Detroit’s winter to-do list already has a few headline items, but one of the sneaky-big decisions looming for Scott Harris is the Rule 5 draft. While Tarik Skubal’s free agency and Kevin McGonigle’s award-winning rookie season grab the spotlight, Harris still has to decide which young Tigers are worth protecting before the November deadline.
The Rule 5 process is simple in theory and messy in practice. Players who signed at 18 or younger become eligible after five pro seasons; college players after four.
Leave an eligible player off the 40-man roster, and another club can grab him in December for $100,000 - but that team has to carry him on the big-league roster all season. That’s why roster space matters so much.
Protect too few and talent walks out the door. Protect too many and the 40-man roster starts squeezing everything else, including free-agent flexibility.
The names at the top of Detroit’s list are easy enough to spot.
Josue Briceño missed time with injuries and played only 42 games, but he still launched nine homers and posted a .479 slugging percentage. Left-handed power like that is exactly the kind of bat a club doesn’t want to leave exposed.
Max Anderson has a strong case too. Baseball America named him the Tigers Minor League Player of the Year after he hit .302 with 15 home runs at Toledo.
And then there’s Izaac Pacheco, who was left unprotected and still went unpicked last winter. He turned that around with a .821 OPS and 21 homers at Erie.
Beyond those bigger names, the decision gets trickier. Rule 5 clubs usually lean toward pitchers who can survive in relief, because asking a pitcher with no big-league experience to start for an entire season is a tough sell. Teams are typically hunting for two-pitch arms who can cover 40 to 60 innings and keep developing under team control.
Peyton Graham is one of the more interesting wild cards. The 2022 second-round pick from Oklahoma set an Erie franchise record with 66 stolen bases while hitting .290/.397/.429. That kind of speed and defensive flexibility is exactly what Rule 5 teams tend to chase, and it stands out even more because the Tigers finished 29th in stolen bases in 2026.
Tanner Kohlhepp also fits the profile of a player who could draw attention. The Notre Dame right-hander worked almost entirely out of the bullpen at Double-A, where he logged a 3.86 ERA, 71 strikeouts and a 1.02 WHIP over 63 innings in 44 appearances.
He has only seven career starts and has been Rule 5-eligible since 2024, but scouts still see him as a possible surprise selection or a player Detroit may want to protect. In 179 career innings, he has struck out 224 batters.
Joe Miller gives Harris another decision point. The former Penn and Savannah Bananas left-hander made 20 starts in 23 appearances, finished with a 3.95 ERA, and piled up 87 strikeouts across 82 innings. Another team could view him as a swingman or bulk reliever, and that gives Detroit a reason to consider shielding him for bullpen depth and flexibility.
Of course, none of this is fully settled yet. The Collective Bargaining Agreement expires on Dec. 1, and baseball’s last lockout in 2021 led to the major league phase of the Rule 5 draft being postponed and eventually canceled. So there’s a real chance the whole thing never comes into play.
And if the draft does happen, there’s another wrinkle: players on the 40-man roster can’t use team facilities, while those left off can. That could make clubs hesitant to claim a player they can’t fully work with, which in turn could give Detroit a little more breathing room with borderline decisions.
However it unfolds, Harris appears positioned to keep building. Ownership’s stance is clear, with Chris Ilitch saying exceeding the luxury tax is “really not an issue” if Harris wants to add. With that kind of support, the Tigers have room to be aggressive - and room to protect the right prospects, too.
In Other News...
Tigers Quietly Made A Depth Move That Puts Focus On Who's Next
The Tigers kept busy with a low-key round of minor league business, bringing back veteran catcher Carlos Prez along with several relief arms on new minor league contracts. Prez had served as the Triple-A depth option behind the plate and was swinging the bat well before an ankle injury ended his season, making his return a sensible move for a club that values catching depth and familiarity in the system.
Detroit also re-signed relievers Moises Rodriguez, Marco Jimenez and Wandisson Charles, each of whom has flashed potential at different minor league levels. Moves like these rarely draw much attention, but they matter in an organization that is always trying to stock enough arms for the long grind, and they also raise the usual question around this time of year: which of these pitchers can force their way into the picture next? [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Have A Buy-Low Rotation Target Fans Should Notice
Foster Griffin is the kind of free-agent arm the Tigers have reason to keep on the radar if theyre looking for value rather than headline-grabbing money. The left-hander just finished a postseason run with the Guardians that quietly checked a lot of boxes, turning in a 3.48 ERA over 10 innings with 15 strikeouts and no walks while giving Cleveland another useful option out of the bullpen.
What makes Griffin especially interesting from Detroits perspective is the winding path that brought him back here. After Tommy John surgery in 2021, he spent time in Japan with the Yomiuri Giants before returning to MLB with the Nationals in 2026 and later being traded to Cleveland, a journey that suggests both resilience and adaptability. For a Tigers club that could still benefit from adding pitching depth without overextending itself, Griffin fits the profile of a buy-low target worth a closer look. [Read more 🡒]
Kevin McGonigle Just Took Another Big Step In Detroits Future
Kevin McGonigles first full taste of the majors could hardly have gone much better. The young infielder was named the American Leagues Outstanding Rookie of the Year by the MLB Players Association after a strong debut season with the Tigers, one in which he quickly established himself as more than just a promising name in the pipeline. He led Detroit with 168 hits, earned an AL All-Star nod and picked up AL Rookie of the Month honors in April, all while showing the kind of steady production teams hope to build around.
The recognition matters because it reflects how quickly McGonigles game has translated and how widely his work has been noticed around the league. Even with the individual acclaim, hes already talking like a player looking past the award shelf and toward the Tigers bigger picture, focusing on helping Detroit win in future seasons. For a club trying to turn young talent into lasting contention, that kind of early traction is exactly the sort of step forward that matters. [Read more 🡒]