The MLB trade deadline is closing in fast, and the spotlight usually lands on the biggest names. Tarik Skubal.
Mason Miller. The headline-grabbers.
But there’s another layer to this market: players whose careers have stalled so badly that a new uniform might be the only real way forward.
Some of them were once elite prospects. Some reached All-Star status before falling off hard.
Others just seem trapped in the wrong place at the wrong time. Whatever the reason, the fit has gone bad, and these five players could use a reset.
Anthony Volpe might need it more than anyone.
The 25-year-old shortstop came into the league with the kind of hype that can crush a player if the bat never catches up. A former top prospect and a Yankees fan growing up, Volpe was saddled with the Derek Jeter comparisons whether he asked for them or not.
The glove has held up, but the offense never became what the Yankees projected. In more than 500 career games, he has hit .225/.288/.375 with a wRC+ of 86.
That’s a long way from the player scouts thought they were getting in 2023, when he debuted as a consensus top-10 prospect with an advanced approach, a plus hit tool and real raw power. Instead, his fourth MLB season has become a dead end.
The Yankees have used him in only 52 games this year, and the situation in the Bronx has turned toxic. Jose Caballero is now the team’s first-choice shortstop, which leaves Volpe looking expendable.
Spencer Torkelson is in a different kind of bind, but the same basic problem applies: the Tigers still have not gotten the version of the player they drafted first overall in 2020.
Torkelson entered that draft as the obvious power bat, a slugger who had already made noise at Arizona State by breaking Barry Bonds’s freshman home run record there. Detroit took him at No. 1 despite the fact that he was limited to first base and hit from the right side.
The bat and the power were supposed to carry the profile. For stretches, they have.
But not enough, and not consistently enough.
Now 26, he still hasn’t put together back-to-back solid big-league seasons. His career line sits at .233/.309/.412 with a wRC+ of 101, and the strikeouts have been a constant problem at 26.7%.
He did have a real 2025 season, tying a career high with 31 home runs while setting personal bests in batting average (.240), on-base percentage (.333), slugging (.456) and wRC+ (118). This year, though, he has slipped back again.
Through 108 games, he’s hitting .210 with a .724 OPS, a wRC+ of 99 and a career-worst 31.9% strikeout rate. Even so, he still has two years of control left and can barrel the ball at a strong clip.
That makes him the kind of player another organization could try to unlock.
Matt Shaw’s case is less about pedigree collapsing and more about a situation that may have simply gone stale.
A first-round pick in 2023 and a top-25 prospect entering the 2025 season, Shaw made the Opening Day roster but has not turned that opportunity into stability. He’s now on the injured list with a sprained left hand and won’t return until after the trade deadline, though that doesn’t rule out a move. In fact, it may make one easier.
Shaw had some bright moments as a rookie, but his first 180-plus big-league games have mostly been a grind. He finished last season at .226/.295/.394 with 13 home runs and a wRC+ of 93.
This year has been better, but only to a point: in 56 games, he’s slashing .246/.322/.415 with four home runs and a 105 wRC+. He’s only 24, he can move around the diamond, and the tools are still there.
But the fit in Chicago no longer looks clean, and his outspoken political views haven’t made him many friends there.
Bo Naylor’s slide has been even more severe.
The younger Naylor brother was once one of Cleveland’s better prospects after being taken in the first round in 2018. He debuted late in the 2022 season and then got a real run the following year, when he posted a strong 123 wRC+ in 67 games.
That looked like the beginning of something. Instead, it has been the high point.
Since then, the production has cratered. Across 2024 and 2025, he has hit .198/.273/.365 in 246 games.
This season, he has spent time at Triple A trying to get his swing back, but in 28 major league games he has managed just .143/.200/.238 with a wRC+ of 21. The addition of Patrick Bailey has made the path to playing time behind the plate look even murkier.
Naylor still has some real traits to work with - a solid arm, enough power to matter, and a track record of hitting while climbing the minors - but he clearly needs a fresh start.
Michael Lorenzen rounds out the list, and his situation is the most straightforward of all: the Rockies need to get him out of Denver.
Lorenzen was an All-Star and posted a 3.31 ERA as recently as 2024, but this season has gone sideways after he signed a one-year, $8 million deal with Colorado in the offseason. In 23 appearances, including 22 starts, he is 3-9 with a 6.54 ERA and a 1.81 WHIP, with 80 strikeouts and 40 walks over 104 2/3 innings.
His Statcast page is a mess, with single-digit percentile rankings across most categories. It has been one of the roughest pitching performances in the league this year.
Still, Lorenzen has a résumé. He’s had multiple sub-4.00 ERA seasons as both a starter and reliever, and at this point he profiles more like a fifth starter than anything else.
The problem is obvious: Coors Field has been brutal on him, and his 8.34 home ERA says plenty. His contract includes a $9 million club option for next season with a $250,000 buyout, but there’s little reason to think he’ll be back in Colorado.
If the Rockies want to move on, the deadline is the cleanest way to do it.
In Other News...
Tigers Just Made A Move That Feels Bigger Than One Prospect
The Tigers are giving Max Clark his first big-league look ahead of this weekends series against the Athletics, a move that says plenty about where the organization is right now. Clark has earned the promotion with a strong run at Triple-A Toledo, and the plan is for him to get work in center field as Detroit continues sorting out its outfield and roster picture.
What makes the timing stand out is the broader backdrop around the club, with the deadline arriving fast and the front office still weighing its options. Clarks arrival adds another layer to a week already filled with questions, especially with Javier Baez working back from injury and the Tigers deciding how much runway to give the rookie once he joins the mix. [Read more 🡒]
Scott Harris Just Sent Tigers Fans A Brutal Deadline Message
The Tigers have spent the days leading into the trade deadline trying to decide whether to keep pushing or start thinking bigger picture, and the roster move involving their catching mix only sharpened that conversation. Detroit is still sitting seven games under .500, and even with Eduardo Valencia turning in a strong showing in recent action, the clubs margin for error remains thin as the deadline creeps closer.
For a team with long postseason odds, every decision now carries extra weight, especially with the front office balancing present-day needs against what comes next. Tarik Skubal has naturally become part of that conversation, too, as rival clubs keep monitoring whether Detroit will listen if the right offer comes along before the deadline passes. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers May Have A Deadline Piece Fans Never Saw Coming
As the trade deadline nears, Detroit is still sorting out whether it will lean into buying, selling or some uneasy mix of both, and that uncertainty has created room for a name few fans would have expected to hear in the mix. Ben Malgeri, promoted from Triple-A after a strong stretch there, has quietly become the kind of under-the-radar piece front offices like to tuck into larger discussions.
Malgeri is not viewed as one of the organizations marquee prospects, but that can actually make him useful when the Tigers start trying to bridge gaps in a deal. A player with his profile can help grease the wheels in deadline talks, especially if Detroit decides to move beyond simply standing pat and starts looking for ways to reshape the roster before the market closes. [Read more 🡒]