The Tigers have an offseason call to make, and the more interesting one might not be the obvious one.
Detroit has two club option decisions coming up, both attached to pitchers with eight-figure price tags. One belongs to Kenley Jansen, a future Hall of Fame closer with a $12MM option or a $2MM buyout.
The other is Drew Anderson, a journeyman whose path to Detroit ran through Japan and Korea before his return to the majors. On paper, Jansen is the bigger name by a mile.
In practice, Anderson may be the likelier candidate to come back.
Anderson signed last December on a one-year, $7MM deal that included a $10MM option for 2026 with no buyout. He entered the season hoping to win a rotation job, but the Tigers’ later signings of Framber Valdez and Justin Verlander pushed him into long relief.
The early results were uneven, and he never quite carved out a true late-inning role. He did handle a few higher-leverage spots, though he also logged his share of mop-up work.
The bullpen hierarchy got crowded early. Jansen, Will Vest, Kyle Finnegan and Brant Hurter before a back injury in late May handled the bigger assignments.
In that setting, an eight-figure salary for a middle-leverage reliever feels steep. Anderson’s case changed later, after the Tarik Skubal and Casey Mize deadline trades opened a door for him to work back into the rotation.
The finish was respectable. The 32-year-old, who turns 33 in March, started his last nine outings and posted a 2.84 ERA over 44 1/3 innings.
The underlying numbers were more ordinary: a 20% strikeout rate, an 11% walk rate, and a homer problem that showed up often enough to matter. He also rarely made it through a lineup a third time.
When hitters saw him again and again, they did damage, going 9-22 with two homers and two doubles apiece.
Still, there was plenty to like in the way Anderson looked once he got back to the majors. His fastball averaged 95 mph, and he missed bats with both a curveball and a kick-changeup he refined with the SSG Landers in Korea.
Overall, he struck out a quarter of the hitters he faced, and nearly 27% when working out of the bullpen. Across 108 innings, he finished with a 3.67 ERA and showed an ability to keep left-handed hitters in check thanks to that changeup.
That makes the option a real decision, not just a formality. Detroit was willing to pay Anderson $7MM before it had any proof he could get big league hitters out consistently.
A $10MM salary is in the neighborhood of what Tyler Mahle and Zach Eflin got in free agency last winter after injury-shortened seasons. Nick Martinez landed $13MM from the Rays, while Michael Lorenzen got $8MM, Michael Soroka $7.5MM and Dustin May $12.5MM.
Lorenzen was a steady fifth-starter type, while May and Soroka were higher-upside bets with injury risk.
Detroit is going to be shopping for rotation help either way. Skubal and Mize are gone, Jack Flaherty is headed for free agency, and Valdez is the projected ace despite an uneven first season in Detroit.
Troy Melton had the best year among the returning starters. Keider Montero pitched well enough to factor into the back end, while Jackson Jobe, River Ryan and Reese Olson all bring upside but not the kind of workload certainty you can bank on for 150 innings.
Anderson could show up to camp as a starter and still slide back to relief later if the Tigers make other moves.
The bullpen needs attention too, and Jansen sits at the center of that debate. Vest and Finnegan both struggled.
Jansen’s deal gives Detroit a $12MM option or a $2MM buyout, and the club may decide to move on. He allowed too many home runs and went 22-28 in save chances.
Even so, his 3.20 ERA and 28% strikeout rate were strong, and he closed with 12 straight scoreless appearances. The walks and the longball just made the ninth inning feel a little less secure than it used to.
Jansen is two saves shy of 500, which would make him the third player in league history to reach that mark. He’s going to want to be a full-time closer wherever he ends up.
Detroit may not be eager to make that commitment in the first week of the offseason. The Tigers could decline the option and keep the door open to a cheaper deal later, once the rest of the bullpen market starts to sort itself out.
In Other News...
Tigers Fans Just Got Another Reminder Why Zyhir Hope Matters
Zyhir Hope keeps giving Tigers fans a reason to track the Arizona Fall League, and his start with the Scottsdale Scorpions has been about more than just getting extra reps. Detroits top prospect arrived in the league with plenty of attention already attached, and early returns have only added to the intrigue as he continues to show why his bat is such a central part of the organizations long-term picture.
Hope picked up his first AFL home run on Oct. 12, and it came as part of a productive opening stretch that has him sitting at five RBIs with an .873 OPS through five games. For a farm system always under the microscope, those are the kinds of markers that keep his name near the top of the conversation, even as other Tigers prospects in Arizona continue working through their own fall-league auditions. [Read more 🡒]
Scott Harris Faces One Tigers Problem He Cant Ignore This Winter
Detroits offseason to-do list starts where so many of its late-game frustrations ended, with the bullpen. The Tigers finished 76-86 and missed the playoffs, and while there were plenty of reasons the season drifted off course, the relief corps was one of the clearest culprits in the standings.
Scott Harris and the front office now have to decide how aggressive they want to be in chasing help, because this is not a problem they can treat as a side project. Free agency offers a few paths, including established relievers who could stabilize the back end, but the market will decide whether Detroit can land the kind of arm it needs to turn close games into wins. [Read more 🡒]
Kevin McGonigle's Award Chase Could Mean Even More For Tigers
Kevin McGonigles rise has already given the Tigers something to build around, and the club made sure of that by locking him up with an eight-year, $150 million extension after his Major League debut. That timing mattered for more than just keeping a young player in Detroit for the long haul. It also preserved the teams eligibility for a draft-incentive pick, giving the Tigers another possible way to keep adding talent to the pipeline.
Now the attention shifts to the American League Rookie of the Year race, with the award set to be announced Nov. 9. If McGonigle comes away with the honor, Detroit would add an extra selection after the first round of the 2027 MLB draft, a small but meaningful bonus that could help deepen a farm system the organization is clearly trying to keep fortified. For a team that has invested heavily in McGonigle already, the stakes of his award chase reach beyond individual hardware. [Read more 🡒]