The Tigers didn’t get much out of the 2025 deadline, and the Rafael Montero deal has only gotten harder to defend with time.
Montero was never a sure thing in Detroit. He arrived as one of the worst qualified relievers in baseball, and while he did finish the season with a respectable 2.86 ERA over 22 innings after the deadline, the Tigers still came out behind. Veterans with stronger résumés - Chris Paddack, Charlie Morton and Paul Sewald - were worse.
What makes the move sting is what Detroit gave up to get him. Scott Harris sent the Braves a real player for a rental arm the Tigers probably should have been able to land for cash alone. Jim Jarvis, an 11th-round pick in 2023, was an unranked Double-A prospect at the time, but even that felt like too much.
Jarvis has spent most of the last year out of mind for Tigers fans, while Montero is now sitting on a 5.66 ERA with the Yankees’ Triple-A club. But Jarvis’ rise with Atlanta is bringing the trade back into focus.
He got a brief two-day call-up in May, then returned to the majors at the start of July and has hit .308 with an .826 OPS since. That kind of production has already made him a Braves favorite.
"Alright, whats the status on that Jim Jarvis statue?"
- Eric Cole (@leprekhan) July 21, 2026
Jarvis has also forced his way onto the Braves’ top-30 prospects list, debuting there this season at No. 28 after making a strong impression in the organization last year. In Triple-A Gwinnett, he was hitting .305 with an .863 OPS before his first promotion, then improved to .313/.867 after going back down.
Atlanta has mostly used him at shortstop in July, but Ha-Seong Kim is nearing the end of a rehab assignment after his second IL stint of the season, which could put Jarvis in line for a demotion. Still, his ability to play multiple infield spots gives him a path to stick.
And then there was Tuesday night, when he got a hit off a 103.1 MPH Mason Miller fastball. The Braves lost 8-3, but Jarvis still turned in the kind of moment that makes a rookie stand out.
The Tigers could have used that bat back in May. Instead, they got 22 decent innings from Rafael Montero.
In Other News...
Tigers Fans May Not Like What This Means For Max Clark
Max Clark keeps doing enough in Triple-A to stay in the conversation, but not enough to force the Tigers hand just yet. The top prospect has put together a solid line with power, patience and speed, the kind of all-around production that usually keeps a player on the cusp of a big-league look.
For now, though, Detroit appears content to let the calendar and the roster situation do some of the work. Unless Clark takes a noticeable step forward or the Tigers are pushed into a move by another injury, a call-up may have to wait until September, which is not exactly the kind of timeline fans had in mind when they started tracking his rise. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Fans Wont Love Where This Ace Chase May Be Headed
Tarik Skubal is still the name hanging over a lot of deadline chatter, and it makes sense why. The Tigers have one of the most coveted arms on the market, and the Dodgers have long looked like the kind of club that could line up the prospect capital to make a deal work if they decide to push in before the Aug. 3 deadline. From Detroits side, it is exactly the sort of conversation that can reshape a summer even before anything is finalized.
The catch is that Los Angeles may not be eager to pay the kind of price a rental pitcher would usually demand, even with the rotation taking hits. Injuries have already thinned the Dodgers staff, and that kind of pressure can change a front offices thinking quickly, but for now the preference appears to be smaller additions rather than a blockbuster swing. So the fit is obvious, the need is real and the clock is ticking, but the path from rumor to reality still has a few turns left. [Read more 🡒]
Justin Verlander's Tigers Future Just Took Another Uncertain Turn
Justin Verlanders path back to the mound has been moving at a crawl, and the latest update from A.J. Hinch only reinforced how little certainty there is around the veteran right-handers next step. Verlander is still working through a hamstring strain, has already dealt with setbacks in rehab and has made only one MLB appearance this season, leaving the Tigers to wait on a pitcher whose future in the game has become as much a storyline as his health.
Even with all of that, the organization remains committed to seeing Verlander pitch in 2026, which keeps his situation firmly in the foreground for a club trying to balance the present with what comes next. Detroit has other rotation and bullpen pieces in motion too, with Casey Mize set to take the ball after recovering from a wrist injury and Ty Madden back in the mix, but Verlanders timetable remains the one that still hangs in the air. [Read more 🡒]