Eduardo Valencia hasn’t piled up a huge body of work since his MLB debut in July, but the early returns have been loud enough to force a real conversation in Detroit.
In fewer than 30 games, Valencia has made one thing obvious every time he steps in: he can hit. His first big-league at-bat set the tone with a pinch-hit homer on July 9, and he has kept driving the ball ever since. He’s added five more home runs and 16 RBI, and through 83 at-bats he’s sitting on a .313 average with a .956 OPS.
The one area that does not travel with the bat is his plate discipline. Valencia doesn’t walk - pretty much ever. But when he connects, the contact is loud.
Detroit has already used him all over the map. Valencia has started 10 games at catcher, made a brief appearance at first base and gotten eight starts at DH across 15 total appearances. There’s a good chance he’ll keep seeing more time behind the plate in September as Dillon Dingler continues to struggle offensively, but the bigger question is what Valencia’s role should look like beyond this season.
The Tigers may be better off thinking in terms of a more permanent DH spot.
Valencia is a below-average defensive catcher, and Detroit could go find its next Jake Rogers in the offseason if it wants to. No. 5 prospect Josue Briceño is also pressing toward the majors, and while he projects better at first base, the Tigers will likely want to see what he can do behind Dingler before they commit to that move.
That’s where the roster puzzle gets interesting. A full-time DH is not exactly how the Tigers usually operate. Their lineup was built to stay flexible, and AJ Hinch rarely keeps one player at DH for more than two games in a row.
That approach has included plenty of moving parts. During June and July, Dingler’s bat was strong enough that he was getting DH starts when he wasn’t catching.
Colt Keith has also been a regular at DH, and Kerry Carpenter will presumably get a lot of work there in 2027. Even Kevin McGonigle has logged two games there this season.
Still, the offseason may come down to a tougher sort of pruning. Beyond a major bullpen overhaul, the Tigers may need to sort out what really matters and cut back on some of the excess. They’re young, but some players are already making cases for more defined roles.
The fluid setup has worked before. But Detroit may be reaching the point where it has to settle in and make some firm choices, even if that means moving on from a few names that once looked like lineup fixtures.
For now, the Tigers and their fans should keep watching Valencia closely over the rest of the season. They need to know whether this kind of production can hold. So far, he’s given them every reason to believe it can.
In Other News...
Tigers Just Reopened A Deadline Frustration Fans Never Wanted
As the Tigers drift out of playoff contention, the playing time is starting to tilt toward the future, with younger players such as infielder John Peck getting more of a look. It is the kind of shift that usually comes late in a lost season, when development matters more than squeezing out every last win and the organization begins to sort out who belongs in the next wave.
The frustration for Detroit is that the deadline did not fully match that reality. Gleyber Torres stayed put despite carrying real value and looming free agency, a decision that fit the broader mixed approach under president of baseball operations Scott Harris. The Tigers tried to walk the line between selling and staying competitive, and for fans, that half-step has only revived an old question about what kind of season this was supposed to be. [Read more 🡒]
Casey Mize Trade Is Suddenly Looking Better For The Tigers
At the August 3 trade deadline, Detroit moved Casey Mize to San Diego, and the deal looked like the kind of swap both clubs could judge over time. Since arriving with the Padres, Mize has had a rough run in six starts, going 1-3 with a 6.67 ERA, which has only sharpened the spotlight on what the Tigers gave up and what they got back.
Jackson Wolf and Kash Mayfield were among the pieces heading to Detroit, and their early returns have come in different forms across their respective leagues. The larger picture still needs more time to settle, but for now the early results have made the Tigers' side of the trade appear a little more encouraging than it did in the moment. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Waste Promising Rookie Start In Another Brutal Cleveland Finish
Andrew Sears gave Detroit exactly the kind of debut start a team can build around, working 5.2 innings and allowing one run in his first major league outing. For a club trying to steady itself after a rough stretch, the rookies poise was one of the few bright spots on a night when the offense again had trouble turning opportunities into enough runs.
Instead, the Tigers left Cleveland with a sweep and another painful finish in a 4-3 loss, a game that turned in the late innings and then slipped away completely in extra time. Detroit also had to watch Hao-Yu Lee exit after a collision at the plate, leaving the club to sort through both the result and another possible injury issue from a trip that offered too little offense and too much damage. [Read more 🡒]