Tarik Skubal’s first two postseason starts in a Dodgers uniform have brought back a familiar sting for Tigers fans, and not in a good way.
The left-hander opened the NLDS against the Braves, then came right back around to start Game 1 of the NLCS against the Brewers. That second matchup was billed as the headline act: Skubal against Jacob Misiorowski, a duel that was supposed to own the spotlight. Instead, the Dodgers knocked Misiorowski out after 4 1/3 innings and 94 pitches, while Skubal lasted five innings and took the loss after allowing two runs.
For Tigers fans, the whole thing is dredging up old frustration. Skubal’s five-inning night in the NLCS has people thinking right back to the 2025 ALDS, when he went six innings against the Mariners in Game 5 and set off another round of debate.
The postgame reactions only sharpened the memory. After being lifted in that elimination game, Skubal said, “That's just baseball,” while his comment after the first game of a five-game series was, “ I didn't do my job,”
In Milwaukee, the damage was enough. Brice Turang hit a solo homer, Luis Lara added an RBI single, and those two runs were all the Brewers needed. Even with Misiorowski out early, the Dodgers still stranded six runners after he was removed.
This series almost certainly isn’t headed for a sweep. Skubal figures to get another shot if it reaches a potential Game 5, and that would give him a chance to keep building the kind of free-agent case that could land him the $400 million he’s expected to command.
But there’s no denying the challenge in front of him. He’s sharing a rotation with Yoshinobu Yamamoto, who has already made a strong case as the best postseason starter of all time. And for Tigers fans, Skubal’s postseason reputation is still the part that hangs over all of it.
In Other News...
AJ Hinch Is Reshaping The Tigers In A Way Fans Will Notice
The Tigers offseason is already starting to take shape under AJ Hinch, and the changes around the dugout are impossible to miss. Detroit has moved on from first base coach Anthony Sanders and assistant pitching coach Juan Nieves as part of a broader staff overhaul, the kind of reshuffling that signals Hinch is looking to put his own imprint on every corner of the operation. For a team trying to keep pushing forward, these are the sorts of behind-the-scenes decisions that can tell you as much about the direction of the club as any headline move.
Theres also a wider player-development thread running through the organization, with minor league prospects getting early runs in the Arizona Fall League. Outfielder Zyhir Hope has opened well, showing the sort of plate discipline and contact ability that keeps evaluators paying attention, while infielder John Peck has had a more uneven start. And with interest around Tarik Skubal already surfacing at the trade deadline, the Tigers are entering a stretch where the decisions in front of them could shape not just the staff, but the bigger picture of how competitive this roster looks moving ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Face One Pitching Decision That Could Define Their Winter
The Tigers are heading into the winter with a pitching puzzle that goes well beyond the usual roster housekeeping. Club options and free agents are part of the equation, and there are already signs Detroit expects to keep Kenley Jansen and Drew Anderson in the bullpen despite some rough moments late in games. The bigger concern is on the mound behind them, where the rotation picture is still unsettled after a year of churn.
Jack Flaherty sits at the center of that uncertainty, and the front office has reason to weigh every angle before deciding whether to bring him back. Detroits depth has been thinned by the departures of Tarik Skubal and Casey Mize, even with Skubal still a possible return, and the organization is also weighing whether Anderson might be stretched back into a starting role. Troy Melton and Jackson Jobe flashed enough to give the Tigers hope, but the winter could still come down to whether they add one more reliable arm to steady a staff that needs it. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Face A Big Max Clark Decision Before His Price Climbs
The Tigers have spent the season leaning into a young core that already includes Riley Greene, Dillon Dingler, Spencer Torkelson, Kevin McGonigle and Hao-Yu Lee, and the front office has made it clear it wants to keep as much of that group together as it can. McGonigles eight-year deal gave the organization a blueprint, and it has naturally pushed the conversation toward the next wave of potential extensions, with Colt Keith and Max Clark both sitting near the front of the line.
Clark is the name that feels especially intriguing because he has already given Detroit enough on both sides of the ball to imagine a long-term fit before his price climbs any further. The Tigers do not have to decide everything right now, but the logic is obvious: lock in a premium young talent early, or wait and risk paying a much steeper price later. [Read more 🡒]