Illegal? NFL Addresses Maye-Hutchinson Controversy

The debate intensifies over whether Aidan Hutchinson's controversial tackle on Drake Maye during the Patriots-Lions game was an illegal move contributing to Maye's injury.

The biggest talking point out of the Patriots’ opening drive against the Lions wasn’t a flag that was thrown. It was the one that stayed in the pocket.

On Sunday, Detroit edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson got to Drake Maye from behind as the New England quarterback tried to climb the pocket, and Maye’s ankle was injured on the play. That immediately set off the question of whether Hutchinson should have been penalized, but the answer from the league side was no.

The sequence started with what looked like a breakdown in communication involving left tackle Will Campbell. Hutchinson shot into the backfield, wrapped Maye up from behind, lifted his body off the ground, and came down on Maye’s injured ankle. From there, the debate centered on whether the tackle fit the NFL’s definition of a hip-drop.

According to NFL rules Section 2, Article 18, it does not. The rule says a foul requires a player to grab or wrap the runner, then unweight himself by swiveling and dropping his hips and/or lower body, landing on or trapping the runner’s legs at or below the knee.

FOX rules analyst Mike Pereira laid out the same standard during the broadcast.

“Three things have to happen,” he explained. “You have to unweight yourself, swivel all around the back and land on the back of his leg below the knee.

This was more of a horse collar-type pulled down from behind. [But] certainly not a horse collar penalty.”

The NFL backed that up, according to ESPN’s Mike Reiss. Walt Anderson, the league’s officiating rules analyst, confirmed Pereira’s explanation through a league spokesman and said it was not a hip-drop tackle because there was no swivel or unweighting.

It also wasn’t ruled a horse collar tackle. Pereira pointed out that neither the collar nor the nameplate was grabbed, and referee Clay Martin’s crew did not throw a flag.

Vrabel, who has already had his share of run-ins with officials this season, didn’t see anything dirty in the moment either.

“I don’t think it was [a hip-drop tackle],” he said on Monday. That followed similar comments he made after the game on Sunday.

“I’m not going to assume there was something there,” he said. “However it happened, I don’t think it was anything intentional.

I’m sure that it wasn’t. That’s part of the game.”

In Other News...

Riley Greene Trade Buzz Puts Tigers Fans In A Tough Spot

The chatter around Riley Greene has been hard to ignore, but Scott Harris tried to put some perspective on it during the GM Meetings. Detroits president of baseball operations said the Tigers listen to all trade possibilities, which is standard operating procedure this time of year, while making clear that Greene is viewed as a central part of the lineup going forward.

Harris has never been one to hand out untouchable labels, so the door is never completely shut in theory. Even so, Greenes All-Star resume and arbitration status only add to the sense that he fits what Detroit is trying to build, not what it should be shopping away, and the current read is that a move this offseason is unlikely. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers May Have Another Shortstop Prospect Fans Need To Watch

Detroits pipeline at shortstop got a little more interesting this season with Angel de los Santos, an 18-year-old signee out of the Dominican Republic who moved from the Complex League to Single-A Lakeland after arriving in January. Even at that age, he has already shown a blend of tools that tends to get attention quickly in the organization, pairing a .302 average in the Complex League with a game built around athleticism and range.

De los Santos also swiped 30 bases across both levels, which only adds to the appeal for a player scouts believe could grow into power, speed and strong defense at a premium position. There is still development ahead, especially in areas like pitch recognition, but for a Tigers system that always seems to be searching for the next long-term answer in the middle of the diamond, he is a name worth keeping on the radar. [Read more 🡒]

Tigers May Be Zeroing In On A Bullpen Answer

The Tigers have been linked to another veteran bullpen arm, with BBWAA writer Francys Romero reporting interest in right-hander Raisel Iglesias. The 36-year-old has long been known for steady relief work, and his 2024 season with the Atlanta Braves only added to the appeal for a club still looking to firm up the late innings.

Iglesias brings the kind of track record teams usually chase when they want a proven answer rather than a projection, and Detroits interest suggests the front office is still weighing experienced options for the back end of the bullpen. Nothing is official yet, but the fit is easy to see for a team that could use more certainty in relief as the roster takes shape. [Read more 🡒]