Tarik Skubal is still the familiar face in the middle of this whole conversation, but he’s doing it from a Dodgers uniform now, not a Tigers one. That alone makes this October feel strange in Detroit. Skubal won two Cy Youngs with the Tigers, and now he’s trying to finish the job in Los Angeles while the Dodgers stare at a 3-0 hole against the Brewers in the NLCS.
The Dodgers don’t have much margin left. They need three straight wins just to force a Game 7, then one more to reach the World Series. If that comeback doesn’t happen, the focus in Detroit gets even sharper: what did the Tigers give up, and what did they get back?
The answer to that question starts with Zyhir Hope, the headliner in the trade package along with River Ryan and Brady Smith. Hope has opened his stint in the Arizona Fall League with Scottsdale in encouraging fashion, batting .286 with an .873 OPS through six games. He’s also posted five walks, eight strikeouts and five RBI, and he already launched his first homer on Monday - a two-run blast that came off the bat at 101 MPH.
It hasn’t all come easy for him since the deal, though. MLB.com noted he had “plenty of adjusting to do” after moving to a new organization and lineup, and his Double-A numbers in Erie (.269/.360/.462) settled below what he did at Tulsa (.293/.369/.530).
Even so, he finished the 2026 season with 29 homers, 26 steals and 111 RBI, then added a home run in the Eastern League finals. That’s a strong year by any measure, even if the early trade transition was bumpy.
For now, the Arizona Fall League numbers are just that: a small sample, especially after Hope logged a career-high 564 plate appearances. Still, it’s the kind of start that feeds the optimism around his timeline.
The Tigers clearly see real upside here, but there’s no need to rush the script. He’ll get opportunity, and time will sort out when he’s ready for Detroit.
Ryan is the piece closest to the big leagues already. He made his MLB debut on September 21 and threw three scoreless innings against the Nationals.
For the year, he finished with a 4.15 ERA and six strikeouts over 4⅓ innings in two starts. That’s not nearly enough innings to build a full judgment, so the deeper numbers matter more.
He works with six pitches, and Stuff+ grades all of them as average or better. In Triple-A, he backed that up by striking out 10.3 per nine while walking just 2.0.
The caution flag with Ryan is health. He’s returning from Tommy John surgery and a hamstring injury this past year, and really since 2024.
His two major league starts also came with 6.2 walks per nine, which stands out in the wrong way. But the long-run Triple-A track record and the strike-throwing profile explain why the Tigers are intrigued.
If he stays on the mound, he looks like a real candidate to be in the 2027 rotation.
Smith is the least certain of the three right now, and his story is tied to health as well. He made two starts for High-A West Michigan before leaving his second outing in the second inning after five batters and a visit from a trainer.
He landed on the injured list on August 20. With Tommy John surgery already in his background, the safest read is that the Tigers shut him down as a precaution and are aiming for a healthy 2027.
If that’s the path, he should have a chance to climb to Double-A at some point, and the organization should give him room to move because of what came with him in the Skubal trade. That’s the long view here: one star in Los Angeles, but three very different pieces starting to shape Detroit’s future.
That’s what makes this deal so interesting. Skubal can still be a thrill to watch, even in another uniform.
But Hope’s bat, Ryan’s arm and Smith’s upside give the Tigers something real to look at beyond the present tense. And if the Dodgers can’t claw their way back, the whole thing feels a little sweeter in Detroit.
In Other News...
Tigers Just Got A Crucial Troy Melton Rotation Update
Troy Meltons forearm tightness could have created a much bigger problem for the Tigers, but the latest update offers real relief as the club begins thinking ahead to its 2027 rotation picture. After landing on the injured list, Melton underwent testing that did not show any structural issues, and he has been cleared to keep up his normal offseason routine.
For a team already sorting through a long list of arms, that matters. Detroit is weighing how Melton fits alongside names like Framber Valdez, Jackson Jobe and River Ryan, and any concern around a young pitchers health can quickly complicate those plans. For now, the Tigers can at least move forward knowing Meltons situation appears far less ominous than it first seemed. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Can't Afford The Wrong Rotation Splash This Offseason
The Tigers spent much of the season looking like a team with a pitching identity worth building around, and that makes the coming offseason so delicate. The appeal is obvious: add a veteran starter who misses bats, slot him behind the current core, and suddenly the rotation looks deeper and more dangerous in a division that rewards run prevention. Sonny Gray and Michael King fit that kind of conversation on paper, with the kind of track records that can make a front office lean in.
But the closer look is where the caution creeps in. Both pitchers have shown recent trends that raise questions about whether the strikeout weapon is still as sharp as it once was, and neither would come cheap in contract terms. For a Tigers club trying to make the right kind of splash, the challenge is not finding a recognizable arm, but avoiding the mistake of paying premium prices for a pitcher whose best strength may no longer be fully there. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Bullpen Questions Could Force Scott Harris To Look Inside
The Tigers spent much of the 2026 season trying to patch together a bullpen that never quite settled, with injuries and uneven work from several arms leaving the late innings as a recurring concern. In response, the club added Nick Sandlin on a minor-league deal after he was designated for assignment by the Angels, and his stint with the Toledo Mud Hens offered at least one encouraging sign as Detroit searched for usable relief options.
As the front office looks ahead, the pressure to find answers inside the organization could grow even stronger. Tyler Mattison, a right-handed pitcher the Tigers drafted in 2021, handled himself well in the minors and put himself on the radar for a possible bullpen look in 2027, which is the kind of internal development Detroit may need if it wants more stability without paying heavily on the open market. [Read more 🡒]