If Tarik Skubal’s price climbs past $325 million, the Tigers may be better off taking a different route.
Detroit should put Michael King at the top of its list in that scenario, with Clay Holmes as the next piece. Together, the two would give the Tigers more help across the rotation and keep the long-term bill far lower than a Skubal megadeal.
A Nov. 12 RealGM report, citing USA Today’s Bob Nightengale, said Skubal and agent Scott Boras were telling teams they wanted a long-term contract worth more than $325 million. That leaves plenty unresolved - years, annual value and the final guarantee are all still up in the air - but it gives Detroit a clear point of comparison.
The numbers make the alternative easy to see. ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel, in projections published Nov. 3, pegged King and Holmes at a combined $114.5 million guaranteed and $44 million in annual value. That is $237.5 million less in future guarantees than Skubal’s projection, while still carrying the same combined annual value and filling two rotation spots instead of one.
King is the cleaner fit at the top of that plan. He put together a 3.21 ERA across 185 innings and 32 starts for San Diego in 2026, production that would give Detroit a starter capable of working in a major role next to Framber Valdez.
Holmes would slot in behind him as a middle-of-the-rotation arm. He logged a 3.29 ERA in 18 starts in 2026, though a broken fibula cut into his season. McDaniel also noted that Holmes produced ground balls at a 61% clip, which makes the Tigers’ infield defense part of the equation if they go that direction.
There are risks here, too. King threw just 73 innings in 2025 before bouncing back, and Holmes still has to show he can handle a full starter’s workload again. Detroit would still be counting on its younger starters and depth options to do some of the heavy lifting.
The Tigers have already added Emilio Pagan on a one-year, $11.5 million deal. If they paired him with King and Holmes, the total guarantees would reach $126 million, with a combined annual value of $55.5 million.
That same $55.5 million annual value would apply to Skubal and Pagan under McDaniel’s projection, but the guarantee would jump to $363.5 million. The shorter-term path gives Detroit more flexibility after 2028 and 2029, while still adding an established starter right away.
Those comparisons are based on average annual value. Actual 2027 payroll will still depend on salary structure, arbitration outcomes and the rest of the roster. Drew Anderson’s exercised $10 million option is also part of the picture if more starters end up pushing him into a different role.
Skubal remains the best pitcher of the group, and his case is obvious. His 2.72 ERA in 2026 and two Cy Young Awards put him above either alternative on pure talent. But choosing him means accepting a much bigger commitment for a higher-end ceiling at the front of the rotation.
Sonny Gray’s Nov. 18 agreement with Minnesota has already taken another veteran name off the board. At this point, King looks like the Tigers’ first call, with Holmes as the follow-up if the budget allows. If either pitcher pushes the price higher, or if Skubal’s camp softens on structure, Detroit will have to adjust before making its move.
In Other News...
Tigers Face A Tough Rotation Decision With Two Premium Arms
The Tigers are still sorting through what their rotation could look like beyond the current core, and two of the most intriguing names on the free-agent market are Michael King and Freddy Peralta. Both would give Detroit a premium arm, but the appeal of King appears to be tied not just to performance, but to the shape of the contract itself, with some evaluations pointing to a shorter deal and a stronger fit for the clubs 2026 outlook.
Complicating the picture is the recent six-year extension for Troy Melton, a move that adds another layer to the Tigers roster and financial planning. Contract projections around King and Peralta vary from analyst to analyst, and Detroit has to balance those possibilities against other commitments already on the books, making this one of the more delicate decisions of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Tarik Skubal Speculation Just Put More Pressure On Detroits Offseason
Tarik Skubals looming free agency is already shaping the Tigers winter, and not just because hes the best pitcher on the market. With a record-breaking contract expected before the Dec. 1 lockout, the list of suitors has grown into a heavyweight group that includes the Dodgers, Mets, Padres, Blue Jays and two other teams, while Detroit is believed to be among the clubs still keeping lines of communication open. For the Tigers, the challenge is obvious: they know what Skubal means to the rotation, but they also know what a deal of that size would do to the rest of the roster-building plan.
Scott Harris has already signaled that the bullpen could still get more attention, and the Tigers have at least made one quiet move by signing minor league pitcher Anderson Pilar to a minor league deal on Nov. 17. None of that changes the bigger question hanging over the offseason, though, because every decision now has to be weighed against the chance of keeping Skubal in Detroit, and the possibility that the club will have to move on without him if the bidding gets too far out of reach. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Bullpen Plan Suddenly Centers On One High-Stakes New Arm
The Tigers added a familiar late-inning type to their bullpen mix by signing veteran right-hander Emilio Pagan to a one-year contract, a move that gives Detroit another experienced arm as it continues to shape the relief corps. Pagan brings 90 career saves and the kind of strikeout track record that can matter in tight games, and the organization views him as a meaningful piece for a group that has been looking for more stability.
Detroit also extended fourth-round pick Troy Melton, a reminder that the club is still balancing immediate bullpen needs with longer-term pitching depth. For now, though, Pagan is the name drawing the most attention, and both the pitcher and team officials have sounded upbeat about the fit as the Tigers try to sharpen the back end of games. [Read more 🡒]
