After the deadline passed, the Brewers took plenty of heat for not landing Tarik Skubal. They were treated as one of the teams most likely to make a run at him, right there with the Dodgers, and the whole thing invited easy comparisons to Milwaukee’s 2008 splash for CC Sabathia.
But new details show the Brewers did, in fact, make a serious push.
Scott Harris and the Tigers ended up sending Skubal to the Dodgers for outfielder Zyhir Hope and pitchers River Ryan and Brady Smith. Milwaukee, meanwhile, was left facing the familiar question of whether it would ever make the kind of move that signals a true all-in approach.
It turns out the answer was yes - at least on the offer sheet.
Andy McCullough of The Athletic reported after the deadline that Milwaukee put together an aggressive package for Skubal. The Brewers would not include starter Logan Henderson, a refusal that had already been reported. Even so, their offer still featured infielder Luis Peña, their No. 2 prospect, utility man Jett Williams, their No. 10 prospect, and outfielder Josh Adamczewski, their No. 3 prospect.
“From there, the Brewers brass received radio silence until that evening when they saw Dodgers Double-A outfielder Zyhir Hope was scratched,” McCullough wrote. “Soon after, Harris called [Matt] Arnold to let him know Skubal would not be a Brewer.”
Arnold made it clear he appreciated the way the talks were handled.
“I appreciated the s- out of that,” Arnold said. “He was very transparent.”
Detroit, for its part, was never going to be moved without pitching, and the Dodgers came through with two arms. Ryan was technically major league-ready, even while coming off a hamstring issue. Milwaukee’s package, by contrast, only really offered one player who might have helped the Tigers right away after the deadline in Williams, and even he has been struggling a bit at Triple-A.
The postseason only sharpened the odd logic of the whole thing. Starting pitching barely mattered across the board.
Jacob Misiorowski never went more than six innings in a start, and it took until his third outing for him to get through five. Skubal himself went six and five in his two starts before the Dodgers were swept out of the postseason, reducing the deal to a simple exchange: three prospects for 11 Tarik Skubal innings.
For the Brewers, though, this is the cleanest kind of vindication. They made a real bid for Skubal, and they still ended up winning a World Series without him.
In Other News...
Tarik Skubal Trade Saga Looks Wilder After Tigers Deadline Pivot
The Tarik Skubal trade chatter that swirled around the deadline now looks even more intriguing in hindsight, especially with Andy McCullough of The Athletic reporting that Milwaukee put together a substantial offer to try to pry the left-hander away from Detroit. The Brewers were willing to part with a package that included prospects Luis Pea, Jett Williams and Josh Adamczewski, a reminder of how much interest there was in one of the sports most coveted starters as the Tigers weighed their options.
Milwaukee ultimately stopped short of including starter Logan Henderson, and that proved to be the line it would not cross. Detroit still moved Skubal, but not to the Brewers, and the reported deal instead sent him to the Dodgers as the deadline frenzy kept reshaping the market. The twist for Brewers fans is obvious enough: even without landing Skubal, they still went on to win the World Series, leaving their near-miss as one of the more fascinating what-ifs of the summer. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Have An Early Bullpen Target Worth Watching Closely
The Tigers are still looking for bullpen help, and Sean Newcomb is the kind of left-handed arm worth keeping on the radar. Detroit could use depth in relief, and Newcombs recent stint with the White Sox gave him a chance to show he can still be a useful option in multiple roles. For a club trying to keep its pitching staff flexible, a veteran who can cover different innings has some appeal.
Newcomb also comes with the sort of questions that usually follow a late free-agent fit. His age and recent performance decline make him less of a sure thing than the top names on the market, and the looming expiration of the collective bargaining agreement adds another layer to the timing. If the Tigers do circle back on him, the decision could come down to whether they think the upside is still there for a bullpen that needs reliable depth without much room for mistakes. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Already Face A 2027 Debate Fans Wont Ignore
The early 2027 Tigers projections are already stirring debate, even though the season is still far off. National outlets have taken a first pass at where Detroit might stand, and the results are far from uniform. ESPN placed the Tigers seventh in its early power ranking, while The Athletic slotted them 16th, a spread that says as much about how hard this roster is to read as it does about the team itself.
Both evaluations point to the same basic foundation: Detroit has a strong run differential and a collection of young talent that gives the organization real upside. But the gap in those rankings also reflects the lingering questions, especially in the bullpen and in how quickly several key young players develop. For a club trying to turn promise into something more durable, the future still looks exciting, just not nearly certain. [Read more 🡒]