Casey Mize’s latest injury scare has given the Tigers’ extension conversation a jolt of reality.
What looked like a routine early exit from Sunday’s start against the Angels turned into something more frustrating for Detroit. Mize was lifted after 3 1/3 innings when a comebacker hit his wrist, but after the game he revealed he has also been dealing with groin tightness. That’s the part that has Tigers fans uneasy, especially with the issue sitting uncomfortably close to his previous adductor strain.
The good news, at least for now, is that Mize is expected to take his next scheduled turn. But this is still another reminder of the same problem that keeps shadowing his season: the talent is obvious, the durability is not.
There’s no question Mize has pitched well this year. He may not be fully matching the weight of being a first overall pick, but he has shown enough to look like a strong No. 2 starter in a major league rotation.
The catch is that he keeps getting knocked off track. He has already spent two stints on the IL this season, and the latest scare only adds to the concern.
Health has to be part of any Tigers decision on whether to extend him or bring him back. Even if the price comes down, the bigger question is whether the investment makes sense if he can’t stay on the mound.
Mize could still build a strong case for himself in free agency if he finishes the season well. The comparison that comes up is Tyler Glasnow: plenty of talent, plenty of injury baggage, and still enough upside to land a massive deal. Glasnow had never thrown more than 134 innings in a season before the Dodgers gave him more than $136 million over five years.
Mize is not quite in the same bucket. He hasn’t been as overpowering when healthy, and he also has fewer years of service time than Glasnow had when he was traded and extended. Still, Cody Stavenhagen of The Athletic speculated that Mize could land a contract with a $25 million AAV if he gets past 3 WAR this season, especially with the upcoming free agent class looking thin.
From Detroit’s side, though, that kind of number may be hard to swallow. The Tigers already have a rotation picture for 2027 that looks crowded, with Framber Valdez, Troy Melton, Keider Montero, Jackson Jobe, and hopefully Reese Olson in the mix. Add Mize’s injury history to the equation, and the fit gets murkier.
So the next few weeks matter. Whether Mize avoids a third IL stint could end up being the key factor if the Tigers are seriously weighing a deal. And beyond the contract talk, a healthy Mize is going to matter for this stretch run before the deadline and any postseason push that follows.
In Other News...
Tigers Escaped A First Inning Mess With A Play Nobody Saw Coming
The first inning was already drifting toward trouble when Troy Melton found himself in a bizarre bit of cleanup work behind the plate. After a swinging third strike bounced away, Dillon Dingler briefly lost track of the ball and didnt realize the batter had gone after it, turning what should have been a routine out into a scramble with a runner trying to advance.
Melton saved the sequence by sprinting home and stepping on the plate before the run could score, a heads-up finish to a play that almost nobody sees. It was the kind of oddball first-inning escape that can change the tone of a game, and even around the Tigers it stood out as the sort of moment that leaves everyone checking the rulebook and replay afterward. [Read more 🡒]
Tarik Skubal Just Created A Brutal New Question For Tigers Fans
Tarik Skubals latest comments add a troubling layer to a situation Tigers fans were already watching closely. The left-hander said he felt discomfort in his elbow as early as January, but he did not get an MRI, leaving the club and its supporters to wonder how long the issue had been simmering before it became public.
What makes it sting even more is the backdrop around it. Skubal pointed to the upcoming arbitration fight with Detroit as part of why he did not report the problem, and he also acknowledged that his relationship with the front office has been strained since that hearing. For a team that needs its ace healthy and aligned, the bigger question now is how much damage has already been done behind the scenes. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Suddenly Face A Risky Deadline Question In Center Field
With the trade deadline approaching and Detroit still in the playoff hunt, center field has become one of the more interesting spots to watch. The Tigers have mixed and matched there with Matt Vierling and James Outman, and a report from Jim Bowden of The Athletic has floated New York Mets outfielder Luis Robert Jr. as a possible target if Detroit decides it needs a more stable answer.
Roberts appeal is easy to see even with his season interrupted by injury. He has long handled left-handed pitching well, and that kind of split could matter for a Tigers lineup looking for any edge it can find in a tight race. The question is whether Detroit thinks the upside is worth the risk, especially with a player whose availability has been limited and whose market would come with plenty of uncertainty attached. [Read more 🡒]