The Javy Báez question is back for the Tigers, and it’s hovering over the club again as his contract nears its end.
Detroit has lived with this deal since the 2021-2022 offseason, when Al Avila handed out one of the organization’s biggest splashes in years: Eduardo Rodríguez on a five-year, $77 million pact and Báez on the now-infamous six-year, $140 million contract. Rodríguez is gone. Báez is still here, and his deal remains one of the franchise’s worst and one of the worst active contracts in the game.
And yet the relationship has gotten weirdly warmer lately.
That shift really traces to May 13, 2025, when Báez broke out the biggest moment of his Tigers tenure: a three-run homer in the bottom of the 11th against the Red Sox to complete a comeback win after Detroit had been down by two. The “Javy” chants at Comerica Park were a first. He cooled off badly after the All-Star break, then missed a large chunk of 2026 with injury, but with injuries piling up around the roster, his return almost felt like a bonus.
Now the clock is ticking again, and the same old question is back: should the Tigers absorb the rest of the money and move on early?
Báez was gradually squeezed out during the 2026 season. Injury slowed him, and when he returned, Detroit’s roster looked different. More young infielders had arrived, and his playing time shrank as McGonigle, Hao-Yu Lee and John Peck entered the mix alongside Gleyber Torres.
Still, Báez has managed to carve out value in other ways. He’s shown he can handle center field, and there’s still some of the old El Mago left in his defense and on the bases. But even that came with complications once Max Clark arrived.
The Tigers have never seemed willing to eat what’s left on a contract that’s been impossible to move. Báez is owed $24 million in 2027, and the club has long treated that as too much to swallow.
He was signed to be a centerpiece. Instead, he has been pushed closer and closer to the margins.
An offseason cut seems unlikely. But if the season drags on and Báez is spending more time on the bench than on the field, the Tigers could decide it’s not worth carrying him just to keep paying him.
In Other News...
Max Clark Looks Like A Tigers Starter But One Question Remains
Max Clarks first look in pro ball only reinforced why the Tigers are so interested in his future. Across 206 plate appearances, he kept finding ways to put the ball in play, worked through 754 pitches and backed up the profile with steady production at multiple minor league stops. The broader package is appealing too: he has looked like a contact hitter who can handle center field, with his defense and baserunning grading out well enough to keep him on a path toward regular duty.
The numbers also point to a player who already looks ready for a starting role, with a 115 wRC+ and 1.4 fWAR showing real value beyond just projection. The lingering question is how he handles the softer stuff, because off-speed pitches still gave him trouble and will be the part of his game opposing pitchers keep testing until he proves they cannot. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Fans Have A New Offseason Idea To Debate
Rumors are already starting to swirl around the Tigers' offseason, and one of the louder ideas floating around is whether Jazz Chisholm Jr. could fit as a long-term answer in the infield. For a club looking to keep building on its recent momentum, that kind of name instantly changes the conversation, because it suggests Detroit may not be content to shop only for depth and stopgap help.
The debate is part baseball fit, part bigger-picture ambition, the kind of discussion that tends to surface before the market really takes shape. Alongside the roster chatter, Kirk Gibson is set to be honored with the Stan Musial Award, a reminder that this time of year always mixes present-day speculation with a little franchise history, even as the Tigers wait to see how serious any of these offseason ideas become. [Read more 🡒]
Two Tigers Have A Real Shot At Defensive Hardware
Dillon Dingler and Zach McKinstry have given the Tigers something to watch as the season winds down on the awards front, with both players landing among the finalists for the 2026 American League Gold Glove Award. Dingler is back in the mix after already winning the honor last season, while McKinstry has also earned a spot among the leagues best defenders at his position, a useful reminder of how much value Detroit has gotten from run prevention as well as run production.
Dinglers competition includes Brandon Valenzuela and Austin Wells, while McKinstry is up against Jos Caballero and Ezequiel Duran. The winners will be announced Nov. 1 at 8:30 p.m. ET, giving the Tigers a chance to add some individual hardware to a year that has already featured plenty of attention on the clubs overall progress. [Read more 🡒]