starter or bullpen piece in 2027, a decision that will hinge on how his recovery goes and what the roster looks like by then. For a club always balancing present needs with future depth, Olson remains one of those arms worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]