Tarik Skubal's Dodgers Comments Are Reopening A Painful Tigers Debate

Can Tarik Skubal overcome the haunting memories of past postseason struggles as he navigates his new role with the Dodgers?

Tarik Skubal’s latest start for the Dodgers has only sharpened the awkward comparison Tigers fans have been carrying around since last October.

On Sunday, after going six innings in Los Angeles’ 6-2 loss to the Brewers, Skubal didn’t hide his frustration with the length of his outings. He has now gone six innings in his Dodgers debut, five in the next one, and six again in his most recent start. He allowed no more than three runs in any of them, but the Dodgers dropped the first two.

“My last outing was 5, the one before that was 6; that's just not acceptable, that's not the standard of what I think I'm capable of in this league."

Tarik Skubal (L (7-7), 6.0 IP, 7 H, 2 R (ER), 2 BB, 7 K, 109 P) talks to the media after the #Dodgers lose to the Brewers, 6-2. pic.twitter.com/cBjlMrMqw9

  • SportsNet LA (@SportsNetLA) August 16, 2026

That reaction landed badly with a chunk of Tigers fans who still remember how differently Skubal handled being pulled after six innings in Game 5 of the ALDS last season. After that outing, he took a much more easygoing tone.

"Trust me, I've seen a lot of the stuff that fans are disappointed or whatever. It's just the way the game of baseball is.

It's just baseball. I'm going to go out there and compete and give it everything I had," he said last year.

" I knew my outing was kind of coming to a close [after six]."

That contrast is what’s bothering people now. Some fans have been irritated about Skubal’s Game 5 longevity ever since the Tigers were eliminated, and the Dodgers comments have given them fresh ammunition.

Others have even used that night as a reason to say the Tigers were better off without him. Last year, that argument was easy to push back on: if he was spent, keeping him out there only risked turning one bad inning into something worse.

The Tigers’ offense was the bigger problem in that loss.

Even with all that said, the tone shift is hard to ignore. In a regular-season game for the Dodgers, Skubal sounded intensely dissatisfied with five and six-inning starts. In the aftermath of a postseason exit with Detroit, he sounded far more matter-of-fact.

There’s also the workload piece. Skubal’s 109 pitches on Sunday were a career high.

AJ Hinch never let him reach more than 96 pitches in any start for the Tigers this season. Maybe that reflects a difference in managing styles between Hinch and Dave Roberts.

But it also makes Skubal’s Game 5 departure feel, at least in the moment, like something he and Hinch were both fine with.

The larger point hasn’t changed: the Tigers lost Game 5 for almost every reason other than Skubal’s one-run start. Still, it’s not exactly easy for Detroit fans to hear him sounding this disappointed now that he’s in a Dodgers uniform.

In Other News...

Kerry Carpenter Update Leaves Tigers Facing A Brutal Stretch Run

Kerry Carpenters injury comes at an awkward time for the Tigers, who are trying to keep their footing during the final push of the season. Carpenter was placed on the 10-day injured list July 27 with left foot plantar fasciitis, and his absence takes away one of the lineups more established left-handed bats just as Detroit is trying to sort out its best mix down the stretch.

A.J. Hinch said Carpenter has been sent to see a foot specialist, which only adds to the uncertainty around how quickly this can turn around. The Tigers do have other players available to cover Carpenters spot in the lineup for now, but the broader question is whether they can absorb the loss without it becoming a problem that lingers deeper into the stretch run. [Read more 🡒]

Max Clark May Be Settling In Faster Than The Tigers Expected

Max Clarks adjustment to major league pitching has come with a subtle but important change in his approach at the plate. Early in the year, Clark and the Tigers used a toe-tap to help address range-of-motion issues, but as hes gotten stronger, he has moved back toward a modified leg kick that more closely matches his natural timing.

The shift has helped his hitting performance, and it has also offered a glimpse of why the Tigers are so encouraged by him. AJ Hinch has praised Clarks baseball intelligence and his ability to adapt, a combination that can make the difference for a young player trying to settle in against big-league arms while still learning what works best for him. [Read more 🡒]