Steve Yzerman’s run as general manager of the Detroit Red Wings is going to be remembered in two very different lights.
At the front end, he hit on major draft picks and gave the organization a real foundation with players like Moritz Seider and Lucas Raymond. At the back end, the picture has gotten far messier, with Dylan Larkin wanting out, Detroit sitting a full decade removed from the playoffs and the mood around the team sounding bleak.
That split is what makes Yzerman’s tenure such a mixed bag. His biggest wins and his biggest misfires tell the story.
The strongest part of his work has been the draft. Yzerman’s first-round haul has been impressive, with Seider emerging as a top-five defenseman in the NHL, Raymond developing into a top winger and Simon Edvinsson becoming one of the premier shutdown defensemen in the league.
He’s also found value deeper in the draft, landing Elmer Soderblom in the sixth round and Red Wings Rookie of the Year Emmitt Finnie in the seventh. Even with some inconsistency in the second round, the overall track record says he can identify talent in almost every round.
The problem has been what happened once it was time to add veterans. His pro scouting has been a mess, and the contract and trade decisions reflect that.
Long-term deals for underperforming players like J.T. Compher and costly moves for players such as Justin Faulk have left the roster short on value.
The Ben Chiarot extension, which runs until he’s 38, only adds to the issue, especially with so many players crowding the lineup and blocking younger defensemen like Axel Sandin-Pellikka and William Wallinder. Jacob Bernard-Docker is part of that logjam too.
Yzerman also deserves credit for one of his better trades: bringing in Jake Walman from the St. Louis Blues in 2022.
Detroit got Oskar Sundqvist, Walman and a second round pick for Nick Leddy and Luke Witkowski. Leddy’s production with the Blues was underwhelming, while Walman quickly grew into a top-pairing defenseman.
The second round pick eventually helped the Red Wings land Andrew Gibson, who has not yet made his NHL debut, and the pick before that was used to acquire Trey Augustine, who looks like the goaltender of the future if things go well in Grand Rapids.
But that move makes the next one look even worse. Yzerman later sent Walman and a second round pick to the San Jose Sharks for future considerations.
He never publicly explained the decision, and to this day he still hasn’t addressed it. The result was brutal: Detroit got nothing back.
San Jose then flipped Walman to the Edmonton Oilers for a first round and second round pick, turning half a season of Walman into a major return. For Detroit to walk away with zero value from a young defenseman like that is a serious mark against Yzerman’s record.
Another clear win came with the Alex DeBrincat trade. Yzerman landed the hometown forward from the Ottawa Senators for Dominik Kubalik, Donovan Sebrango and a conditional first round pick.
Ottawa was stuck with DeBrincat, and Yzerman took advantage. Kubalik finished with just 15 points before heading to Europe, Sebrango was claimed off waivers by the Florida Panthers, and the first round pick Detroit sent out was later used to acquire Linus Ullmark, who posted a .891 save percentage with the Senators last season.
By the source’s own measure, Yzerman won that deal by a mile.
The final criticism is more about approach than any single transaction. Yzerman has preferred a slow, steady build, but the NHL has shifted toward a more aggressive model, with teams using trades and offer sheets to speed up the process.
That hasn’t been his style. In another era, that patience might have been praised.
In this one, it has left Detroit stuck in the mushy middle, unable to take the next step.
In Other News...
Red Wings May Have A Familiar Answer For This Crucial Front Office Job
The Red Wings search for a new Director of Hockey Operations has naturally turned into a familiar kind of conversation around the organization: who knows the franchise, who can help shape the next phase, and who has the front-office chops to handle a job that matters more than it might sound at first glance. Among the names circulating, Ryan Martin stands out as someone with real Detroit roots and a long track record in hockey operations, which gives the discussion a different feel than the usual round of outside candidates.
Martins appeal comes from more than just familiarity. He spent 16 years in Detroits front office and built a reputation around contract work and talent evaluation, the sort of background that can translate well in an interview room if the club wants a modern voice who already understands the pressure points of the job. Brendan Shanahan, Shawn Horcoff and Kris Draper are also part of the broader fan conversation, but the Red Wings next move will say plenty about whether they want a fresh perspective, a trusted name, or some blend of both. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Fans May Never Stop Debating This Yzerman Draft Move
Steve Yzerman has never shied away from a bold draft night move, and the 2021 NHL Draft gave Red Wings fans one of the clearest examples yet. Detroit traded up to take Sebastian Cossa with the 15th overall pick, betting on the towering goalie after a standout season in Edmonton and making him the centerpiece of a decision that immediately became part of the organizations long-running draft debate.
The cost of that move still lingers in the background, because Detroit sent the 23rd, 48th and 138th picks to Dallas to climb the board. For a franchise still trying to sort out its future in net, the gamble was always going to be judged over time, and it remains one of those Yzerman calls that Red Wings followers will keep revisiting every draft season until the picture gets a little clearer. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Cup History Is Suddenly Back In A Strange Spotlight
A strange little piece of Red Wings history has been pulled back into the spotlight after Carolina used all 55 name slots on the Stanley Cup, matching the maximum Detroit reached in 1997-98. That old Red Wings engraving now matters again because it is the last time a team filled the Cup to capacity, a reminder that the trophys surface can become a snapshot not just of champions, but of how a franchise chooses to define its season and its people.
For Detroit fans, the comparison is especially notable because that 1997 engraving included nine members of the Ilitch family, showing the organization was willing to use the full allotment for owners and executives as well as players and hockey staff. The current debate around Carolina has only sharpened attention on the NHLs formal rules for Cup engravings, which spell out who qualifies and how exceptions are handled when a name does not fit the standard criteria. [Read more 🡒]