Framber Valdez arrived in Detroit with real expectations attached, and the Tigers paid accordingly. Last winter, they gave the left-hander a three-year, $115MM deal, the third-largest contract among free-agent starters, hoping he’d pair with two-time reigning AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal and give the rotation a true southpaw punch.
Instead, Valdez’s first season in Detroit came up short. He finished with a 4.03 ERA, his highest since he became a full-time starter in 2020.
His strikeout rate slid to a career-low 17.8%, while his walk rate climbed to its highest level since 2021. He wasn’t the only reason the Tigers missed the postseason, but he also didn’t give the staff the steady innings they were counting on.
The biggest shift started on the ground. Valdez still posted a strong 56.3% groundball rate, but that figure was down from his career 61.5% mark and represented his second-lowest total as a big leaguer, with only 2023 sitting lower.
That matters because his whole profile is built around forcing the ball into the dirt and limiting damage. Even with that dip, he remained well above the league average groundball rate of 44.1% in 2026.
That kind of approach has always helped him survive some hard-contact issues. Valdez tends to live near the bottom 10th percentile in hard-hit rate and average exit velocity, but grounders keep the damage in check. When the ball stays on the ground, the WHIP can run a little higher, yet the ERA usually lands in that low-to-mid 3.00s range.
This year, though, fewer grounders meant more balls in the air, and more of those were pulled. Valdez posted a career-high 16.4% pulled air rate, which is around league average but well above his 10.7% career norm.
He had been below 10% in five of the previous six seasons before this one. The result was a .258 batting average against and a .370 slugging percentage - not a disaster, but a noticeable step back.
Those are numbers he hasn’t allowed since his relief days.
The strikeouts disappeared, too. Valdez has never been an overpowering arm, but he’s usually close to a punchout per inning.
In 2026, he dipped below a 21% strikeout rate for the first time as a full-time starter. His swinging-strike rate also cratered to 8.7%, which ranked 42nd among 46 qualified starters.
The curveball was the clearest culprit. His main breaking pitch produced a 31.8% whiff rate, far below its usual standard.
Since his rookie year in 2018, that pitch had never posted a whiff rate below 39.8% in a season. He also threw it about 1 mph slower than he did the year before, with a little more vertical drop and less horizontal movement.
The difference wasn’t massive, but it was enough to stand out.
Valdez also never really found one of those dominant stretches he usually seems to hit every season. In 2025, he caught fire from June through July, when he logged a 1.93 ERA and a 28.9% strikeout rate.
He allowed just 11 earned runs across his final nine starts in 2024. This season lacked that kind of heater, aside from a 1.93 ERA over four September starts.
None of that points to a broken pitcher. It looked more like several small issues piling up at once, with the added pressure of starting over on a major contract possibly playing a role as well. With Skubal and Casey Mize traded away, and Jack Flaherty and Justin Verlander also gone, Detroit will need the Astros version of Valdez to show up in 2027.
In Other News...
Tigers Face One Growing 2027 Problem At Shortstop
The Tigers have spent a good part of this season trying to sort out an infield that has not held up well defensively, and shortstop has become the clearest pressure point. The overall range numbers have lagged, and the clubs Fielding Run Value has reflected the mess, even as Zach McKinstry has provided the cleanest glove work among Detroit shortstops.
Looking ahead to 2027, the bigger issue is how Detroit balances offense and defense across the dirt without creating another weak spot. Trey Sweeney and Javier Baez have not given the Tigers enough defensively, and the organization may have other infield options to weigh at third base, including Kevin McGonigle, Hao-Yu Lee and Colt Keith, but shortstop remains the position that could shape the entire alignment. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Prospects Just Raised A Bigger Question For Detroit's Future
The Tigers got a useful reminder about the state of their farm system when MLB Pipeline named Max Anderson and Ben Jacobs the organizations Prospects of the Year. Anderson, ranked No. 10 in the system, turned in a strong Triple-A season and gave Detroit another look at a bat that has been trending in the right direction. Jacobs, the No. 6 prospect, made his mark at High-A with a pitchers toolkit that drew attention all season, especially with the way he missed bats and settled in as the year went on.
For Detroit, the honor is more than just a seasonal award. Andersons status adds an immediate layer of intrigue because he is eligible for the Rule 5 Draft this offseason, which makes his future part of a larger roster puzzle. Jacobs, meanwhile, continues to push his way forward as one of the more interesting arms in the system, giving the Tigers a pair of prospects who are forcing the front office to think not just about development, but about how soon those improvements might need to turn into decisions. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Fans Have Every Right To Question This Front Office
The frustration around the Tigers is not just about one bad season. It is about a club with a promising young core still finishing 2026 well short of expectations, while other small- and mid-market teams keep finding ways to stay competitive with similar or even lower payrolls. When Milwaukee, Tampa Bay and Cleveland keep stacking wins with leaner budgets, it naturally puts Detroits operation under a brighter light and invites uncomfortable comparisons.
That is why the criticism has started to land on Scott Harris and the broader front office approach. The talent base is there to make the Tigers more than a rebuilding exercise, but the results have not matched the promise, and fans have every right to wonder whether the organization is getting enough out of the resources it has. Until that gap closes, the questions around how this team is being run are not going away. [Read more 🡒]