The Tigers have spent the better part of a decade searching for a real answer at designated hitter, and the numbers keep telling the same ugly story.
Baseball may have changed around the role, but the DH is still supposed to be an offensive boost. In Detroit, though, it has too often been a sinkhole. From 2017 through 2026, Tigers designated hitters managed only two seasons above a 100 wRC+, with a 107 mark in 2020 and a 102 last year, when the club posted a second straight season with an OPS above .700.
This season was a step backward again. Detroit’s DHs finished with a .358 slugging percentage, a .676 OPS and a 92 wRC+.
That .358 slugging mark was second-worst in the American League, ahead of only the Royals’ .331, and the group’s combined -0.8 fWAR was also near the bottom of the league. The power outage was especially glaring: just 13 home runs in 648 plate appearances, the fewest in baseball and two fewer than the Padres’ designated hitters, who had 11.
That’s why Detroit’s offseason options matter so much. One possible path is adding a hitter who can bring real offensive value and, in the right case, help elsewhere on the roster too.
Ty France is one name that fits that mold. He is not projected to be a 30-homer bat, but he was a steady hitter this year and a high-level defensive first baseman.
France won a Gold Glove last year and was among the finalists this season, which would give Detroit another option at first base, where Spencer Torkelson finished among the worst first basemen with -12 OAA in 2026.
Torkelson still has a case because of the power he has shown and the fact that he has stayed on the field. Since debuting in 2022, he has played 83% of the team’s games. With a bat like France’s, or another free-agent hitter who can supply power, Detroit could reduce Torkelson’s load and split some of that time at DH.
France is not the only name on the market, and a broader look at the available options is coming. But the urgency is obvious. The Tigers have not solved this spot, and the recent production makes that impossible to ignore.
Over the last three seasons, Detroit’s hitters with at least 100 plate appearances as designated hitters have come with a team strikeout rate of 27.5%, the second-highest in that span, and a -0.5 fWAR, fourth-worst. Riley Greene is part of the picture only in a limited sense, since he is usually the starting left fielder and is not really a full-time DH, even though he leads the offense with 17 home runs in fewer plate appearances than Kerry Carpenter.
Carpenter looked like a possible answer at one point because of the power upside, but the production has not matched the promise. Over that span, he has put up -0.1 fWAR, hit .227, struggled to draw walks, struck out too much, and carried an on-base percentage of just .279.
Colt Keith has logged the most games at the spot, with 107, but the results were just as discouraging: -0.5 fWAR and an 83 wRC+. Gleyber Torres managed one home run in 123 plate appearances and hit only .306 slugging.
Mark Canha was part of the mix. Jahmai Jones gave Detroit some power, especially against left-handed pitchers at the time, but finished with 39 strikeouts and 13 RBIs.
The Tigers have cycled through names, but not answers. And that leaves the DH spot as one of the clearest offensive debts on the roster.
In Other News...
Tigers Could Make A Bullpen Decision Fans Never Saw Coming
The Tigers have already started clearing room on the 40-man roster, designating Matt Vierling for assignment ahead of the non-tender deadline. That move alone signaled a busy stretch ahead for Detroit, with the front office weighing not just roster fit but which players it wants to keep in the fold as the offseason decisions stack up.
The next questions are more interesting, and a little less predictable. Brenan Hanifee and Beau Brieske have surfaced as possible non-tender candidates, with Wenceel Prez also mentioned in the mix, but the name drawing the most attention is Will Vest. MLB Trade Rumors flagged Vest as a surprising possibility, even as the Tigers have generally valued him and have had to account for an injury-shortened 2026 season that complicates the picture. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks Suddenly Fit A Skubal Chase Fans Never Saw Coming
Tarik Skubals free-agent market is already shaping up to be one of the most watched in baseball, with the left-hander having met with the Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays and Padres. Now there are reports of two more mystery teams lurking in the background, and the speculation has naturally widened to include clubs such as the Diamondbacks, Yankees, Angels and Tigers as people try to sort out who can actually make a serious run.
For Detroit, the conversation is less about wishful thinking than about what kind of team could realistically join the chase if Skubals market keeps expanding. Arizona has emerged as one of the more intriguing possibilities in that discussion, thanks to the way the market is being framed around financial capacity and fit, but the full list of suitors still has one important layer missing. Until those mystery clubs are identified, the Skubal sweepstakes remain as much about reading the tea leaves as they are about the pitcher himself. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Quietly Brought Back Two Arms Who Could Still Matter
The Tigers have kept their pitching depth moving quietly through the winter, working through two rounds of roster cuts while still finding ways to hold onto arms that could matter later. Bailey Horn and Sawyer Gipson-Long were released, Yilber Daz was designated for assignment, and Daz ultimately cleared waivers and returned to the organization, leaving Detroit with a little more flexibility as it sorts out its staff.
Horn and Gipson-Long both re-signed on minor league deals, a reminder that the Tigers are still willing to bet on pitchers whose value may come only after they get healthy again. Injuries have slowed both, but they remain in the system as low-risk options who could provide depth if Detroit needs help during the season. [Read more 🡒]
